Quote:
Originally Posted by Steel City Scotty
I wasn't using "good ol' boys" in the negative context that it is often used in today (ex. "He's just a member of the 'good ol' boy' network."). Basically, I was using a literal version of the phrase, describing traditional Pittsburghers as "good, old" hardworking, down-home, red-blooded Americans.
|
Yeah, I figured as much... and again I'll say, I don't think your general understanding of Pittsburgh's (or many other "rustbelt" cities') population makeup was like in the past is very accurate.
While the immigrant, first, and second generation blue-collar populations who were strongly identified with steel and heavy industry were certainly
hardworking, the phrase
"down-home, red-blooded Americans" is something that has, in my opinion, become rather pejorative and is likely much better reserved for the "yinzer" culture... something that has been celebrated, if you will, in its rejection of progress and education and adherence to small-town "values" and a
"good ol' boy" ideal.
Point is, Pittsburgh historically has been a much more educated, urban, cultured, formal, and wealthy city than what many seem to realize... and the idea that it has somehow been dominated by less-educated millworkers who
"enjoy the simpler things in life" is exaggerated.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Steel City Scotty
I've watched the video at the following link several times, and it's definitely my favorite "Pittsburgh Tribute" video on YouTube. I'll admit that the message it expresses is probably a big part of where I get my idea of what older residents of the city are really like.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aR14UxpyGpo
|
And I think the video (and its accompanying country music soundtrack) is about as nauseating as it can get as a portrayal of Pittsburgh... and not simply because it is filled with inaccuracy.
Best not to get your information from youtube videos.