Hate, hate, hate Hamilton's skyline. I'm allowed to say this because I'm from there.
Hate, hate, hate Hamilton's skyline. I'm allowed to say this because I'm from there.
It has precisely one good building. Which is actually fantastic. But the other office buildings are terrible, and the residential towers got slapped up in the 1960s and 70s during the dying moments of the "tower-in-the-park" era. They feature lawns in front or are just generally set back way too far from the street with driveways arcing up to the front door. Truly bleak, but the worst part is that they almost destroyed Hamilton's most charming neighbourhood, Durand, were it not for community activists who worked to put a stop to the developers before they ruined it entirely.
Hamilton's skyline embodies everything that was wrong with urban North America in the 20th century.
By building style Hamilton is my favourite skyline.
in my opinion:
Overall Canadian skyline: Toronto, followed by Montreal
Natural setting Canadian skyline: Vancouver, followed by Quebec City
Building variety and eclectic styles Canadian skyline: Montreal, followed by Winnipeg
Those complaints are mostly street level interaction based, which are a totally separate issue from skyline. I will admit that some of the buildings have poor street interaction, but most of them are on quite residential streets that feed customers into nearby commercial streets. Not every street in a city will be a commercial route, and most of the buildings that were built on commercial streets have much better street interaction.
Yep, it's personal taste. Or in your case, a complete lack of taste combined with a childish desire to present yourself as an off-beat eccentric tip-toeing merrily past the tulip fields of convention.As for the buildings impact on the skyline, that's totally personal taste. By building style Hamilton is my favourite skyline. A minimum number of depressing office towers set in a sea of human residential buildings. It could be bigger, but it's the right type of buildings.:yes:

We are all entitled to our opinions of course. But...is Hamilton really your favorite skyline on that metric?
Hamilton's skyline is far from being the worst. That said, I really dislike the overwhelming dominance of generic 60s residential towers.
in my opinion:
Overall Canadian skyline: Toronto, followed by Montreal
Natural setting Canadian skyline: Vancouver, followed by Quebec City
Building variety and eclectic styles Canadian skyline: Montreal, followed by Winnipeg





60s and 70s apartment towers are ugly. They are a blight on cities. Your opinion is bizarre.60s and 70s apartment buildings are great. They're residential (which is always a plus) and they lack the excessive glass of 90s to modern residential buildings. Instead they look solid and permanent. They give a sense of urban stability unlikely the weak glass towers so popular today. Luckily actual walls seem to be regaining popularity.
Yes, let's look at this "street." More closely. Because it's not a street, it's one single, solitary section of a street filled with soul-crushing apartment blocks with large setbacks and grass lawns in front of them. In fact, look right across the phreaking street from those lovely New York-esque townhouses. Like what you see? Of course not.Look at this street. The rowhouses, 30s lowrise, and more modern highrise are all about the same distance from the street, yet the highest density one is the "blight upon downtown"?:sly:
What on earth are you talking about? Who mentioned anything about retail? What does that have to do with anything?Also all those lovely historical commercial buildings are an important reason as to why most of these apartment buildings lack ground level retail, the city has massive amounts of unused retail. Adding more is just bad planning.
Only complete idiots who feel faint at the notion of having to traverse urban territory without their trusty automobiles would ever claim that Hamilton lacks greenery. The very idea is farcical.Beedok said:Also most people seem to complain Hamilton doesn't have enough greenery, yet you folks are complaining about it having the slightest amount. I understand some people don't like residential buildings, but a lot of these complaints make little sense.
It has precisely one good building. Which is actually fantastic.
It's my honest to goodness opinion. Buildings without balconies tend to look depressing and inhuman to me, and all glass buildings just don't look complete.60s and 70s apartment towers are ugly. They are a blight on cities. Your opinion is bizarre.
Across the street we have brick walk up lowrises. Across the street the other way we have another brick low rise walk up. Diagonally across the street we have a more modern brick dominated mid-rise. you have to travel about a block to get any highrise apartment blocks. That's more or less the heart of one of the most high rise dense parts of the city, yet it's loaded with historic buildings between them.Yes, let's look at this "street." More closely. Because it's not a street, it's one single, solitary section of a street filled with soul-crushing apartment blocks with large setbacks and grass lawns in front of them. In fact, look right across the phreaking street from those lovely New York-esque townhouses. Like what you see? Of course not.
I think most people in the neighbourhood would say they look nice and sooth the eyes. People tend to like trees.And yes, the lawns in front of those lovely townhouses are a disgrace, and actually do ruin what would otherwise would have been a nice section of the street. Look at all of those lawns. Do kids play in them? Do people sit in them, enjoying them? Do they look nice? Do they soothe the eye, give the street a pleasant vista?
The front yards of Victorian (maybe Edwardian) stone rowhouses are the result of a mid-century mindset focused on subdivisions and highways?:???:No, no, no, no and no. They are a product of a mid-century mindset bereft of design ideas that didn't involve carving new highways and subdivisions out of the countryside.
In a city of Hamilton's size going up to the property line is generally a design for retail or offices.What on earth are you talking about? Who mentioned anything about retail? What does that have to do with anything?
No, actually it's directed at many of the lower income neighbourhoods of the inner city where there's been fairly large discussions about the psychological effect of a lack of greenery and such. The area around those apartment builds is one of the more desirable downtown neighbourhoods due to the trees and grass you seem to hate so much.Only complete idiots who feel faint at the notion of having to traverse urban territory without their trusty automobiles would ever claim that Hamilton lacks greenery. The very idea is farcical.
Trying to be in keeping with the existing urban fabric is still something practiced today.Nobody is claiming they don't like residential buildings. I'm claiming that Hamilton's residential high-rises are ugly and depressing, making for an ugly skyline. Just because they replaced houses with front lawns is no excuse for them having front lawns themselves, but that was the sad mentality of the era.
I like St. Jamestown. I realise there's crime and poverty issues, but from an architectural stand point is one of my favourite highrise segments in Canada. I also like Yonge and Eglington area (apart for the rather ugly office towers in the area).Declaring Hamilton's skyline anything other than hideous is akin to praising St. Jamestown in Toronto for how lovely it is. Don't be ridiculous.