Quote:
Originally Posted by Valyrian Steel
You should probably elaborate and what exactly was absurd about his comment. You can build a parking podium without making it stick out like a sore thumb (see: 8th & Hope). The city also should do a better job of promoting the use of mass transit, which IMO should include changing parking minimum requirements. These podiums are permanent and we shouldn't just accept every monstrosity just because LA is historically a car city.
|
Thank you!
I'm a believer in constructive criticism where necessary and giving credit where it's due. I heaped both praise and criticism in this instance, and my points were reasonable IMO. Instead of having such knee-jerk reactions to any and all perceived negativity, the forumers in question (scania, Resident, Just-In-Cali, and The Illusive Man) should actually look at what the critics are saying and evaluate the arguments based on their merits.
Circa in particular irks me because it's adjacent to a rail station. That and the architect/developer didn't put much thought into concealing the massive podium (based on the renderings), something that the city should've forced them into doing. Atelier (8th and Olive) is a great example of what can be done. Heck, even Oceanwide Plaza, which will have an equally massive podium, isn't that offensive looking to me.
You're absolutely right in that the city should be adopting more policies designed to help us evolve out of our car culture. We'll never be able to root it out completely, but we can chip away at it little by little... and that's what ultimately matters. Eliminating parking minimums is a no-brainer for everyone involved, including the developers. The city could also have developers build these podiums in such a way that would allow for the possibility of future residential conversion (Seattle is doing this). Another option could be to have them built as detached structures (9th and Hope), so that they could one day be torn down and replaced with housing. Almost anything is possible provided there's the will, imagination, and creativity. I'm just not seeing that from LA city yet, and it's very frustrating.
[/endrant]