TORONTO - Transit Developments


So because its 2x as big the transit should be 6x. Seems off to me, maybe it should be 2x as big as well, shows how lacking TO really is.

You lost my point about half the directions from downtown Toronto is a body of water, Paris has rail lines extending out in all directions because it isn't situated next to a body of water. That's one of the major reason why it's metro rail lines are 6 times longer. It's more than just population differences.
 
The main point is about the method of financing and faster to getting the tunneling done faster to get to the finished product faster and therefore the payback faster especially if some of the loan was borrowed against future revenue projections.
 
You lost my point about half the directions from downtown Toronto is a body of water, Paris has rail lines extending out in all directions because it isn't situated next to a body of water. That's one of the major reason why it's metro rail lines are 6 times longer. It's more than just population differences.

But that's not really the case. With all else being equal, if there were two cities of equal size and one had populated areas radiating 180 degrees from a central point and the other extending 360 degrees, the one extending out 180 degrees would either be more densely built by cramming the same number of people onto 1/2 the land available within the same distance of the central city (meaning that it would require a much higher density of rail lines to serve the area), or the cities would have the same density meaning the 180 degree city would need to have its rail lines extend much farther from the center, say 20km in one direction from downtown rather than 10km in opposite directions.

Yes, there are variables that would affect how long the network needs to be, but they're mainly related to capacity rather than the orientation of the built form. For instance, if one city had mostly smaller, lighter rail services (shorter and/or narrower trains) than it would need more of these services to serve the same number of people. One city could have two equal length rail lines that each can handle 25,000 pphpd while another could have 3 lighter lines of the same length that each can handle 15,000 pphpd. People may comment of the first city's relative lack of system length since the second city's is 50% longer, but such criticism may not be entirely fair.

There also the factor of some cities having somewhat hybrid systems that are more of a crossover between metro and commuter rail with a long network extending far from the city center mainly on the surface with lower frequency that regular metro and greater frequency than typical commuter rail. This often allows such cities to have more impressive sounding system statistics.

In the case of Toronto and Paris, obviously Toronto is much less densely populated so it would not be as well served by a Paris Metro type system as it would by a greater amount of BART/RER/S-Bahn/S-tog type services. Paris has a wealth of both and far ahead of Toronto at the moment even though Toronto could have built a 150-200km metro grade BART/S-tog style system to supplement the subway that would be appropriate for both its lower density and its lakeside orientation. This isn't something that can be explained away, it is simply a lack of transit infrastructure investment. There are other cities that have done poorer, but I'm not sure that not being one of the worse is really something an ambitious, up-and-coming city should be aiming for. It's goal should be to be among the best.
 
^ Toronto has it easy too because all GO trains feed into Union Station and Union is a through station. An S-bahn could be set up with zero tunnelling and merely some station/track upgrades.
 
^ Toronto has it easy too because all GO trains feed into Union Station and Union is a through station. An S-bahn could be set up with zero tunnelling and merely some station/track upgrades.

Except GO is probably the most commuter-oriented among major commuter railroad operators: nearly every station has hundreds, sometimes thousands of free parking spaces, adding up to something like 65,000 parking spaces system-wide or 0.7 parking spaces per daily rider. Of course commuter rail will generally have substantial parking facilities but GO's dramatic orientation around car parks basically makes the system co-dependent upon it.

Other than Lakeshore lines it's hard to see how the system gets from the present state to one of cost-effective frequent off-peak regional rail service without dramatic shifts in land use, operating strategy, and politics (though the first two are arguably merely an expression of the latter).
 
My understanding is that many stations are located in industrial or office-park areas that are good candidates for TOD, and local governments are pursuing this aggressively. Toronto's never had the same opposition to suburban density that we see in the States, and even highrises are a common part of the suburban Toronto landscape and have been for decades.

You're right that Paris tends to derive ridership from suburban town centers with high density, both old and new master-planned ones, which Toronto doesn't have to the same extent along its legacy rail lines. But they seem to have a tremendous willingness to adapt land uses to support transit, so 10-20 years of strong growth may very well create the ridership base for all-day two-way service on GO. You can't say that about the piddly little apartment projects in Chicago's railroad suburbs, which are unlikely to make much of a difference for Metra unless they jump up in scale dramatically.
 
Except GO is probably the most commuter-oriented among major commuter railroad operators: nearly every station has hundreds, sometimes thousands of free parking spaces, adding up to something like 65,000 parking spaces system-wide or 0.7 parking spaces per daily rider. Of course commuter rail will generally have substantial parking facilities but GO's dramatic orientation around car parks basically makes the system co-dependent upon it.

Other than Lakeshore lines it's hard to see how the system gets from the present state to one of cost-effective frequent off-peak regional rail service without dramatic shifts in land use, operating strategy, and politics (though the first two are arguably merely an expression of the latter).

Many of the stations though have massive parking garages under construction. They will soon have even more parking spaces than they have now, on a fraction of the land. This along will open up tonnes of land for development. No other dramatic shift in land use will be needed other than what's already happening (and almost finished).

Pickering:

pickering-go-station-parking-garage-01.jpg


New pedestrian bridge at Pickering:

go-pickering00sr5.JPG


Ajax:

110.jpg


Oakville:

7088059015_bd83e6965e_z.jpg


go-oakville00sr99.jpg


Clarkson:

clarkson-go-station-multi-level-parking-structure-01.jpg


Erindale:

erindale_aug_2012.jpg


6054155998_6a1ce32237_z.jpg
 
Last edited:
Those parking lots are insane (in a good way), are the indoor multi-level parking lots free as well or is there a fee to park?
 
I don't understand GO's obsession with parking. There is substantial local bus transit in the 905, especially in Mississauga and Brampton, yet GO acts like the buses doesn't exist. Furthermore, most GO Train stations are located in the middle of nowhere to maximise parking space, at the expense of transit, biking, and pedestrian connections. And now they're spending hundreds of millions of dollars to build giant parking garages that dominate the suburban landscape. As if the traffic congestion near GO stations wasn't bad enough.

GO Transit is more pro-car and pro-sprawl than Wendell Cox is pro-car and pro-sprawl. It's ridiculous. The GO Trains will never have the ridership to support 30 minute all-day service if GO continues only caters to motorists. But I guess GO doesn't really care about 30 minute all-day service to begin with.
 
GO Transit is more pro-car and pro-sprawl than Wendell Cox is pro-car and pro-sprawl. It's ridiculous. The GO Trains will never have the ridership to support 30 minute all-day service if GO continues only caters to motorists.

Said more emphatically than I said it, but yes, this. GO's car-centric orientation is not an accident; it's a reflection politically of what the suburban residents who use it and control its oversight want it to be. I seem to recall (though I don't have a source handy) that even suburban Paris has a household auto ownership rate less than 60%, a rate more comparable to the more transit-oriented inner city areas of North America. Put another way, the RER exists in a dramatically different context than GO, and those difference extends beyond mere zoning issues.

As to whether to encourage more high-density residential or commercial uses near GO stations ... is that actually preferable for the GTA compared with focusing such land uses around non-core TTC stations instead, where significant excess transit capacity exists (due to the service volume meeting the peak demand south of B-Y)?
 
These parking garages are opening up many acres for walkable development adjacent. The Oakville station area alone will have upwards of 5500 condos:

4253881337_b75e8581fd.jpg
 
Said more emphatically than I said it, but yes, this. GO's car-centric orientation is not an accident; it's a reflection politically of what the suburban residents who use it and control its oversight want it to be.

I seem to recall (though I don't have a source handy) that even suburban Paris has a household auto ownership rate less than 60%, a rate more comparable to the more transit-oriented inner city areas of North America. Put another way, the RER exists in a dramatically different context than GO, and those difference extends beyond mere zoning issues.

I think you overstate car-orientedness of the 905. GO ridership far exceeds the amount of parking space it has. GO has (or will have) 61,000 parking spaces, so roughly only 60% of GO riders (~250,000 boardings = ~100k unique riders?) park-and-ride, assuming that 100% of the parking space is used.

You can look more specifically, like Oakville GO sees 13,100 "passengers" per weekday. Divide that in two, that's 6,550 boardings in one direction (approx 5000 unique riders), for 2,724 parking spaces, despite GO's staunch pro-car and anti-urban policies. And Oakville Transit has nowhere near the ridership that MiWay (aka Mississauga Transit) and Brampton Transit does.

And speaking of MiWay and Brampton Transit, I think if look at these systems, GO Transit policies really are not as reflective of 905 attitudes as you suggest. Consider the ridership of the local (bus) transit systems in the 905:

MiWay: ~180k boardings per weekday
Brampton Transit: ~100k
York Region Transit: ~120k
Durham Region Transit: ~35k
Oakville and Burlington Transit: ~10k each

that's around ~450k weekday boardings compared to ~250k for GO Transit. So to use GO as indicator for attitudes in the 905 is problematic, since GO is a niche system, even more niche than local transit in the 905, let alone the TTC. Local transit is more important to 905ers than GO Transit is. It also goes to show that if GO continues to be deliberately exclusionary and elitist, they will never be mainstream enough for 30 minute all-day service.

I guess they can keep building parking to the heavens, but there is a limit to how many cars can fit on the roads surrounding the stations, and those cars will get in the way of pedestrians, cyclists and local transit riders (~40% of GO ridership, remember). So I think there is diminishing returns there.

As to whether to encourage more high-density residential or commercial uses near GO stations ... is that actually preferable for the GTA compared with focusing such land uses around non-core TTC stations instead, where significant excess transit capacity exists (due to the service volume meeting the peak demand south of B-Y)?

I don't think any part of the TTC has "significant excess transit capacity". The City of Toronto isn't exactly lacking in demand for high density right now either, so I don't see how what limiting high density development in the 905 will accomplish. For the GO Trains to be truly successful and efficient, the trains need to be full in both directions, instead of just one direction.
 
Last edited:
I don't understand GO's obsession with parking. There is substantial local bus transit in the 905, especially in Mississauga and Brampton, yet GO acts like the buses doesn't exist. Furthermore, most GO Train stations are located in the middle of nowhere to maximise parking space, at the expense of transit, biking, and pedestrian connections. And now they're spending hundreds of millions of dollars to build giant parking garages that dominate the suburban landscape. As if the traffic congestion near GO stations wasn't bad enough.

GO Transit is more pro-car and pro-sprawl than Wendell Cox is pro-car and pro-sprawl. It's ridiculous. The GO Trains will never have the ridership to support 30 minute all-day service if GO continues only caters to motorists. But I guess GO doesn't really care about 30 minute all-day service to begin with.


Outside of of the Lakeshore lines Milton and Markham probably not.
 
Last edited:
As to whether to encourage more high-density residential or commercial uses near GO stations ... is that actually preferable for the GTA compared with focusing such land uses around non-core TTC stations instead, where significant excess transit capacity exists (due to the service volume meeting the peak demand south of B-Y)?

Why not both/and? Even many of the single-family home developments in suburban Toronto exist at a density only found in US' inner cities, so there's an innate tolerance for density that is well beyond what we see in America, even if it's not at Parisian levels. There's nothing that tells me Torontonians can't prepare zoning and plans for an array of dense new town centres around both GO stations and TTC stations. That seems preferable to high-rise development in places like Mississauga with no convenient rail transit access (this particular planning blunder has necessitated a new $1.6bn LRT line).
 
No, the Hurontario LRT line is not "necessitated" due to a "planning blunder". Hurontario is Peel Region's main spine, so it should have an LRT line whether or not there is high-rise developments in places like Square One. Even if none of the dozens of condo towers around Square One were ever built, Hurontario should have some sort of higher-order transit simply because it is such a major spine.
 
I honestly don't understand how a chronically overcrowded post-war, exurban/suburban local bus corridor with 4 minute bus service all day (Hurontario Street) can be considered a planning failure.

Do people really think that suburbs should be pure bedroom communities that force people to travel long distances by car and/or commuter rail? I don't understand that at all. It goes against all contemporary planning principles of minimizing travel distances and creating live/work communities.

And it's not like there is a lack of density around GO Train stations in Mississauga either (e.g. Cooksville, Clarkson, Port Credit, Erindale all have high-rises built around them), or that the GO Trains in Mississauga are running empty. Lack of ridership and density is not what's holding back all-day 30 minute service for the Milton Line.

For suburbs to be sustainable, they need to be built like inner cities, and that means having transit systems similar to inner cities: e.g. 4 minute bus services all day and $1.6 billion dollar light rail lines.
 
I honestly don't understand how a chronically overcrowded post-war, exurban/suburban local bus corridor with 4 minute bus service all day (Hurontario Street) can be considered a planning failure.

It's not. He has no clue what he's talking about. The Hurontario corridor and MCC area is actually very successful planning-wise. The newer stuff west of Square One in particular is urbanistically perfect.
 
Last edited:
It's not. He has no clue what he's talking about. The Hurontario corridor and MCC area is actually very successful planning-wise. The newer stuff west of Square One in particular is urbanistically perfect.

C'mon dude, that's harsh. There is obviously merit in the idea of increasing density around GO stations, especially if they get more service. But local transit, cycling, pedestrian trips shouldn't be neglected either (and even in that respect I wouldn't call Hurontario or MCC a success yet either).

Maybe the isolation of certain GO stations can be attributed to the failers of local planners, but I don't think that's the case in Mississauga. A lot of the GO stations in Mississauga have high density around them and they are well-integrated into the surroundings.

I think in a lot of cases it is GO's fault the stations are isolated and surrounded by low density. Look at where the Burlington or Bronte or Oshawa stations are located for example. The local municipalities don't have a lot to work with.

I actually think the Hurontario LRT will be a great benefit to GO and its riders when it is built. It will connect with 3 different GO Train lines, and eith a forecast ridership of over 100,000 boardings per weekday, I think it will add more even more pressure for improved GO Train service, not less pressure (seriously, this will be one the busiest LRT lines in North America, think about that).
 
It's not. He has no clue what he's talking about. The Hurontario corridor and MCC area is actually very successful planning-wise. The newer stuff west of Square One in particular is urbanistically perfect.

I concede that planners don't have total control over what gets built where; political and voter concerns often dominate. But if you want to have high density in the suburbs, it should be placed by high capacity transportation lines, right?

The Mississauga "downtown" is where it is because of the 403 and Square One. The bus route may be successful (it's great that residents are using transit) but it's far from ideal. The good planning of the newer buildings doesn't make up for the fact that the most convenient option for residents is the freeway.

Toronto's far better than US cities but this just demonstrates a shared problem in the Anglosphere: land use and transit don't align and so both underperform. As a result there is a need to extend transit lines into developed areas at great financial cost, or to redevelop areas around transit with higher densities at great political cost.
 


Back
Top