Quote:
Originally Posted by h0twired
What about a fused grid layout?

|
The fact that the Commercial zone (as antiquated as that is) is segregated from the residential by a major street creates problems... It's the only path in and out for cars, so it will have a lot of cars on it.
Here are 2 examples: Minto/West End -- you have the Safeway on Sargent Ave between Sherbrook and Maryland, and you have a Sobey's, Walmart, et al. at Waverley West. Crime aside, would you feel safe walking to the Safeway? I would -- traffic goes much slower in that area. But even if I lived a 2 minute walk from Waverley West I wouldn't walk there ever and part of that is the fact that Waverley is the only path out of most of those neighbourhoods. Just like in the Fused Grid pic above, the only major street in and out is the Commercial strip.
When you build a grid pattern, each street has the potential for traffic (and I don't mean just cars). If every street can be used to equal proportions, then any street could create density. But it also means that any street can take traffic away. From the West End: Sargent, Ellice, Wellington/Notre Dame, Portage, McDermot, and William all come into downtown. They all share vehicular traffic, so none (except Portage) really creates problems for pedestrians.