Quote:
Originally Posted by Lancaster
I intentionally left "some" out of the statement on YUL with regards to Asia. If you look at the asian destinations that mainline AC offers from YVR...
HKG (YYZ)
PEK (YYZ, YUL on CA (accounting for expected JV))
PVG (YYZ, YUL)
NRT (YYZ, YUL)
ICN (YYZ)
TPE
And then look at european destinations that mainline AC offers from YUL...
BRU
FRA (YYZ, YVR)
GVA (YYZ)
LYS
CDG (YYZ, YVR)
FCO (YYZ)
DUB (YYZ)
KEF
YUL has more fingers in YVR's 'Asia' cookie jar than YVR has in YUL's 'Europe'. And in both cases, YYZ is all over each airports "strengths". Whatever. I could not care less if YUL gets just as many asian services as YVR so long as the journey time for the passenger is the shortest. It makes zero sense for a passenger to fly NRT-YVR-BOS if a NRT-YUL-BOS ticket is available. If AC can do it profitably then it's only better for Canadians. However, I only get upset if AC strategized connecting passengers NRT-YUL-SFO instead of NRT-YVR-SFO.
That was a totally unnecessary drive-by.
|
If we are talking strictly AC, then yes YUL having 1/2 of the Asian destinations of YVR is a higher proportion than YVR has of Europe for sure. But if you take all airline services to both continents from both airports, then it changes fairly dramatically. The only European services YUL has that YVR doesn't is Swiss (and YVR has Swiss-owned Edelweiss), and seasonal Azores Airlines and Corsair (and Transat's various small frequency seasonal services). YVR has Icelandair, KLM, Air France, Lufthansa, British Airways same as YUL. But for Asia, YVR has ANA, JAL, Korean Air, Beijing Capital, Cathay Pacific, China Airlines, China Eastern, China Southern, EVA, Hainan, Hong Kong Airlines, Philippine Airlines, Sichuan, and Xiamen (and tons of individual destinations amongst those). And really Asia Pacific is the correct category, so you add in AC to MEL, BNE, SYD, and *Alliance to AKL and YUL only has 3/10, and you can add Air New Zealand and Qantas to the other airlines list.
And please let's be honest, noflyzone goes out of his way to diminsh anything about YVR at every chance, it's just the way it is, doesn't matter, but it is what it is. Claiming it isn't the case is being really oblivious.... YUL is doing well and so is YVR, they have their own strengths, can't it just be discussed without so much hostility lol