Quote:
Originally Posted by Acajack
Why would Résidences Soleil never be allowed in Calgary? Generally speaking, the city development approvals process doesn't take aesthetics into account unless it's a historic district with a specific look that has to be preserved. Am I not right?
|
There is a design committee at least for the Beltline that would likely make recommendations for changes. Nothing's binding but the city usually takes their opinion into consideration. I mean if some crazy developer was hellbent on building a Laval-like monstrosity technically I guess they could. But for a few reasons I will elaborate on, I don't think they would.
Calgary isn't free from hokey, faux historic design but it tends to look different. An example of a recent eye gouger from the Beltline is this building that houses the Pint pub. Our own miniature clocktower, though much less elaborate.
In general though our buildings that harken back to historical 'styles' tend to fit into the theme we in Calgary call Stampitecture. The reason we call it that is in the early 00's the city had a misguided policy requiring new towers being built near the Stampede grounds to incorporate red brick or sandstone like materials into their podiums to blend in with a few remaining 100 year old warehouses nearby. It was called the warehouse district. The results were ghastly. This style also tends to be the go-to theme for the Stampede. It's like a fake western version of Laval's fake French mansard roofed, village clock tower, commie block.
This would be our version of the Residences Soleil. Vantage Pointe with an e at the end to be pretentious and because the developer was called Pointe of View. Note the red brick podium. It is not near the Stampede or even required to have this red brick but jumped on the red brick bandwagon at the time and that's why you get all these useless bricked arches.
It's fat and ugly but for totally different reasons. It's early 2000's Pomo and it dominates the west side of the Beltline like no other building.
There is however one example of a building that went up within the last 10 years that had a mansard roof and was also geared towards old people (though not a retirement home like Residences Soleil). These twin towers perch atop a mall in NW Calgary that is home to the biggest old people Mecca in the city (Northhill SEARS). If it mated with the other two examples above you might get a Laval Clocktower.
Thankfully design has moved leaps and bounds ahead in this city in the last 10 years. It's not even that one couldn't build the Clocktower of Doom. It's that it wouldn't be proposed in the first place because everyone in the field has upped their game to a different level.