shivtim
New member
For what it's worth, the ARC estimates have been much more accurate than the census estimates, because they use richer local datasets. The 2009 census estimate was off by 121,000 compared to the actual 2010 count.
Yes, but is it a good thing?
If you look at ARC's data the growth is heavily centered on the city[/url]
I don't think that's entirely correct. While CoA is growing faster than it has (and a huge shift from the population trends of the 80s and 90s), the vast majority of the growth is still in the suburbs. You can see in the 2020-2023 numbers that only 11.8% of metro population growth was in the city (7553 / 63620). Even in 2022, which has promising numbers, while there were 10,078 multi-family unit permits in the city, there were 15,625 single family home permits outside of the city.
The city is growing faster than the rest of the metro. It still only has a small fraction of the total though, so of course the absolute number is low.
I've said this to plenty of people but Atlanta doesn't feel as big as what it is. Maybe it's because I've been here too long where Midtown/Downtown don't make me awe struck anymore, but cities like Boston/Seattle/Philly just feel bigger, even if Atlanta Metro is bigger.
It's not just their downtown cores, though those three cities have better cores for sure, but their immediate first ring within a few miles of downtown are significantly more densely populated with houses and businesses.
Even with all of the amazing growth the city has seen since I moved here, and the continued growth, I'm afraid it'll never match other cities without sweeping changes that few are willing to allow. I don't see Homepark being redeveloped en mass, or Ansley Park or Grant Park, etc. Our inner neighborhoods should/could house so many more people than they do, but it likely wont.
The Beltline has been amazing for the city, but at somepoint they're going to run out of industrial land to redevelop. Will the single family neighborhoods let themselves upzone then?
Well we are now 6 months before the 2024 Census MSA (and CSA) estimates are released. Seems we are mostly in agreement that we will make a whopping 2 place jump in the MSA to the #6 largest metro in the US.:cheers: I suppose it will be almost shocking if we only move past Philly but stay behind DC.
Since we had about 2.2% growth from 20 to 22 what do people think the rate will be this time? I'm feeling optimist that it may be over 2.5% and closer to 3%.
This will likely still leave is at #10 on the CSA but should move up to #9 by 26.
Anyone thinking differently?
I've said this to plenty of people but Atlanta doesn't feel as big as what it is. Maybe it's because I've been here too long where Midtown/Downtown don't make me awe struck anymore, but cities like Boston/Seattle/Philly just feel bigger, even if Atlanta Metro is bigger.
How "big" a city feels is an interesting concept. Of course the core "political cities" of Boston, Philly and Seattle are all more populous than the city of Atlanta. But one could make the same case that LA doesn't "feel" as big as Chicago.
Part of the answer is the density in the city and the feeling of many pedestrians on the streets. Having lived in Edinburgh, Scotland the feel of the "downtown" is one of packed sidewalks and constant buses and arriving trains, but it is not a metropolis and has far less than a million people in the metro area and Princes Street has probably more street traffic than any American city outside of NYC. In contrast, even our lauded Peachtree St. is a lazy thoroughfare (only exception might be at 14th Street where there is moderate activity).
Obviously a great part of this imagery is due to the fact that cars are not an easy option in these apparently "big" feel cities. In fact, many major cities in Europe simply restrict the use of private cars in the center and on major shopping streets.
I am always reminded of the reported "fact" that the entire center of Florence, It. would fit within the I285 -I75 interchange.
I've said this to plenty of people but Atlanta doesn't feel as big as what it is. Maybe it's because I've been here too long where Midtown/Downtown don't make me awe struck anymore, but cities like Boston/Seattle/Philly just feel bigger, even if Atlanta Metro is bigger.
How "big" a city feels is an interesting concept. Of course the core "political cities" of Boston, Philly and Seattle are all more populous than the city of Atlanta. But one could make the same case that LA doesn't "feel" as big as Chicago.
Part of the answer is the density in the city and the feeling of many pedestrians on the streets. Having lived in Edinburgh, Scotland the feel of the "downtown" is one of packed sidewalks and constant buses and arriving trains, but it is not a metropolis and has far less than a million people in the metro area and Princes Street has probably more street traffic than any American city outside of NYC. In contrast, even our lauded Peachtree St. is a lazy thoroughfare (only exception might be at 14th Street where there is moderate activity).
Obviously a great part of this imagery is due to the fact that cars are not an easy option in these apparently "big" feel cities. In fact, many major cities in Europe simply restrict the use of private cars in the center and on major shopping streets.
I am always reminded of the reported "fact" that the entire center of Florence, It. would fit within the I285 -I75 interchange.
I get what you're saying, but I have to disagree a bit. I travel all over the country for the work that I do and have for the last 35+ years. This is just my opinion, but of each of the cities you mentioned, only Philly "seems" bigger to me. Seattle and Boston don't. A comparison I like to make is that Atlanta, Houston, and Dallas all seemed about the same to me 25 or 30 years ago. But those two have clearly outpaced Atlanta over that time frame and now each seems, and in fact are, bigger. I also like to say Los Angeles is Atlanta on steroids.
Seattle and Boston do have more dense downtown cores. Metro Atlanta remains the least dense major metro in the nation. But, again, in my opinion, metro Atlanta seems bigger than both metro Seattle and metro Boston. And it is!
I've said this to plenty of people but Atlanta doesn't feel as big as what it is. Maybe it's because I've been here too long where Midtown/Downtown don't make me awe struck anymore, but cities like Boston/Seattle/Philly just feel bigger, even if Atlanta Metro is bigger.
How "big" a city feels is an interesting concept. Of course the core "political cities" of Boston, Philly and Seattle are all more populous than the city of Atlanta. But one could make the same case that LA doesn't "feel" as big as Chicago.
Part of the answer is the density in the city and the feeling of many pedestrians on the streets. Having lived in Edinburgh, Scotland the feel of the "downtown" is one of packed sidewalks and constant buses and arriving trains, but it is not a metropolis and has far less than a million people in the metro area and Princes Street has probably more street traffic than any American city outside of NYC. In contrast, even our lauded Peachtree St. is a lazy thoroughfare (only exception might be at 14th Street where there is moderate activity).
Obviously a great part of this imagery is due to the fact that cars are not an easy option in these apparently "big" feel cities. In fact, many major cities in Europe simply restrict the use of private cars in the center and on major shopping streets.
I am always reminded of the reported "fact" that the entire center of Florence, It. would fit within the I285 -I75 interchange.
There's really nothing special about Peachtree St. I'd love to see the city convert it to pedestrian only. This would be a huge boost for midtown/downtown and could change the area in a way the beltline did for other parts of town.
I've said this to plenty of people but Atlanta doesn't feel as big as what it is. Maybe it's because I've been here too long where Midtown/Downtown don't make me awe struck anymore, but cities like Boston/Seattle/Philly just feel bigger, even if Atlanta Metro is bigger.
How "big" a city feels is an interesting concept. Of course the core "political cities" of Boston, Philly and Seattle are all more populous than the city of Atlanta. But one could make the same case that LA doesn't "feel" as big as Chicago.
Part of the answer is the density in the city and the feeling of many pedestrians on the streets. Having lived in Edinburgh, Scotland the feel of the "downtown" is one of packed sidewalks and constant buses and arriving trains, but it is not a metropolis and has far less than a million people in the metro area and Princes Street has probably more street traffic than any American city outside of NYC. In contrast, even our lauded Peachtree St. is a lazy thoroughfare (only exception might be at 14th Street where there is moderate activity).
Obviously a great part of this imagery is due to the fact that cars are not an easy option in these apparently "big" feel cities. In fact, many major cities in Europe simply restrict the use of private cars in the center and on major shopping streets.
I am always reminded of the reported "fact" that the entire center of Florence, It. would fit within the I285 -I75 interchange.
There's really nothing special about Peachtree St. I'd love to see the city convert it to pedestrian only. This would be a huge boost for midtown/downtown and could change the area in a way the beltline did for other parts of town.
Please share this (in writing as public input) to Midtown Alliance! They are kicking off a process to reimagine Peachtree street in Midtown. We can all push for it to maximize ped/bike infrastructure.
not really, though it would be a non insignificant portion of it regardless - https://acme.com/same_scale/#33.90255,-84.26625,43.78082,11.25421,13,M,M (comparing spaghetti junction with florence)
How "big" a city feels is an interesting concept. Of course the core "political cities" of Boston, Philly and Seattle are all more populous than the city of Atlanta. But one could make the same case that LA doesn't "feel" as big as Chicago.
I get what you're saying, but I have to disagree a bit. I travel all over the country for the work that I do and have for the last 35+ years. This is just my opinion, but of each of the cities you mentioned, only Philly "seems" bigger to me. Seattle and Boston don't. A comparison I like to make is that Atlanta, Houston, and Dallas all seemed about the same to me 25 or 30 years ago. But those two have clearly outpaced Atlanta over that time frame and now each seems, and in fact are, bigger. I also like to say Los Angeles is Atlanta on steroids.
Seattle and Boston do have more dense downtown cores. Metro Atlanta remains the least dense major metro in the nation. But, again, in my opinion, metro Atlanta seems bigger than both metro Seattle and metro Boston. And it is!