I got a draft of this bill yesterday. I like it, it's very to the point. But I am not confident about its chances in the House. In terms of mandatory arbitration, it is pretty much the same as what raised the stink last year.
The bill will not require a "right to remedy" — a provision in California law that mandates that unit owners give builders an opportunity to repair defects before taking legal action.
While a number of coalition members wanted to include a similar provision, that would have required amending CDARA as well as CCIOA, backers were afraid that could open up general defects-litigation law to too many unwanted attempts at changes, Mulligan said.
"We think the mediation process on the front end of this bill is kind of a right to remedy," Clark said.
The mayors all supported last years' attempts too. My purpose in reviewing it is to see what holes are left by it only applying to common interest communities under CCIOA.
The mediation provision is a waste of money and won't influence insurers at all. It's tossing a bone to feel good legislators and folks who make money off of mediation. The part that matters is making it so you can't amend mandatory arbitration clauses out of covenants, and requiring a majority of votes sign on to litigation. Especially during declarant control periods, this seems like it could effectively make early defects litigation impossible (admittedly I still need to review more closely). Fine by me, but it's not exactly a compromise with what the Dems and their concerns. Fingers crossed though.
Bunt please tells us more. No sarcasm. If you can't, it's cool.
Bunt please tells us more. No sarcasm. If you can't, it's cool.
Fun facts and ironies about Stapleton. It's named after Ben Stapleton, who was a Denver Mayor in 12935 and also a KKK member.
Given that, Stapleton is named after him with MLK BLVD going right through the heart of it. Funny..
It's not a secret, I can email you the draft.
I think the bill would give builders and insurers plenty of comfort to move forward with condos again. (Whether that bring prices down, who knows, see bcp's post.) I just don't think it'll pass.
I'm curious who specifically these developers really are. It would be nice to get a record and tally up some "we would have had it not been for..." statements from notable developers.Developers say current state laws make it too easy to file class-action lawsuits over condo construction defects, bringing construction of condos to a virtual standstill.
Bunt, why don't you think it will pass? Its right down the middle bi-partisan as far as its advocates. I'm not questioning your intuition but I'm genuinely curious while hoping that you're pessimism is a mechanism for not getting disappointed.
I'm curious who specifically these developers really are. It would be nice to get a record and tally up some "we would have had it not been for..." statements from notable developers.
I think the bill would give builders and insurers plenty of comfort to move forward with condos again. (Whether that bring prices down, who knows, see bcp's post.) I just don't think it'll pass.
I think bunt_q is just being anxious and overly concerned.Bunt, why don't you think it will pass?
Also regarding,
I'm curious who specifically these developers really are. It would be nice to get a record and tally up some "we would have had it not been for..." statements from notable developers.
I (still) bet the largest issue with condos is that values aren't high enough. Defect law makes them more expensive of course, and it's a problem. But if values rise enough, I bet they get built.
buyers will see more benefit to locking up a place and a price early.
The second problem is that the old "presale" method isn't trusted by buyers/financiers/developers, so you can't finance them that way yet. You need a ton of equity, then you get a smaller loan based on selling during/after construction. Not many developers can do this. Again, things will loosen up when condo values are higher. When that happens,
A third problem is that construction costs are rising quickly. In my area it's looking like around 5% annually for construction. Don't know for Denver but it might be similar. It'll get worse as the rest of the country improves, which will exacerbate today's lack of construction people on the technical and trade sides (our cities are currently living off migration of construction people from other regions). Land costs are probably rising even more quickly than 5% in Denver. Condo values need to rise even faster than 5% annually to overcome these and the other issues.
A fourth problem is that rentals are profitable. A developer will often choose the safe, easy path.
A fifth problem in Denver's case is the oil question. Regardless of how diversified the city has become it's a big sector, including whatever multiplier.
On the bright side, interest rates are incredibly low again, Denver probably has a lot of pent-up condo demand, and the city overall is getting better every year, which becomes a self-sustaining upward spiral.
Hey, how are the Union Station plazas doing? Are there people in them?
I mean, recognizing that it's winter so naturally there'll be fewer than summer.
Interesting comment.It's different here, none of those "normal" factors are really driving. Any and every developer locally would disagree with you. Insurance is impossible. I've got one client doing massive amounts of over-ex where the geotech says the soils are absolutely fine and it's not needed (engineer just throws up his arms). Folks are acting straight up paranoid - it's basically 100% you get a defects claim on every single project. It's a real world problem, not just academic anymore.
But that's the entire condo segment right now. It's under, what, 3% of building permits now are for-sale multi-family housing? That's not natural, it was 7-times that before the recession, when the urban market was much less strong than it is today. Land costs aren't a factor outside of the urban core, and outside of the urban core there are exactly zero units under construction.
I just hope the bill passes, that's all.
Yes I remember those well! The current "D4 Urban" plan for the Alameda and Broadway strip mall/Design Center area, http://d4urban.com/, is similar in the density that it shows. Let's hope they stick to it, because I think it could really work in this location. Especially once the CPV is all wrapped up, which now appears will now be very soon.
It's different here, none of those "normal" factors are really driving. Any and every developer locally would disagree with you. Insurance is impossible. I've got one client doing massive amounts of over-ex where the geotech says the soils are absolutely fine and it's not needed (engineer just throws up his arms). Folks are acting straight up paranoid - it's basically 100% you get a defects claim on every single project. It's a real world problem, not just academic anymore.
Yes, at high enough price points ($600k+ probably) you can get it done, and we're seeing a couple hundred of those. But that's the entire condo segment right now. It's under, what, 3% of building permits now are for-sale multi-family housing? That's not natural, it was 7-times that before the recession, when the urban market was much less strong than it is today. Land costs aren't a factor outside of the urban core, and outside of the urban core there are exactly zero units under construction.