c_speed3108
Active member
I check on the PRT corridor. VIA sold it to the Prescott Russell Recreational Trail Corporation in late 2021. (Not saying they couldn't buy it back, at least it's intact).
Ah, I wasn't aware of the 2021 sale. :shrug:
I check on the PRT corridor. VIA sold it to the Prescott Russell Recreational Trail Corporation in late 2021. (Not saying they couldn't buy it back, at least it's intact).
Not to add to the confusion but Alto’s social media specifically says Ottawa>Laval>Montreal. Who knows what it will actually be built as.
I’m inclined to agree that including Laval is an unnecessary cost and contributor to trip time, especially when you consider that most trips will likely be between Montreal and Ottawa/Toronto, meaning that most passengers will have to spend time stopping at Laval. Putting my tinfoil hat on for a sec, maybe it’s a hedge against a yes vote on Quebec independence.
On Alto website it's
![]()
It really depends how much the per ride subsidy would be. Unless they are very high train tickets would be prohibitive for commuting.
I highly doubt that Alto would want to go through the Quebec side of Ottawa River when the Ontario side has much much easier terrain. Some rock cuts on A-50 reach as high as 30 m and that road is only designed for 110 kph. Now imagine plowing through metamorphic rocks for a railway designed for 300 kph.
On Alto's website, there is a map showing where they have commissioned surveys. Given that the surveys commissioned in 2025 were mostly along a northerly route between Ottawa and Montreal, that should indicate where they are focusing their attention.
https://www.altotrain.ca/en/field-studies/field-studies
![]()
The vast majority are still going to drive as their final destinations aren't downtown at either or both ends. The vast majority living more than 30 minutes by public transport from either central station wherever that might be.
It really depends how much the per ride subsidy would be. Unless they are very high train tickets would be prohibitive for commuting.
It would be funny if the corridor goes through Mirabel and ends up reviving that airport.![]()
I expect that fares will at least cover operational costs.
In every other market with HSR, supercommuters are a massive proportion of users. Usually something like a third to half. And I would guess it's not people who travel everyday.
I was traveling in Spain on my Honeymoon and met a young lawyer taking the train from Cordoba to Seville. 150 km commute done in 45 mins. He explained to me that his job in Seville gets him a big city salary. Cordoba gives him small town life and affordability. He was was walking distance from the station on both ends. And only having to go in 2-3x per week made the whole thing worthwhile. That anecdote is a good one of supercommuters I'd expect. People who don't have to travel everyday. Mostly white collar. And they can get to either station in good time. Probably lots of people who do short them contracts. Etc.
By the way, there's a ton of people who already use VIA to commute from Coburg, Belleville, Or even London or Kingston to Toronto.
Super commuters being half to a third of customers seems implausible, what is your source for that? If that were the case you would expect to see large numbers of trains leaving at about 7 am and much lighter traffic during the day, and that is not what schedules look like. The first train from Cordova to Seville for example gets in after 9, even though Spanish work days start relatively early. On most routes the early morning trains are also the cheapest of the day, which again you would not expect if that train carried a third to a half of business.
Spain also has some of the most subsidized trains in the world, with the government heavily subsidizing individual tickets and passes in recent years. As well, Spain is a major recipient of EU infrastructure funding. A Spanish financial model would not readily apply to Canada.
Spain also has some of the most subsidized trains in the world, with the government heavily subsidizing individual tickets and passes in recent years. As well, Spain is a major recipient of EU infrastructure funding. A Spanish financial model would not readily apply to Canada.
The stat I read wasn't Spain specific. But if I find it I'll post. It jived with my observation taking our train at 11 am (I wasn't going to book an early train on vacation). Most passengers weren't dressed like tourists with luggage. It was mostly business travelers. Which also lines up with HSR eating in to air travel. I assume most travel is either business (for a meeting) or commuters in the less traditional sense of 9-5, say a patent lawyer going to the patent office for an afternoon. Clearly somebody who can afford a more expensive ticket isn't going to be doing this everyday and probably has way more flexibility than a 9-5er. A good chunk of them also worked during that train ride. Connectivity was surprisingly good.
Well not sure about the last point. If this is really going north of the Ottawa River its looks it will be a mostly Quebec line. With a few kilometers only built in Ontario. Add maybe a stop in Lachute that would be the Cordoba-like super commuter route. Quebec is absolutely the Spain or Hungary of Canada in terms of squeezing funds from the centre.
Quebec is nowhere near Spain in getting money for rail projects. Quebec is also probably unwilling to give the massive ticket subsidies that Spain does.