Quote:
Originally Posted by Obadno
I don't think it is that silly,
It is two stops from Roosevelt and 2 stops from the east lake park residences by train and only a couple of blocks from 3rd/Roosevelt.
people using the grocery store downtown wont be making large grocery trips they can walk a couple blocks.
anyone doing a large grocery trip would drive anyway. 
|
I agree that anyone doing a decent amount of grocery shopping would choose to drive than bring a wheel barrel. If one assumes this to be the case, what is the advantage of driving to Block 23 where parking will be structured (god forbid!), traffic might be jammed, etc., vs. just heading down to McDowell? This is an honest question.
CityScape has 200 units and is the only really walkable residential project nearby. Contrast that to the Central/McKinley area, where Linear, iLuminate, Alliance, Union, and enHance (excluding quite a few others) have the same # of units, and ASU is just south. That's a mass of nearby residents who can do "last-minute" or "essentials" shopping by foot, bike, or rail that probably won't ever be possible for Block 23 (assume Barrister gets its 100 units; the only other possible spots within walking distance for development are the lots surrounding Barrister that are land-banked, and Madison 1st St-Central if the St. James stump is demo'd).
if this were being proposed on any random lot, I would agree with whoever posted "why not?" as in "having one hear doesn't hurt and another can go north later." But, I would consider this the hottest piece of property in all of downtown and is surrounded by successful, active blocks on all sides. If this is designed properly within a mixed use project, that would be great. But, if not, a large portion of space across from CityScape, USAC, and Colliers will have been wasted on something that could have been built anywhere in downtown's limits.
Whoever posted the pics of Chicago's version of an urban grocery store shows why I am hesitant. That is exactly what CAN'T happen here. This urban safeway project is *exactly* how I'd like to see Block 23 developed, replacing the left 2 towers with a taller condo-tel, and having the tower in the back (i.e., facing 2nd st) be office:
Note that this project has active uses along all of its sides; translated to Block 23, this would mean something like:
1) 1st St would have Safeway's entrance and windows, garage ramp flanked by 2 small stores, and a corner restaurant/bar at Washington/1st St
2) Jefferson would have 3-5 retail spaces hiding the windowless part of the Fry's; underneath the office tower could be something like a Nike Concept Store
3) 2nd Street could have the office lobby, 1-2 small restaurants, loading docks and office garage ramp
4) Washington could have the hotel restaurant/bar on the 1st St corner, residential/condo lobby, one more nightlife/bar space, and a West Elm/HomeGoods on the corner of 2nd St
I don't expect more than 1/4 of the lot to be developed, but it would be great if at least the right side of that photo was built - residents and jobs would be great additions.