Quote:
Originally Posted by WhipperSnapper
That's not just limited to exteriors. The interiors are so off trend. Suburban Halifax looks like London with 6 to 12 storey ugly slabs in parking lots going up everywhere. The interiors of the few models I've seen are on par with the major cities.
|
What are your criteria for buildings being ugly or slabs?
Generally I can't keep track of all the suburban highrises being built around metro Halifax. I find most of them ugly because they have large footprints, very little uniqueness and detailing and a very simple exterior appearance, and often don't sit very well on their sites ("plinth" style architecture is common in Halifax when there are elevation changes; build a giant retaining wall or concrete slab to start out with a flat site instead of working with the terrain.. big footprints make this worse). They also tend not to have mixed uses, so even though there might be 12x12 storey buildings in a blob in the suburbs the people in those buildings might have nowhere to walk to.
I don't really get the appeal of them (slightly cheaper, maybe somewhat closer to a desired employment area) but then again they also don't seem worth getting too upset over and I think the quality is trending upward. Often the response to buildings on here is a bit weird because it's devoid of context. People don't know where something fits in in the metro area or what the historic norms are. There's a huge difference between a site in a key area and one out in an office park somewhere.
In the city I tend to like the smaller projects with narrow lot frontage and more detail, and there are quite a few nice ones. There are also some decent larger ones. You can often tell what will be good or bad based on the local developers involved. Architects have some impact too but often the quality seems dictated by the developer/budget. I think some of the architects that have done "ugly" projects just took on lower end ones. Many architects have a wide variety of quality levels while the developers tend to evolve slowly.