Quote:
Originally Posted by PPAR
Edmonton is an interesting, if sad, case study in an interventionist approach to air service. They shut down a highly coveted airport in the central city to concentrate services at YEG, ran public campaigns to discourage use of YYC for transfer (even if that meant a worsened travel experience) and offered incentives to airlines willing to serve YEG (Iceland air). However, the biggest mistake was initiating a very public spat with the country's largest air carrier when they perceived that they were being slighted in service commitments. What they have forgotten is to ask what is best for the individual traveller, not what best serves the collective ego.
What you are seeing is a market that is contracting due to a poor economy served by an airport authority that the industry does not trust.
|
Let me preface this with I am a consumer and not airline insider. Edmonton needed to choose, 1 strong comprehensive airport with a variety of flights or a muni serving corporates from Calgary, feeding YYC and a horrifically underwhelming 'international' property. They made the right choice, YEG grew well, flight came even ^in the ever-present shadow of YYC, terminal expansion, parking, services, a hotel, air and non airside is going well and until the last 6-12, we were about bang on with flights, destinations and service given our market, location proximity to YYC. Yes our airport authority has had ups and downs, but AC has made it clear that if we want to fly south, ^^we YYC hub it and that does not sit well with us, maybe even justifies being publicly upset.
This aside, closing the muni has meant multiple new towers as our overlay is now removed... Hundreds of millions, maybe billions of new development, a new tallest ^in western Canada etc.
Losing SFO and ORD hurt, a lot, but YEG pax is still very respectable and the last ten yr run was pretty impressive.
I typically and purposefully connect through YVR or SEA over YYC, but more to plane watch, visit friends or pop into that city if time permits, less so because I want to avoid Calgary. Heck, I am NRT'ing it YYC stylez in Nov.
YEG will always have an uphill with less J customers, an AC 'sorta hub' nearby and being so far north, but looking to WJ, Delta, KLM, Iceland and other willing partners, YEG will endure.
