Quote:
Originally Posted by Feathered Friend
|
Quote:
Panel Consensus:
Having reviewed the project it was moved by Ms. Spoelstra and seconded by Ms. Anderson and was the decision of the Urban Design Panel:
THAT the Panel Recommend RESUBMISSION with following recommendations to be reviewed by City Staff:- Re-examine the character of the building
- Make the expression and symmetry of the building more contemporary
- Make the building more sustainable, including the glazing ratio and the solar orientation
- Acknowledge the corner of the building
- Look at the retail and street opportunities on Broadway, possibly add an outdoor patio area
- Re-examine the Quebec façade to add more articulation and take more advantage of the views
- Re-examine activating the lane
- Change the staircase exiting to open up to Quebec street
- Look at the amenity programming in the lane
- Consider consolidating parking access in the lane with loading
- Reconsider lateral stability by looking at stairs
- Further develop mechanical systems for the next stage of development
Related Commentary: The panel noted the building design overall had missed design opportunities. A few panel members noted the design was ‘too dated’ for Broadway.
Stamped asphalt should be a different material. The ramp should be moved. The restaurant expression and main lobby expression needs work. The elevator core should not be the only ‘lateral’ element.
|
Also, a couple of interesting tidbits from the Applicant’s Introductory Comments:
Quote:
- The applicant noted there was no setback requirement in the zone. However the road would be widened at the ground level in future.
- The restaurant and market rental units will be owned and operated by the same party.
|
Like much of our forum, it's clear the UDP was not a fan of this design. Hopefully the team can recover fast from this dissection and come back when something more fitting for the location, even if it still won't reach the density that the neighbourhood should have.
Something that puzzles me is the remark in the introductory comments about road widening happening in the future. I'm not sure if this refers to Broadway, the Laneway, or Quebec.