Quote:
Originally Posted by FarmerHaight
Surrey should have considered the effect sprawling all over the place with a discombobulated grid and lackluster transit would have on traffic flow years ago.
And do his complaints even make sense? You would think that people who normally take the Fraser could divert to the TCH, highway 10, 64th, 88th, or 96th with minimal delays.
|
Complaints make sense if you've ever driven through Surrey on a regular basis during rush hour. It's a nightmare going east-west and even north-south during rush hour. Even with Fraser Highway widened, it can take 10-15 minutes just to cross 152nd on any of 88th, 64th, and 96th. Highway 10 tends to back up as you reach 176th and can do so for multiple km.
Fraser Highway itself will backup often headed eastbound from 176th all the way to up the hill coming down or since your tag says you're in the West End, basically the distance from Stanley Park to just past Burrard Street.
Pressure is pretty big along the routes and shutting down Fraser Highway which they just did effectively for half a year+ a few times with the current widening, will add at least +30 minutes to the average commuter's 1-way commute over normal easy. Adding effectively +1 hour per day to commuters I would call "significant" with no alternatives and no room for any issues on the alternate routes.
1 accident on one of the alternates like 96th or Fraser Highway, or a big accident on SFPR causing people to divert to the Surrey E/W through roads, and you're adding 1-2 hours+. That happened recently SFPR was effectively shut to an accident as I was headed home and I had to divert up along 104th to rejoin HWY 1. My typical 45 minute commute took 3 hours that day.
1 accident.
As for your first comment regarding sprawl, if Surrey and other cities in the suburbs didn't sprawl the last 20 years, we'd have even more of a housing crisis today. I agree that they should have considered the effect from at least a roads perspective but transit is under the Provincial Government and reginal, and most of the Mayors including the past Mayors of Vancouver, Burnaby, and Richmond voted multiple times against any transit expansion in Surrey and beyond. So they can't take all the blame, just some of it regarding major roads networks.
And in general, not exclusive to Surrey, many of the suburbs seem to stuck in the mode of only expanding roads when there is redevelopment so you end up with these patchworks of road expansions and sidewalks that end up going 2 blocks only to stop at a ditch because the next plots of land haven't been built on. The new council in Township of Langley is taking the first steps of the suburb cities/towns to actually stop that ridiculous cycle that has resulted in things like a 4 block stretch of 140th avenue in Surrey going from 2 lanes to 1 lane to 2 lanes and being that way for the past 25 years.
25 years to get rid of that 4 block choke point on a major N/S route??? So yes Surrey does take some blame for sure for crappy road networks I agree there though not all.