TORONTO - Transit Developments


Canada isn't Europe or the USA, but is more alike the USA than Europe. Many Eurpean countries have taxes collected only at the national level, so sharing subidies (not revenues) between different train systems is possible. The USA and Canada have taxes collected and funds allocated by many different levels of government, so sharing operating subsidies between them is very difficult. It's difficult enough just to establish formulas for funding capital projects. VIA is subsidized by the national government, GO by Ontario, and TCC by Toronto.

The idea that buying a single seat ride on a TCC streetcar ticket with a small fare will be allowed for riding a higher fare VIA train seems ridiculous. Who would ever pay the higher fare when they can ride with the lower fare?

The GTA has smart cards. With the advantage of smart cards you can start to make the charges you pay more tightly related to the distance you travel. Get on a street care in Toronto and hop off down the road and you get charged very little; travel to a far away suburb you should be paying quite a bit more.

If I travel from Union Station to Oakville on Via Rail, Amtrak, Go Transit or some combination of street care and bus; why should it cost any more or less because of the operator. If you strategically locate gates at the correct places you can figure out how to divide up the fare between the various operators.

I am more familiar with Vancouver than Toronto (though I have traveled in the GTA a bit). In Vancouver, the skytrain capital costs are funded through a combination of Federal, Provincial and Municipal governments (coming from the same tax payers). I don't think Toronto is that much different. All the local infrastructure is build through joint funding with higher levels of government.

More realistically it is Metrolinx owning Go Transit and providing substantial funding for TCC expansion projects.
 
In almost every European case, there is a central-city zone where flat fares apply for all means of transport (transfers not always free). Outside of that zone, fares begin to increase in relation to distance, just like American commuter rail.
Our traveler's experience isn't markedly better than if he took the subway - except he gets there faster.

Again, you have completely overlooked how each train system is subsidized, and where the taxes to do so come from. Canada isn't Germany! Not all funds are allocated by the national government. The subsidy % for VIA is less than GO, which is less than TCC. At best you'll see the ability to purchase different fares for different trains at one location.
An example will be DART, TRE, and DCTA arrangement for combined fares in Dallas.
Your $2 DART fare allows you to ride a DART train and bus system within 2 hours. A local daily $4 fare allows you to do so all day. There's a similar local fare structure for the two commuter rail trains, TRE and DCTA. But all three agencies sell regional fares, where you can ride throughout the region - but the daily fare is now $8; $4 for DART and $4 for TRE or DCTA. You might as well buy the tickets separately, the only advantage you get with the regional fare is having to buy tickets once. Note: Amtrak isn't included with the single ticket ride.

The ride you receive on the different trains is far more different than just elapse time. During the morning and evening rushes, more than 50% of the streetcar and light rail riders are standing, less than 50% of the commuter train riders are standing, and 0% of the intercity trains are standing. Your average streetcar passengers ride the tram a mile or two, commuter train passengers ride the train 10 to 20 miles, and intercity train passengers ride the train 100 to 200 miles. Few passengers are willing to stand 100 to 200 miles on an intercity train, most are willing to stand a mile or two on a streetcar. So there are far different accommodations aboard the different trains.
 
Canada isn't Europe or the USA, but is more alike the USA than Europe.

This kind of thinking will get us nowhere. If there are better ways of doing things in other cities, what continents those cities are on doesn't matter. Besides, we don't even have to look to other countries to see how it can be done - just look at Vancouver or even Durham and York Regions outside Toronto. Fare integration and beefing up GO service could completely transform the way we get around the GTA.
 
The ride you receive on the different trains is far more different than just elapse time. During the morning and evening rushes, more than 50% of the streetcar and light rail riders are standing, less than 50% of the commuter train riders are standing, and 0% of the intercity trains are standing. Your average streetcar passengers ride the tram a mile or two, commuter train passengers ride the train 10 to 20 miles, and intercity train passengers ride the train 100 to 200 miles. Few passengers are willing to stand 100 to 200 miles on an intercity train, most are willing to stand a mile or two on a streetcar. So there are far different accommodations aboard the different trains.
But the train would only be standing-room only for the short distance while it passed through the dense urban and suburban areas. Many people would disembark before it continued onto the rest of the 10-20 mile or 100-200 mile journey. So whether or not people would be willing to stand up for the longer distance is irrelevant.
 
This kind of thinking will get us nowhere. If there are better ways of doing things in other cities, what continents those cities are on doesn't matter. Besides, we don't even have to look to other countries to see how it can be done - just look at Vancouver or even Durham and York Regions outside Toronto. Fare integration and beefing up GO service could completely transform the way we get around the GTA.

Again, you have completely ignored know these trains are funded, subsidized, and taxed. It's not geographic, it's how the different trains are funded, and where those funds are allocated. The funding is not coming from the same pie in Canada as they are in Europe.
European government subsidized programs are based upon all the taxes and money coming from one national fund, the crown where still appropriate. Canada and America have local taxes, providence or state taxes, and national taxes - each taxing authority allocating its taxes as it sees fit. There are revenue sharing mechanisms where funding is shared between various levels of government for many programs and entitlements. Never-the-less, the money exists and is allocated from different pies.
 
But the train would only be standing-room only for the short distance while it passed through the dense urban and suburban areas. Many people would disembark before it continued onto the rest of the 10-20 mile or 100-200 mile journey. So whether or not people would be willing to stand up for the longer distance is irrelevant.

And who would be the ones standing, those who paid $50 fare or those who paid $2 fare? No one paying $50 would want to stand when they paid to sit. Besides, most intercity trains are already full when approaching major cities where there might be a local train system.
 
Toronto is unique, in a bad way, in that buying a commuter rail ticket doesn't get you a discount on the standard transit and vise-versa. It is a truly bizzare situation.

Fare integration is a complete essential if GO is ever to become a truly viable alternative for Toronto city dwellers. In the last city election the other main candidate { who I cannot remember the name} put forward the idea that the TTC pass should allow a person to travel one free station ie Union to Bloor West.

Although the idea of one station was idiotic, the idea of using a TTC pass for GO was a good one. What the TTC could so is introduce a "Super-Metropass" which would allow travel on all GO routes {bus and rail} in the city for the cost of a regular ticket plus a small amount ie $1. They could sell a similar Super-Metropass for an additional $10/month on top of the standard monthly Metropass.

It would bring in extra revenue which could be forwarded to GO to make up for their lost revenue inside the city itself and is fair as GO is for more long distance service and so charges more for longer trips without penalizing those who don't need the service.
 
Again, you have completely ignored know these trains are funded, subsidized, and taxed. It's not geographic, it's how the different trains are funded, and where those funds are allocated. The funding is not coming from the same pie in Canada as they are in Europe.
European government subsidized programs are based upon all the taxes and money coming from one national fund, the crown where still appropriate. Canada and America have local taxes, providence or state taxes, and national taxes - each taxing authority allocating its taxes as it sees fit. There are revenue sharing mechanisms where funding is shared between various levels of government for many programs and entitlements. Never-the-less, the money exists and is allocated from different pies.

None of what you're saying prevents proper fare integration in Toronto or any other North American city. Where the funding comes from isn't some insurmountable hurdle. It's already happening in some cities and in certain Toronto suburbs.
 
It is good news that GO is greatly increasing frequency, I don't think most Torontonians themselves will even, except for the pollution and noise, notice. GO is very much a 905 service and relatively few people in the city itself take it and much of this is because it is damn expensive and many figure that the shorter distances they travel, it really isn't worth it.
.

Case in point: a former coworker of mine lived right next to Milliken station in north Scarborough, but still took the TTC to work downtown even though it took her well over an hour (plus 2 transfers) each way.

That being said, distance-based fares within the city of Toronto are a complicated issue because the areas furthest from downtown (NW Etobicoke/North York and NE Scarborough) are also the poorest areas. Many residents in these areas have no choice but to take transit to work and do not have the option of moving somewehre more central. It doesn't seem fair if they have to pay a higher fare reflecting their greater distance from downtown when the reason they live so far is because that's all they can afford.
 
Brampton keeps doing great. This map shows routes in the 905 which operate every 30 minutes or less seven days a week. Generally until midnight Mon-Fri, and until at least 10-11 pm on Sundays. Brampton has more routes providing this type of service than the rest of the 905 combined. Brampton is doing an outstanding job.

https://maps.google.ca/maps/ms?msid=212278035587262346137.0004daa9ceb7250f1eeb8&msa=0

Wow, I had no idea transit frequencies were this terrible throughout the 905. Small cities like Guelph do soooo much better. I know it's a university town with a good number of elderly people, but still.
 
And who would be the ones standing, those who paid $50 fare or those who paid $2 fare? No one paying $50 would want to stand when they paid to sit. Besides, most intercity trains are already full when approaching major cities where there might be a local train system.

That wouldn't really be relevant since standing would be such a short distance. I can hardly see anyone complaining that they had to stand for a couple of miles on a 200 mile trip. Especially when having dozens of people paying a $2 fare to go a short distance without the training needing to add extra capacity would mean more money available for service enhancements that could benefit everyone.
 
Wow, I had no idea transit frequencies were this terrible throughout the 905. Small cities like Guelph do soooo much better. I know it's a university town with a good number of elderly people, but still.

Miketoronto's just spewing his usual anti-905 BS.

For example, the combined weekday local and express bus service for Hurontario Street south of Square One in Mississauga has an average frequency of 3.9 minutes during rush hour, 4.2 minutes during the midday, and 6.0 minutes in the evening (6-10pm), but according to Miketoronto's arbitrary criteria it is merely a corridor with "30 minute or better" service.
 
Miketoronto's just spewing his usual anti-905 BS.

For example, the combined weekday local and express bus service for Hurontario Street south of Square One in Mississauga has an average frequency of 3.9 minutes during rush hour, 4.2 minutes during the midday, and 6.0 minutes in the evening (6-10pm), but according to Miketoronto's arbitrary criteria it is merely a corridor with "30 minute or better" service.

Doady. If you read the requirements for the map, it is based on the max frequency you will wait at night in off hours.

The fact is that on Hurontario at night, particulary on weekends, you could have to wait up to 30 minutes south of Square One. So that is why it is listed like that.
If Mississauga Transit provided as good frequency as Brampton does, then it would be represented. But the fact is, Hurontario on the Mississauga strech does not receive frequent service at all times.

So don't yell at me. Yell at Mississauga Transit for providing such dismal off peak service levels.

This is about people being able to rely on transit as their primary mode of transport. And to do that, we require frequent service. And the fact is, that if the service dips down to 30 minute levels, then it is going to be represented.

Sunday service after 9pm is every 24-26 minutes on Hurontario in Mississauga.
 
Case in point: a former coworker of mine lived right next to Milliken station in north Scarborough, but still took the TTC to work downtown even though it took her well over an hour (plus 2 transfers) each way.

That being said, distance-based fares within the city of Toronto are a complicated issue because the areas furthest from downtown (NW Etobicoke/North York and NE Scarborough) are also the poorest areas. Many residents in these areas have no choice but to take transit to work and do not have the option of moving somewehre more central. It doesn't seem fair if they have to pay a higher fare reflecting their greater distance from downtown when the reason they live so far is because that's all they can afford.

I appreciate what you are saying but their transit fares would not go up. They would still have the option of taking the standard TTC. If the extra amount is kept reasonable ie $0.50 to $1 per ticket or $10 to $20/ month, it would still be far,far cheaper than current GO fares.

Right now GO is a very expensive system and this explains why relatively few Torontonians take it. Imagine if all of a subben the people in Malvern, Humber, or Miminco could get downtown twice as atleast twice as fast as they are now but at the same fare or slightly more. Transit ridership on GO would soar and it would do wonders for the travelling public.
 
Wow, I had no idea transit frequencies were this terrible throughout the 905. Small cities like Guelph do soooo much better. I know it's a university town with a good number of elderly people, but still.

The map that he posted does not totally reflect the totally random and unpredictable nature of public transit.

There are so many corridors that are more frequent than every 15 minutes during rush hours. Tell me after showing the following exhibit below, Guelph still offers "soooo much better" service than the 905 (especially Peel Region).

Here they are:

Mississauga:
Hurontario: every 2 to 4 minutes at the express stops, every 5 to 6 minutes at the local stops
(Hurontario's local version runs every 5 to 6 minutes during the midday periods. No other route outside of Toronto and Ottawa can beat that. This local route also runs every 8.33 minutes during Saturdays. With overlapping express service, that becomes 6 to 7 minutes south of Rathburn, or 4 to 5 minutes north of Rathburn. Yes, you saw it right! 4 to 5-minute service in the 905 exists on a Saturday afternoon!)
Dundas: every 4 to 5 minutes at the express stops, every 9 minutes at the local stops
(Dundas runs every 6.5 minutes at the busiest segment during Saturdays. Tell me of another route outside of Toronto and Ottawa that have the frequency on Saturdays.)
Eglinton: every 4 to 5 minutes at the express stops, every 6 to 7 minutes at the local stops at the busiest segment
Erin Mills: every 5 to 6 minutes at the express stops, every 9 to minutes at the local stops at the busiest segment
Burnhamthorpe: every 6.5 minutes at the busier segment, every 13 minutes at the less busy segment
Britannia: every 7 to 8 minutes at the express stops at the peak direction
University Express: every 7.5 minutes
Westwood - Humber: every 8 to 9 minutes at the express stops
Dixie: every 9 minutes
Bloor: every 5.5 to 9 minutes
Rathburn: every 9 minutes at the peak direction during the latter half of the PM rush
Colonial loop: combined loops every 10 to 11 minutes, every 14 minutes at one direction
Westwood: every 11 minutes
Tomken: every 12 minutes
McLaughlin: every 13 minutes
Lakeshore: every 13 minutes
Mavis: every 13 minutes
Square One - Finch (GO Transit): every 5 to 15 minutes at the peak direction during AM rush
Square One - York University (GO Transit): every 5 to 10 minutes at the peak direction

Brampton:
Queen: every 4 minutes at the express stops, every 10 minutes at the local stops
Steeles: every 3 - 4 minutes, every 10 minutes at the local stops
Ray Lawson loop: combined loops every 5 to 6 minutes
Main: every 6 to 7 minutes at the express stops
Bovaird: every 7.5 minutes
Dixie: every 7.5 minutes
Kennedy: every 7.5 minutes
Springdale: combined loops every 10 minutes
Torbram: every 10 minutes
Airport: every 10 minutes
Bramalea: every 10 minutes
Chinguacousy: every 7.5 minutes come September
Bramalea - York University (GO Transit): every 10 minutes

York Region:
Highway 7: every 7.5 minutes at the busiest segment
Yonge: every 3 to 4 minutes at the express stops at the busiest segment, every 7 to 8 minutes throughout the entire route
Leslie: every 10 minutes
Bayview: every 10 minutes

Durham Region:
Highway 2: every 7.5 minutes come September
Simcoe: every 7.5 minutes

Yell at Mississauga Transit for providing such dismal off peak service levels.

You can scratch midday service off of that. Throughout the past few years, they have quietly improved their midday services, with many routes running every 20 or less, not mentioning the overlaps. Before, only Hurontario, Dundas, Bloor, Dixie, Finch, and Burnhamthorpe were the only ones that run every 20 minutes or less. Now, they more than doubled that number to 13 routes:
Hurontario: 4 to 5 minutes at express stops, 5 to 6 minutes at local stops
Dundas: 9 minutes
Bloor: 14 minutes
Burnhamthorpe: 15.5 minutes
McLaughlin: 16 minutes
University Express: 17 minutes
Mavis: 18.5 minutes
Malton Express: 18.5 minutes
Lakeshore: 19 minutes
Colonial: 20 minutes
Dixie: 20 minutes
Finch: 20 minutes
Eglinton: 20-22 minutes (10-minute frequency at the west end before noon)

Compare that to Brampton...
Queen: 6 to 7 minutes at express stops, 20 minutes at local stops
Steeles: 7.5 minutes at express stops, 20 minutes at local stops
Main: 8 to 9 minutes at express stops, 20 minutes at local stops
Ray Lawson loop: 8 to 9 minutes
Bramalea: 15 minutes come September
Bovaird: 15 minutes
Dixie: 20 minutes
Kennedy: 20 minutes
Chinguacousy: 20 minutes


-------------------------------------

I gotta admit that Hurontario's buses are very well-used during the evenings, despite its 25-minute frequency, it has around 20+ passengers at the last runs on weekends.

Mississauga may receive 24/7 service soon which makes it the third transit agency in Ontario to have 24/7 service, but frequencies will be around 31-60 minutes (naturally due to very low ridership), so will that imply Mississauga will be totally blank?

I cannot find any reasoning for York Region's dismal services though. I mean, a bus every 120 minutes? You'll never find that in Halton and Peel regions.

When it comes to Brampton vs. Mississauga, it seems that Brampton cares more about service, Mississauga cares more about taxpayers.

Brampton's local buses past 10 PM on Saturdays and past 8 PM on Sundays normally carries around 5 people or less, except for Zum corridors. In Mississauga, you'll see more than 20 people on the bus during those times. Mavis, specifically, has extended service hours to 9 PM, and surprise! The bus carries around 30+ passengers at those extended runs.

So, there you have it.

Mississauga: increases service but when only absolutely needed and invests money to where they can get the maximum possible revenue out of taxpyers' money. When numbers decline below a certain threshold, reduce frequency, realign the route, merge with another route or cancel service altogether.

Brampton: increases service whether there is demand on it or not, as long as it meets certain requirements set by their master plans (frequncy, service hours, area coverage). When numbers decline below a certain threshold, keep the service.

York Region: make the the system the most technologically-advanced in the entire country, but decrease the service in local corridors in exchange of those toys. When numbers decline below a certain threshold, reduce frequency even though it's already running every 75 minutes, or just cancel the route altogether.

Durham Region: implement a route and call it a "BRT" but still stopping at all stops.
 
Last edited:
The map that he posted does not totally reflect the totally random and unpredictable nature of public transit.

No the map shows what I said it shows. And that is where you will never wait more than 30 minutes for a bus. Lots of people travel outside of the peak hours or midday hours.

And it is often these late night and off off peak times when people will decide whether to take transit or not, based on if service is available and convenient.

When it comes to Brampton vs. Mississauga, it seems that Brampton cares more about service, Mississauga cares more about taxpayers.
Brampton's local buses past 10 PM on Saturdays and past 8 PM on Sundays normally carries around 5 people or less, except for Zum corridors. In Mississauga, you'll see more than 20 people on the bus during those times. Mavis, specifically, has extended service hours to 9 PM, and surprise! The bus carries around 30+ passengers at those extended runs.
Ohh please. I will tell you what Brampton cares about. It cares about making transit a viable option and not a last resort. Transit during some periods needs to be provided for the benefit of residents. No based on loads. That is why it is public transit.
I happen to know for a fact that almost all Brampton Transit services meet or exceed minimum cost recovery and ridership targets. In fact many exceed it as Brampton has to continue adding service to handle loads.

Mississauga: increases service but when only absolutely needed and invests money to where they can get the maximum possible revenue out of taxpyers' money. When numbers decline below a certain threshold, reduce frequency, realign the route, merge with another route or cancel service altogether.

Which is why transit will not become a viable option in Mississauga anytime soon. There are entire areas of Mississauga you can't get to in the evening, because transit ends early.

I can not believe someone on this forum would actually being trying to justify the dismal service in Mississauga on a taxpayer excuse.

Brampton: increases service whether there is demand on it or not, as long as it meets certain requirements set by their master plans (frequncy, service hours, area coverage). When numbers decline below a certain threshold, keep the service.

And that is why Brampton is the leader, and will have more success. Brampton Transit is a viable travel alternative to the car now.

Anyone who does transit planning knows that the most important thing is

SUPPLY CREATES DEMAND. As in you put out an attractive service to attract people to your transit system.

Transit systems which CREATE SUPPLY BASED ON DEMAND, often fail.
 
SUPPLY CREATES DEMAND.
Which does not always happen.

For example: 36 Colonial's Sunday service. Their buses used to run every 19 minutes during Sundays for so many years, which made it the third most frequent route in Mississauga on Sundays. But then, the buses kept running empty, so empty that it dropped below the 10 rides per hour threshold and the subsidy was more than $5 per passenger, so they decided to drop it to 38-minute service. Now the subsidy in the route is much less, and is one of the better-performing ones, financially speaking.

Another example: 101 service in Oakville's Uptown terminal. Throughout those two years of the pilot project, their buses used to run ever 20 minutes in that terminal. But at maximum, there were only 5 passengers in a bus, with only one to two people going all the way to Oakville. And the rest of the runs carries 0 to 1 passengers when leaving the terminal. So they decided that it's not worth going to Oakville and ended it at Ridgeway instead, with 24 rerouting to the Uptown terminal some time this year or the next.

Another example: 33 Erin Centre. A very useful local route for the Erin Mills community running every 30 minutes 7 days a week, which offers timed connections with route 34 if they wished to venture further east. Well, what happened, subsidy went to $11 per ride on a typical day. So, obviously, they cancelled it! 33A got replaced with 67 though, and is performing really great after a reminder from MiWay staff at the community meeting that if they don't use it, they will certainly lose it!
 
Toronto is unique, in a bad way, in that buying a commuter rail ticket doesn't get you a discount on the standard transit and vise-versa. It is a truly bizzare situation.

No. Mississauga Transit is only $.60 (as opposed to $3.25) if you show your GO ticket. That's a deep discount.



Fare integration is a complete essential if GO is ever to become a truly viable alternative for Toronto city dwellers. In the last city election the other main candidate { who I cannot remember the name} put forward the idea that the TTC pass should allow a person to travel one free station ie Union to Bloor West.

Although the idea of one station was idiotic, the idea of using a TTC pass for GO was a good one. What the TTC could so is introduce a "Super-Metropass" which would allow travel on all GO routes {bus and rail} in the city for the cost of a regular ticket plus a small amount ie $1. They could sell a similar Super-Metropass for an additional $10/month on top of the standard monthly Metropass.

Whatever they do though would have to be revenue-neutral. There would be no point in giving the riders a better deal if it meant less fare revenue for the agency. And I haven't heard a proposal of how that could be done.
 
No. Mississauga Transit is only $.60 (as opposed to $3.25) if you show your GO ticket. That's a deep discount.





Whatever they do though would have to be revenue-neutral. There would be no point in giving the riders a better deal if it meant less fare revenue for the agency. And I haven't heard a proposal of how that could be done.

The way you make it work is:
1. Have the agencies that operate these systems agree on zones and cost per zone.
2. Passenger swipes their presto card in and out at the end of their journey. Gates may need to be installed.
3. For each swipe in and out you calculate the percentage split between the two agencies involved based on distance traveled for that passenger.
 
When it comes to Brampton vs. Mississauga, it seems that Brampton cares more about service, Mississauga cares more about taxpayers.

Mississauga actually spends more per capita on public transit than Brampton does and MiWay's revenue service hours per capita is significantly higher than that of Brampton Transit.

http://forum.skyscraperpage.com/showthread.php?t=205132

Miketoronto only chooses the data that fits this picture he's trying to draw of Mississauga providing less transit service than Brampton and York Region, but the reality is Mississauga is on a whole other level transit-wise compared to the rest of the 905.

MiWay provides 20% more service per capita and has 40% higher per capita ridership than Brampton Transit. Compared to York Region Transit, MiWay provides 65% more service per capita and has 250% higher per capita ridership. Those are just the facts.

And don't get me started on the fares.
 


Back
Top