City not throwing in towel on change room
Unisex facility 'different' but has advantages
Alexandra Zabjek
The Edmonton Journal
Tuesday, March 31, 2009
Plans to build a unisex change room with individual stalls at the Queen Elizabeth pool might be revisited, but the city doesn't want to abandon the controversial concept altogether.
The project has been placed in jeopardy since details of the change room design recently emerged.
The plans include a change room with 25 stalls that would be large enough to accommodate families or people with disabilities who require an attendant.
The change room would be open to men and women.
People would be expected to change in the stalls and not the main room.
That proposal is being vigorously opposed by the Friends of the Queen Elizabeth Pool Society, which has lobbied for years for the facility and has raised almost $400,000 for the project.
"We'd like to go down this path, recognizing that it's different than what we're used to in this city," said Rob Smyth, the city's manager of recreation facility services.
When asked if there might be any opportunity to redesign the change room, Smyth said, "I'm not going to say no."
However, the city must continue to "explore new ways of delivering services to the public," he said.
This isn't the first time Edmonton has pitched a "universal change room" for a swimming pool. Similar plans were unveiled for upgrades to the Fred Broadstock Outdoor Pool last year.
Smyth said those plans were nixed because the city was upgrading an existing building, which made the project more difficult.
That facility is oriented more towards young people than families, making such a change room less appropriate, he said.
"There was a little bit (of community concern). But not to this degree," he said.
The Queen Elizabeth pool would have separate, segregated washrooms for men and women. Lockers and showers are planned for the pool deck.
The "universal change room" was pitched, in part, to save money for the Queen Elizabeth pool's aquatic facilities, rather than its change areas.
But the design could end up costing a lot if the pool society pulls the rest of its funding -- as it has threatened to do unless the change room design is revisited.
The society has already donated $100,000 to the project.
The city has acknowledged that could put the entire $5.1-million project in jeopardy.
"What a shame it would be to build a brand new building and not have people feel safe or comfortable," said John Stobbe, a spokesman for the Society.
Stobbe said what's at issue is respectful community consultation and proper design.
"We're a partner in this project, but we don't feel like one," Stobbe said. "The reason we're in this position is because they've chosen not to bring people together."
Stobbe said it wouldn't be difficult to redesign the change room to create a men's change room, a women's change room, and a family change room.
Coun. Kim Krushell, who sits on the city's community services committee, said it would be a challenge to come up with more money for the project right now.
"I'd like to think there's some reasonable solution," she said.
Lifeguards could do "sweeps" through the universal change room to keep an eye on things.
As the mother of a nine-year-old boy, Krushell said she prefers to use facilities with some kind of family room.
"It would allow parents such as myself to take my son to a facility and avoid the awkward situation of sending him to the change room by himself," she said.
"From what I've seen, it makes sense to me."
Family change rooms with large cubicles exist in all Edmonton YMCAs, but there are age limits on who can use them.
At the TransAlta Tri Leisure Centre in Spruce Grove, family change rooms were "expected" when the facility was built in 2002, said Sylvia Gillespie, the centre's marketing and events co-ordinator.
Those change rooms consist of a number of fully enclosed rooms. The centre also has separate men's and women's change rooms.
[email protected]
Copyright © 2009 CanWest Interactive, a division of CanWest MediaWorks Publications, Inc.. All rights reserved.
CanWest Interactive, a division of CanWest MediaWorks Publications, Inc.. All rights reserved.
http://www2.canada.com/components/print.aspx?id=d1f53898-4398-4c65-b0c4-ac858e458c69&sponsor=