Quote:
Originally Posted by scania
At the end of the day, the new stadium will be great for the economy. It will also be beneficial for the economy in years to come, as the city will be able to attract events that will bring money to the city. As far as most of you who are complaint, please just go and sit down somewhere. Who cares if they have a big parking lot, most of you never go down there anyway. As far as the tailgater's park, that will be welcome addition to sports fans. Maybe before you all complain about things, you should do some research and not sound so ignorant. I am stunned with the complaints about this Dome
|
So, actually, I do have a degree in urban planning and took a course that included information about stadiums and how they affect the local neighborhoods and economy. I also currently work as a city planner. A GT professor also used to occasionally take a class around the neighborhoods near Atlanta's existing stadiums and meet with the community representatives. From these experiences, I'm pretty convinced that stadiums are more trouble than they're worth for most people. So I wouldn't make the generalization that everyone that speaks against the stadium is uninformed...
Sure, the business community in Atlanta may benefit, and sure you guys that live OTP, Buckhead, Decatur, etc may benefit from some sense of pride that your city did something interesting; and now you can watch 300lbs men give each other concussions somewhere that might beat out Dallas's stadium (just whip it out already guys, yeah?)...but the people that live near the thing will almost certainly not have the quality of their life improved, and we could use those public dollars for other purposes that would improve the quality of life of the entire city and not just a select few (I don't need to hear anything about how the money is coming from a hotel tax, I fully understand that, but it could be repurposed and used for something better even if that requires legislative action).
The somewhat mitigating factors of this whole boondogle for me would be if they do decide to build it immediately south of the Georgia Dome, the community has already 'adapted' to the stadium and there is good transit access. Also, I hope they do not create vast urban parking lots surrounding the stadium that cut the community off from the dome and create a future eyesore.
For those of you that think the stadium will bring immense economic opportunity you're forgetting that we already have a stadium (and one that's not even 21 years old yet). How much EXTRA economic opportunity do you think replacing something that already functions well with something that functions incrementally better will provide? I'm not denying that maybe Atlanta will get to host the Superbowl or something in the future as a result of building this stadium, I'm just skeptical that the economic benefit from public investment couldn't be better realized in another endeavor.