Quote:
Originally Posted by circle33
Forgive me if this is posted already, but I was looking at this video concerning the "Urban Village" in Willowgrove. I found it both intriguing and sickening at the same time. It sounds like it's narrated by Big Kenny from those AIM Electric radio commercials, which probably accounts for the most of sickening factor.
Anyway, if you haven't already seen this....
look if you dare
|
Wow, what a great marketing tool to legitimize...but where will all these Urban Village residents work? No mention of an employment center, nor does this video speak to transit, instead one is left with the impression which the following image illustrates nicely (a back lane off Maguire Lane in Willowgrove):

Photo credit: Me
At least your kids will have a nice paved surface to play street hockey on
The marketing video strives to create something which already exists (existing core neighborhoods) and packages and presents Willowgrove Urban Village as a similar alternative to living in an inner city neighborhood...in some ways perhaps it is.
This is better than past suburban community design, but a complete slap in the face with respect to core development. It seems we must come to grips with Saskatoon continuing outward expansion (hopefully 50% of the growth is upward). As it stands with current municipal practices and objectives, the best we can hope for is appropriate transportation plans and adjacent employment centers are developed at the same pace as suburban communities to ensure minimal friction (traffic congestion, commute times, parking space demand will continue to increase for existing employment centers including Downtown, North End, and University) as our population increases further.
One final remark. If people pay a premium to live in Willowgrove's Urban Village we should expect similar design principles (new urbanism) for the large West Sector Blairmore SDA, the south east, east and continued northeast expansions.
I would much rather see less suburban development, but I am uncertain on whether necessary demographics, lifestyle choices have shifted enough or realizations occurred yet to support the huge push for dense development and gentrification in the core. We're approaching it though.
Might Willowgrove Urban Village be a final installment of suburban design and development in Saskatoon? Yeah right