Muni airport hardwired into Edmonton's civic consciousness
But new generation looks ahead and sees 600 acres of opportunity
Scott Mckeen
Edmonton Journal
Wednesday, June 24, 2009
The Muni airport is steeped in civic legend and lore, romance and adventure.
Personal memories of the Muni are potent: Of joy and tears, reunions and farewells, first flights and doomed flights.
The Muni is hardwired into our civic consciousness, along with things like our weird traffic circles, our nuts-and-bolts High Level Bridge and our glass pyramid fetish.
The Muni is integral to countless personal histories; central to many Edmontonians' sense of community.
No wonder, then, the outcry. How dare city council consider closing the Muni?How dare media pundits encourage it?
They dare, I suppose, because times change. So do values. Romance, like youth, is fleeting. The new generation is not the Muni generation.
The new generation, with fewer memories, looks ahead and sees 600 acres of opportunity. It sees high-density, environmentally sustainable urban development and an antidote to urban sprawl.
At 9:30 this morning, public hearings on the future of the City Centre Airport begin in council chambers. A crowd will come. Temporary seating and closed-circuit television will handle the overflow from council chambers.
Council will hear from speaker after speaker who with fear, fury and tears will demand the Muni be saved. It will not be easy to watch.
But neither rage nor grief make for good policy. Facts are the thing. But as I've said before, facts are up for grabs. Facts collide. Facts argue with other facts.
A fact will flourish, or not, depending on how it resonates with the adjudicator. For example, some people accept as fact that the Muni is our true gateway to the north.
They accept as fact that northerners rely on the Muni for medical, business and leisure travel into Edmonton.
Is that a fact?Or a myth?
A report released last week revealed that medevacs from the north can be safely relocated to the International Airport. Yes, delays might occur.
Medical transfer times can be shortened at the front end. And if need be, helicopters can transfer the sickest patients from the International to an Edmonton hospital.
But the gateway is more than just about medevacs, right?Northerners fly into the Muni. They use the Muni to fly back home.
Yes, they do. But not in numbers you'd expect. First off, almost three out of every four Muni flights in 2008 were unrelated in any way to the north.
Out-and-back training flights by student pilots are the most common trip, making up 41 per cent of air traffic at the Muni.
Yes, the next most common outbound flight was to Fort McMurray. But close behind was Calgary.
But the fact is, all those numbers represent a fraction of the air traffic between Edmonton and northern towns and cities.
In 2008, only 15 per cent of all the passenger seats on inbound northern flights landed at the Muni. The balance, 85 per cent, landed at the International.
Those figures are roughly the same for flights to the north from each of the airports. Simply put, the International is the north's preferred airport.
The 1995 referendum and consolidation of scheduled service to the International will be blamed for the Muni's paltry amount of northern air traffic.
But consolidation is no longer up for debate. It is a fact, bound in legal contracts and potential liabilities.
Yet it is also a fact that some aviation businesses will be harmed by the Muni's closure.
It is a fact that some private plane owners will have to relocate to other airports. It is a fact that student pilots will have to drive out of town for flying lessons.
Those facts must be heard and considered, as well. The facts and arguments brought by the pro-Muni forces in coming days will stimulate the debate.
At the same time, they will make council's decision that much more difficult.
That this council has dared to rule on the future of Muni is a sign of generations rising and falling. Previous councils dared not. But it is a new day. A new council. And in truth, there is a new gateway to the north.
It's called the Edmonton International Airport.
© The Edmonton Journal 2009
Copyright © 2009 CanWest Interactive, a division of CanWest MediaWorks Publications, Inc.. All rights reserved.
CanWest Interactive, a division of CanWest MediaWorks Publications, Inc.. All rights reserved.
http://www2.canada.com/components/print.aspx?id=3d5a7394-1e47-4f77-b08c-7bc7f09f4a86&sponsor=