Quote:
Originally Posted by cardeza
Commuter rail is probably the most expensive way to move people via mass transit for a host of reasons. RR is not akin to a subway and is totally incapable of providing the type of service subways provide at similar cost. A subway needs less labor, offers superior reliability, has totally dedicated tracks with no conflicts and shorter lines which allow trains to cycle between terminal points relatively frequently. On top of that the sub/EL travel through more densely populated areas where constant ridership is more feasible. The reality of RR is that during the day most suburban stations are absolutely dead. The stations are flooded with activity at rush hour and demand is minimal off peak. If you ride a RR train mid-day with current service levels you will find trains that are 75% empty- and I'm talking about in CC- it probably gets worse as the trains move out of CC towards their destinations.
|
concerning off peak headway---isn't it a chicken or the egg problem? With once a hour service SEPTA is limiting themselves to a very limited market. But I'm guessing SEPTA would say that their studies don't indicate a need for more service.
Up until last year I took the train once a month in from Paoli during the week on off peak hours and was surprised that by the end of the trip most seats were full, regardless of when I took the train, morning or afternoon.
Does SEPTA still have a labor storage? In the past they couldn't train engineers fast enough, because those engineers would be hired away by other agencies who were paying more