governorgeneral
New member
As HomeInMyShoes said, the best way to tell if your maps works is to run it by people who aren't familiar with the system.
You're welcome.
I'm with you on the easy-to-read part, but Arial having a monopoly on transit? Look at almost every major transit system in the world, they steer clear of Arial! Some even come up with their own proprietary fonts precisely because it's easier to read than Arial (as well as being image-conscious).
Like the suggestion to include major roads, this is mostly for people who don't know Calgary and would need some way to orient the map around landmarks.
Maybe you could just add the name of the road to the line running along it? Like the TTC map. Also, do the station names in Calgary correspond to the cross streets? If not, that could also be useful for non-Calgarians.
Yes, it's hard to tell that there's really just one track on either side of the street downtown, and both "lines" use it. (Though if they were really separate lines on separate tracks, presumably there'd be a space between the colours instead of them touching each other, so it should be reasonable as-is.) I think the double-arrows will make it more clear that both lines stop at each station, but something in the legend like "<- westbound trains only" and "-> eastbound trains only" is definitely necessary.
The easy way is to take a proven map (eg London Underground) and copy its technique to fit the local system. I found a TTC map done London-style, including the both the subway and streetcar lines (the TTC map doesn't even show the streetcars), and it definitely made those first days getting used to living in Toronto easier:

(Photo: me)
I'll look into some of those suggestions.
You're welcome.
I prefer Arial because it is fairly easy to read and is the only Sans Serif font used on transit.
I'm with you on the easy-to-read part, but Arial having a monopoly on transit? Look at almost every major transit system in the world, they steer clear of Arial! Some even come up with their own proprietary fonts precisely because it's easier to read than Arial (as well as being image-conscious).
Adding rivers, probably not. That would add confusion. Particularly since we have 2 rivers that run around downtown at random angles, then meet and join at the edge of downtown, then run east wards along the 202 for a while, the abruptly turn south. Not to mention the not to scale nature of everything, the river will become really weird or will end up looking like it is near to things it obviously is not. Just like the existing maps, but even worse.
Like the suggestion to include major roads, this is mostly for people who don't know Calgary and would need some way to orient the map around landmarks.
Major Roads: all the lines run along or very near major roads. The line's own footprint will eventually cover itself.
Maybe you could just add the name of the road to the line running along it? Like the TTC map. Also, do the station names in Calgary correspond to the cross streets? If not, that could also be useful for non-Calgarians.
That was my reading, but it wasn't completely clear and I can definitely see people misreading it. I think actually writing that out somewhere on the map would make it more understandable. I actually don't think the problem is the map, but Calgary's LRT routes that are the legibility problem here.
Two arrows might help. Single dots for each line with the arrows maybe.
Yes, it's hard to tell that there's really just one track on either side of the street downtown, and both "lines" use it. (Though if they were really separate lines on separate tracks, presumably there'd be a space between the colours instead of them touching each other, so it should be reasonable as-is.) I think the double-arrows will make it more clear that both lines stop at each station, but something in the legend like "<- westbound trains only" and "-> eastbound trains only" is definitely necessary.
The only way to know for sure is to find random people some who know the system and some who don't and show them one of the map options, then ask them how to get from A to B. That should tell you what is more readible for more people. Assuming a large enough sample size. Useability is tough because in the end, using LoFi design to hash through it and then sampling the poplulation is the best way to guarantee the best design. And best does not mean good for all people either. But then, almost no one pays for that process and we end up getting crappy websites, and unuseable guidebooks. You've hit a subject matter I care about a lot.
The easy way is to take a proven map (eg London Underground) and copy its technique to fit the local system. I found a TTC map done London-style, including the both the subway and streetcar lines (the TTC map doesn't even show the streetcars), and it definitely made those first days getting used to living in Toronto easier:

(Photo: me)
Last edited: