LRT Map

As HomeInMyShoes said, the best way to tell if your maps works is to run it by people who aren't familiar with the system.

I'll look into some of those suggestions.

You're welcome.

I prefer Arial because it is fairly easy to read and is the only Sans Serif font used on transit.

I'm with you on the easy-to-read part, but Arial having a monopoly on transit? Look at almost every major transit system in the world, they steer clear of Arial! Some even come up with their own proprietary fonts precisely because it's easier to read than Arial (as well as being image-conscious).

Adding rivers, probably not. That would add confusion. Particularly since we have 2 rivers that run around downtown at random angles, then meet and join at the edge of downtown, then run east wards along the 202 for a while, the abruptly turn south. Not to mention the not to scale nature of everything, the river will become really weird or will end up looking like it is near to things it obviously is not. Just like the existing maps, but even worse.

Like the suggestion to include major roads, this is mostly for people who don't know Calgary and would need some way to orient the map around landmarks.

Major Roads: all the lines run along or very near major roads. The line's own footprint will eventually cover itself.

Maybe you could just add the name of the road to the line running along it? Like the TTC map. Also, do the station names in Calgary correspond to the cross streets? If not, that could also be useful for non-Calgarians.

That was my reading, but it wasn't completely clear and I can definitely see people misreading it. I think actually writing that out somewhere on the map would make it more understandable. I actually don't think the problem is the map, but Calgary's LRT routes that are the legibility problem here.

Two arrows might help. Single dots for each line with the arrows maybe.

Yes, it's hard to tell that there's really just one track on either side of the street downtown, and both "lines" use it. (Though if they were really separate lines on separate tracks, presumably there'd be a space between the colours instead of them touching each other, so it should be reasonable as-is.) I think the double-arrows will make it more clear that both lines stop at each station, but something in the legend like "<- westbound trains only" and "-> eastbound trains only" is definitely necessary.

The only way to know for sure is to find random people some who know the system and some who don't and show them one of the map options, then ask them how to get from A to B. That should tell you what is more readible for more people. Assuming a large enough sample size. Useability is tough because in the end, using LoFi design to hash through it and then sampling the poplulation is the best way to guarantee the best design. And best does not mean good for all people either. But then, almost no one pays for that process and we end up getting crappy websites, and unuseable guidebooks. You've hit a subject matter I care about a lot.

The easy way is to take a proven map (eg London Underground) and copy its technique to fit the local system. I found a TTC map done London-style, including the both the subway and streetcar lines (the TTC map doesn't even show the streetcars), and it definitely made those first days getting used to living in Toronto easier:



(Photo: me)
 
Last edited:
For other transportation connections, should I even bother to leave the "Via bus route _______" or would the simple icons and name be sufficient? See the Inter-City bus boxes on the image below to compare.

Calgary%20LRT3.jpg
 
Just out of curiousity, why did Calgary make travel WITHIN the downtown area free? I've never seen that before.
 
Just out of curiousity, why did Calgary make travel WITHIN the downtown area free? I've never seen that before.

In Portland there's a "fareless square" which is about 1 sq mi downtown in which ALL transit is free, not only the LRT but buses and streetcars as well. And it's been expanded to include neighbourhoods adjacent to DT (inner NW and NE) as well. Calgary's is okay but not nearly as comprehensive as Portland.

I'm pretty sure the monorail peoplemover thing in Miami is free DT too.

I can't say why these free fare zones exist but it's not unique to Calgary.
 
Just out of curiousity, why did Calgary make travel WITHIN the downtown area free? I've never seen that before.

Makes it an attractive option for just hopping around the core. It's been like that for as long as I can remember, and while there have been some calls to remove it (it would make changing to anything but a proof of fare system difficult if it was left) I don't think it will go anywhere any time soon.
 
The free fare zone was originally introduced back in the 80s to encourage downtown office workers to use the LRT during lunch hour rather than getting in their car and driving to restaurants. Also, since there are much travel between office buildings, they wanted to encourage people to use the LRT for this as well.

There has been talk over the past few years of expanding the free fare zone to include the Zoo on the northeast-bound line and to Sunnyside station in the northwest. Also, there as a proposal by one alderman a year or two ago about expanding it to Victoria Park-Stampede station to help deal with the "parking problem" downtown. The idea was that people would park at the Stampede grounds and ride the LRT the rest of the way into downtown. The proposal was defeated in council.
 
For other transportation connections, should I even bother to leave the "Via bus route _______" or would the simple icons and name be sufficient? See the Inter-City bus boxes on the image below to compare.

I think it would be sufficient to put a label for connections in the legend, and then remove the redundant text from the map.
 
The free fare zone was originally introduced back in the 80s to encourage downtown office workers to use the LRT during lunch hour rather than getting in their car and driving to restaurants. Also, since there are much travel between office buildings, they wanted to encourage people to use the LRT for this as well.

There has been talk over the past few years of expanding the free fare zone to include the Zoo on the northeast-bound line and to Sunnyside station in the northwest. Also, there as a proposal by one alderman a year or two ago about expanding it to Victoria Park-Stampede station to help deal with the "parking problem" downtown. The idea was that people would park at the Stampede grounds and ride the LRT the rest of the way into downtown. The proposal was defeated in council.

Didn't Edmonton get rid of their free zone about a year ago? Not sure how that is working but Calgary has considered doing the same thing along with what you've mentioned. Free fare to the Stampede facilities for convention delegates would be great but I'm not sure I would support free for everybody or to anywhere else.
 
Didn't Edmonton get rid of their free zone about a year ago? Not sure how that is working but Calgary has considered doing the same thing along with what you've mentioned. Free fare to the Stampede facilities for convention delegates would be great but I'm not sure I would support free for everybody or to anywhere else.


I've been in Edmonton for over 3 years now, and I don't recall a "free fare zone" in the downtown.
 
For other transportation connections, should I even bother to leave the "Via bus route _______" or would the simple icons and name be sufficient? See the Inter-City bus boxes on the image below to compare.

The icons are sufficient, on both the connexions to the bus stations and the airport.

Is the new font Trebuchet? Any particular reason for that font? I think Arial looked cleaner (esp the lower-case "g"s), but if you're making the change, you should be consistent with the top title and small print in the lower right corner too.

The "Bridgeland / Memorial" name is cut off.

If you're going to keep the explanatory text (why?) in the City Centre Free Fare Zone in the highlighted area on the map, you should at least be consistent with the text on the legend. "Travel Within This Area Is Free" vs "No Charge For Travel Within This Area" - why the difference in text?

The main readability/useability issue (esp for people not familiar with the CTrain) is still how to illustrate the one-way stations downtown. Again, double-arrows as you mentioned will make it clear both lines do serve each stop; and a "westbound trains only" text or somesuch in the legend will explain the meaning.
 
The icons are sufficient, on both the connexions to the bus stations and the airport.

Is the new font Trebuchet? Any particular reason for that font? I think Arial looked cleaner (esp the lower-case "g"s), but if you're making the change, you should be consistent with the top title and small print in the lower right corner too.

The "Bridgeland / Memorial" name is cut off.

If you're going to keep the explanatory text (why?) in the City Centre Free Fare Zone in the highlighted area on the map, you should at least be consistent with the text on the legend. "Travel Within This Area Is Free" vs "No Charge For Travel Within This Area" - why the difference in text?

The main readability/useability issue (esp for people not familiar with the CTrain) is still how to illustrate the one-way stations downtown. Again, double-arrows as you mentioned will make it clear both lines do serve each stop; and a "westbound trains only" text or somesuch in the legend will explain the meaning.

Those problems are getting fixed. Still picking fonts, not decided. The Free Fare bubble text on the map has been replaced with text describing the directional arrows.
 
Are you planning to pitch this map to Calgary Transit, or is it for some other purpose?

If you can come up with a more useful and better-looking map than the existing one (and I think you have already) you absolutely should pitch it to Calgary Transit. If not to adopt it outright, then to at least make changes to the current one to make it user-friendly.
 
PortlandTriMetMAXSystemMap.png
From Wikipedia

Maybe this would be a good system map to model off?

Even if all the stations are on the same street, maybe for clarity the map (the Calgary map that is) should be split like the free fare zone on this map.
 
That's Portland, right? Where the split appears on the map, the lines actually do split to either side of a block (eg Pioneer Square), on different streets. So westbound trains board on on the north side, eastbound on the south side. To change directions, you walk across the square to the next street.

DSCF3049.jpg


DSCF3050.jpg


(Photos: me)

Whereas Calgary's are on either side of the same street, aren't they? When you want to change, you just cross the road. I think splitting the line would make it more confusing, it will make you think you have to go to the next block. (Though it should be obvious in real life, seeing the tracks (and maybe even the actual stations?) right across the street, right?)
 
In Portland there's a "fareless square" which is about 1 sq mi downtown in which ALL transit is free, not only the LRT but buses and streetcars as well.

Seattle also has one and it also includes all transit. Actually, I don't think it's all that uncommon at all.
 
I think its confusing to have the bend on the NE lone between Franklin and Barlow instead of between Franklin and Marlbourough, like it is. If people weren't familiar with the system, they might think, "first station after the curve" or something like that, and then miss their station.
 


Back
Top