LRT Map


I think its confusing to have the bend on the NE lone between Franklin and Barlow instead of between Franklin and Marlbourough, like it is. If people weren't familiar with the system, they might think, "first station after the curve" or something like that, and then miss their station.

Not sure what you mean--the official line map has the turn between Franklin and Marlborough, while the current Wikipedia map has Franklin somewhat less accurately in the middle of the turn. Though realistically, the turisti are in far greater danger of falling prey to operator indifference:

Turist: Izzat dere Pacific Place up bah Mahrl-burra, Ellie-Mae?
Turistka: Shurr is, Jimmy-Bob!
Recording: Bing, boo-oop. Franklin.
Turist: Almost they-ur, Ellie-Mae!
Turistka: But Jimmy-Bob, thuh sigh say-uz--
Driver: Mzzrlbzzrzz Stzztzzn. Mzzrlbzzrzz. Nzzt Frzznklzzn! Mzzrlbzzrzz!
Turist: Cain yuh git the doh-ur, Eliie-Mae?
Turistka: Aww, shucky-darn, Jimmy-Bob! Thuh lai-ut waint out!
Nelson (pointing): Ha-ha!
 
Not sure what you mean--the official line map has the turn between Franklin and Marlborough, while the current Wikipedia map has Franklin somewhat less accurately in the middle of the turn. Though realistically, the turisti are in far greater danger of falling prey to operator indifference:

what I'm saying is, shouldn't the map reflect what is reality? The actual line turns north between Franklin and Marlbourough, shouldn't the map show that?
 
How close can we get? Schematic maps will always have this problem in order to be easy to read. I mean look at the size of downtown on the map. Its huge compared to the others, especially the south.

I can try to move that station, but space is very very limited. I've already blown by original dimmension restrictions several times.

Side-> Heres a more recent working copy of the map. I've tried to add more imprtant bus lines and I'm about halfway through. The shape of the map is not making it easy at all and its looking like a horrible mess (hence I've stopped halfway through).

Calgary%20LRT4.jpg
 
what I'm saying is, shouldn't the map reflect what is reality? The actual line turns north between Franklin and Marlbourough, shouldn't the map show that?

^^^ Ohhh, that map. Whoops. :rolleyes:

Good point on the overall issue of schematics versus maps, though. A map at true scale shrinks the downtown to illegibility, so you would need an inset, whereas a more legible, evenly-spaced schematic...errm...loses the scale.
 
Jeffsey500: Unlike what others may be telling you, I don't think you should worry about the shape of the lines. If they are going in the general direction they should it doesn't really matter. Exaggerate the sizes where it matters but otherwise just try to balance compactness and readability.
 
great map but I wonder if it would be easier reading if the city centre stations had a shape more in tune with an eight (two connected circles common on other maps) with an arrow in each circle
 
90 degrees is still in the "general direction?"

Let me clarify, I'm talking about any changes to the shape of the lines. He could make the lines go straight in their respective directions from Sunnyside and from Bridgeland/Memorial, and it wouldn't make a difference in my interpretation.

My observation of people on the CTrain suggests to me that they care more about the name of the next station and figuring out where it is relation to their destination, and don't read much into the shape of the lines on a schematic.
 
Looking good!

- that font's (on the map itself) more like it! But the Trebuchet on the main title and the Accessibility box, and the remaining Arial "201" and "202" in the legend should be changed to match. Consistency.

- the extra bus routes, where they lead to destinations (like hospitals) look great! Are you planning to add more destinations to the other routes? Otherwise, why are they there? It must be hard to decide on which routes to include... have to balance between being useful and complete, and cluttering the map with unnecessary detail.

The 20/72/73 and 4/5 crossover west of 70 Av Terminal really needs some destination to justify it. (Or do those routes work as express service that extend the CTrain network (like the B-lines in Vancouver)? In which case, including their "stations" would be worthwhile too.)

- the text "City Centre stations are offer travel in one direction only. as shown by arrows." is more confusing than having nothing at all, I think. The simplest way is really just to include the arrows in the legend, and "westbound trains only" / "eastbound trains only". Two arrows over each line within a single circle/ellipse will clearly convey that 1) each stop is really a single station, and 2) both lines service each station.

- "39th Avenue South" should be consistent with the other numbered roads: "39 Avenue South".

- the text "No Charge For Travel Within This Area" should be cleaned up, "No charge for travel within this area". Just type and capitalise as normal writing would. There's A Reason Books And Newspapers That People Have To Read Are Not Written Like This.

- the pictogramme for walking connexions shouldn't be captioned "Bus Connections to Other Services", just the bus graphic.

Save for those details, it's coming together beautifully.

For another perspective, you should consider posting it on the graphic design forum Typophile (either "design" at http://typophile.com/forum/5 or "composition" at http://typophile.com/forum/28). Since they do visual communication with normal people for a living they probably have good feedback on what works and doesn't.
 
great map but I wonder if it would be easier reading if the city centre stations had a shape more in tune with an eight (two connected circles common on other maps) with an arrow in each circle

I believe that this would normally indicate two separate stations on two separate lines that permit a connection between them.

As for the map reflecting the actual physical configuration of the network (when the line turns north, for example), don't bother trying to achieve this. Look at the Tube map for London, and then compare it with a tube map that reflects the true location of lines and stations. The two don't mesh at all, except in the most abstract way. Instead, the topological relationship between different stations, lines, destinations, and possibly landmarks (rivers are common ones) is all that is important.
 
The 20/72/73 and 4/5 crossover west of 70 Av Terminal really needs some destination to justify it. (Or do those routes work as express service that extend the CTrain network (like the B-lines in Vancouver)? In which case, including their "stations" would be worthwhile too.)

The 72/73 are a circle route that run counter to each other and connect to 3 of the LRT stations. 20 runs N-S as a fairly major route (with one of the highest frequencies in the city during rush). They don't really have any other 'stations' beyond the terminals at the LRT stations, and the one additional one at the University. The 20 has a similar terminal at Mount Royal College.

Including them as is works pretty well, the only thing that sticks out to me is how they aren't connected above the legend. Aside from that good work :)
 
Looks like the consensus wants the bus lines. So they will stay. It will take time to get all the things corrected. I know the fonts and some of the sentences are still a mess. They're coming along.

What else should I include? I will add Mount Royal College (but I still need an icon).I'm trying to edge away from shopping malls (too many and not transit friendly).

Are there any major non-LRT station terminals in the south? I rarely ever get down there.

Also, somebody did mention pitching it to transit. But in that case, changes need to happen as the main font that's now used is not licensed for that (I think, correct me if I'm wrong).

Sidenote: YAY! You can draw things into Google Maps now! If there isn't already, somebody should make a location train map in Google.
 
Like the map!

A few notes though:

-While I agree that the shape of the map does not have to be perfect, it seems like the south line is way to far over. Just think of where the Southeast line would fit on the map. If it's possible, this should be moved to be more central in the map.

-I like the overall graphics of the map, but I feel like they are crunched together. Are you able to use a larger background so there is more room for the bus routes and a better orientation of the city?

Keep up the good work!
 
^^^I'd like to, but moving the entire line will be "difficult" none-the-less. I'd trying to avoid a larger background as the map is already ~30% larger in each dimension than I had originally hoped. I might just go and "screw" my original size boundaries, but thats undecided for now.

Unfortunately not much can get done in the next 2 - 3 weeks as time's short when exams are coming.

But thanks for the compliment!
 
Last edited:
Alright, heres the next update of the map. Added a lot more thing. A lot more work to be done still.

PS. I know the line is quiggley by Rockyview and the font in one of the boxes is wrong. I'm also aware of the wording in the legend. You don't have to tell me, I already see it! :P

Large Image (Please wait to load 401KB)
Calgary%20LRT2.jpg
 
Nice. Aside from the things you mentioned, the only thing that stands out to me is that the 72/73 don't actually go to the Rockyview. Other then that, amazing work on it.
 
I know this is probably going to contradict what other people have said, but as an outsider to Calgary Transit, most of those bus routes shown have absolutely no meaning to me; they're just clutter. I'd recommend sticking to how you originally had it: show what bus route goes to important destinations such as hospitals and bus stations and such. Without showing what streets they run on, they mean nothing right now and I'd still have to go to a more comprehensive source for additional information.
 
@ Jeremy

I'm actually with you. I don't really like the bus routes that much. Too everywherey (and yes I know thats not a word). I'll post a version with or without to coompare later.

(Can you convert a post into poll?)
 


Back
Top