Quote:
Originally Posted by MonctonRad
Personal note:
Why am I not surprised.
|
You cannot be surprised, considering the government expectations are kept secret -- and the one proposal has been kept secret.
Quote:
Originally Posted by MonctonRad
MHS is an architecturally distinctive building and this is why it must be preserved, but this is also what will make it a hard sell for any developer to repurpose. The need to preserve the architectural integrity of the building, as well as the requirement to maintain the auditorium will be major stumbling blocks to any developer.
|
MHS's architecture isn't what's making this a challenge for private developers;
the lack of demand in the downtown is. If there was demand, more of the core's surface parking lots would be purchased by developers eager to construct their residential proposals, and the downtown would be seeing more than a few suburban style apartment buildings.
Many other cities easily repurpose old buildings without breaking the bank. For the sake of physical heritage, the old facades may be reused, and most of the internals can be rebuilt (which is often cheaper than total restoration). Redevelopments usually build additional storeys to make the enterprise a profitable one; and in MHS' redevelopment case, any additional floors should be mostly glass, as this would act to contrast and 'show off' MHS's old character.
Quote:
Originally Posted by MonctonRad
Don't get me wrong. I agree that the auditorium should be saved, and the facade of the building should largely be preserved. I imagine that aside from the auditorium, the future of the building will be in upper floor condo conversions and some form of ground floor community space (art galleries, meeting spaces etc). I doubt that there is much of a commercial future for the building. This is reality. Let's all hope for the best for this fine building and for the eventual return of a downtown high school someplace else in the core......[/COLOR][/I]
|
Schools are not cheap. I believe the downtown is saying a last goodbye to the residential-attracting asset that is a high school.
By allowing the school relocation, Moncton has already shown that it doesn't actually care about this old school. I don't think beggars can be choosers. Moncton should accept the proposal -- because this private developer is honestly doing the city a favour for committing funds to such a poor downtown market.