Local builders unconvincing in pitch for housing project
The StarPhoenix
Published: Wednesday, November 12, 2008
Re: Pick local firms: builders (SP, Nov. 4). It's amusing to see local builders tout themselves as charitable contributors to Saskatoon's social life and clamour over the Pleasant Hill affordable housing project.
They celebrate their own economic as opposed to ecological localism, and actually fail to connect the two. Left unsaid is that the builders have capitalized enormously on typically low-input/high-profit housing during the course of an inflated housing bubble now undergoing "market corrections."
Of course, this rarely is mentioned, given the tendency to naturalize the "healthy" business of home builders. Besides, in a precedent not confined to Saskatoon, benevolent displays of good corporate citizenship further the harvesting of future tenders and profit-making opportunities.
The builders predictably deride and derogate the proposal from Cenith, a company apparently committed to green building, energy efficiency and sustainable construction.
Keith Hanson's argument that green building technologies and green design don't stand up to scrutiny echoes the same rhetoric used by those who recently opposed LEED-based plans for the Station 20 West project and the River Landing proposal, claiming they are: unproven, unrealistic, too costly for public funds and not worth the risk.
The Cenith proposal may indeed have problems and stretch costs on the front end. Yet, I suspect these costs will pay for themselves over time. Notably, beyond the promise of local power generation and geothermal heating, Cenith's proposal actually offers 21 more units than the development foundation.
Yes, it would be wonderful to bring in Saskatoon-based, ecology-minded builders. If only there were any. Cenith is shrewdly positioning itself as the sustainable option.
Yet, the real risk is the current default setting: a tired approach to housing, affordable or otherwise, and the reliance on self-interested, for-profit builders to determine how communities ought to design and conceptualize the idea of house and home.
Neil Balan
Saskatoon
Source