Quote:
Originally Posted by CoR East
|
The design looks really lackluster compared to Douglas, Arcola and Seven Stones. There is something bland about it. The view from the North, fronting 13th lacks something. It needs texture or something. It's just a blank box. And this is coming from someone who loves modern architecture and supported Connaught's demolition. The position of the gym, while maybe advantageous for events, completely limits the design.
Additionally, putting the parking fronting 13th is just offensive. A proper street frontage should be encouraged to continue west into the future. Having 35 cars parked directly off 13th is absolutely horrific. The rendering of this view is completely disingenuous considering during the day will be a bunch of vehicles and ugly as hell.
The main problem is that the school board keeps on insisting on doing these open concept schools with "commons" which simply a terrible idea. Students learn worse, teachers hate it and it wastes space. It's completely analogous to the office trend where open and collaborate offices are the new thing. But they're terrible for almost everything except businesses being able to create more density and spend less money. As far as I can tell this design has very few actual classroom spaces. Maybe 14 depending how you count. There should be enough classrooms for 2 of each grade. But it's OK the School Board and the Fielding Nair are having fun, and that's all that matters.
We can have modern architecture without having modern, unproven educational models.