Quote:
Originally Posted by feepa
Downtown also doesn't offer the central living lifestyle that you find in most larger centers like Toronto, Vancouver, Calgary, Montreal... Fix those two issues and you'll see a lot more people choosing to live centrally.
|
I really don't get why people lump Calgary into these groupings. They may have a bit more options and a bit more construction compared to Edmonton, but I'd hardly call it up there with the big three. I don't find Calgary terribly different from Edmonton in this area, aside from Calgary being a bit further ahead in shifting the mentality.
Quote:
Originally Posted by feepa
There isn't very much for 'other options' and 'more coming' is not really evident at all.... I gave up, like many others have 'waiting' for 'more coming' that's been bandied about for 20 or more years now. More is not 'coming'.
Reality is central living is at best okay for the 20% that work downtown, as long as they are also okay with living in a condo tower with limited space, and have no family. But the real reality is that for the other 80%, it doesn't make any sense at all to live downtown or centrally, as the work force is outside of the core. Leduc, Fort Sask, Acheson, NW Industrail, etc etc, etc, etc,. On top of the work force working outside of the core, the attraction to live centrally is not there, like it is for other major centers. Downtown and central living is much different in Edmonton than it is in Toronto, Vancouver or Montreal. There are no shops and restaurants open late, everything closes down really early, and you are forced to travel to the burbs to get what you need.... It's highly laughable when you say you have all the same amenties here in central Edmonton that you do in central TO or Van.... You are fooling only yourself.
|
Vancouver and Portland are both pretty decentralized, yet are held in high esteem among urban planners. I don't see why Edmonton can't have a vibrant city centre even if more people work in Acheson or Nisku or Refinery Row than downtown.
Of course Downtown Edmonton doesn't have the amenities of Downtown Toronto. That's a silly comparison. Toronto's an older, bigger, and more prominent city than Edmonton. Downtown Toronto has over 100,000 people compared to Edmonton's, what, 13,000?
Isn't it widely known that Vancouver too closes up early for a "big" city?
The points of comparison here are a bit silly, but the usual suspects nonetheless. Vancouver is the only one that is sort of realistic, but even it is pretty sleepy after dark like the other Western Canadian cities.