Quote:
Originally Posted by Vin
That's why the City has been failing to create any new retail hubs except for Cambie and Broadway: too many preplanned neighbourhoods which don't support any interesting organic growth of retail. One-street retail will never create a vibrant neighbourhood. Retail centres should be spanning across multiple streets.
Something exciting should be an anchor built on that empty lot beside Mc Donald's.
From the postings of some forumers, one can see that this city has indeed stifled the imaginations of how neighbourhoods can be vibrant.
|
You have to plant healthy appleseeds before you can have a thriving wild orchard.
I think the city's plan of starting neighbourhoods works very well in a part of the world where the population is still so small. 640,000 people (Vancouver) is not that much, over the geographical area it covers. If you want a neighbourhood to appear, first you need population, then you need population density. Much of this city still lacks population
density, so good luck with thriving retail neighbourhoods organically popping-up overnight.
Any of the other cities that you and others mention on here have enough people to support random retail districts. But for a few specific neighbourhoods in this city (the West End comes to mind), that can't yet happen because there's not enough, to be blunt, consumers within a walking distance to support them...yet.
So the city's approach of seeding specific neighbourhoods to encourage a focus of retail (and equally as important, to discourage retail from popping-up in places that will discourage the success of their seeded neighbourhoods) makes a lot of sense. Once these succeed, and we get enough people living here to warrant it, the hard zoning rules could be relaxed.