US maglev thread


^ Yeah, I noticed that. Thanks.

Disneyland :koko:

Wouldn't a line Downtown L.A. - Downtown Las Vegas make a lot more sense?

No, because overall, Las Vegas attracts over 33 Million tourists every year. Don't you think more would travel from LA to LV than vice versa?
 
I have been talking about a high speed rail line proposed for Colorado's I-70 mountain corridor. It is congested and there isn't much room for making the interstate wider. Mag-lev has most recently been identified as ideal mode of transit for this corridor. It would initially be constructed from downtown Denver Union Station to Glenwood Springs.

it's target ridership would also (like the CA-LV proposal) be tourists. Million of annual tourists travel from Denver to ski resorts along or near the I-70 corridor. Currently, shuttle buses charter skiers from Denver to these resort--across icy, snowy and fairly dangerous roads. There is little doubt that riders would opt for the high speed mag-lev over these buses or driving rental cars. For the resorts which aren't right on a station, they could run these buses the final length--thus private charter bus companies wouldn't go out of business. they would actually have much shorter routes, but would have to carry the same number of passengers the rest of the way.

Polls indicate that this is what Coloradans want built in the corridor. The initial stretch would be built to Glenwood Springs (a popular mountain hot spring resort town). But there would be much pressure to extend it to the booming Western Slope city of Grand junction (approaching 100,000 people), near the Utah Border.

Utah and Salt lake City would at this point, probably want to extend it from Grand Junction to Provo (where it would share a transfer station with Utah's commuter rail line running north into Salt lake City).

With equal potential, Utah would look at extending the California-Las Vegas mag-lev a short distance to Saint Gorge, Utah.

What would be amazing and obvious about that--is at that point-- is that all which would be needed is a mag-lev extension from Saint Gorge, Utah to Provo, Utah, and we have Los Angles, Las Vegas, Salt Lake City and Denver all connected via Mag-lev. With the enormous amount of tourist destinations along the corridor to supplement the business and leisure ridership, this would have a high probability of success.

By this time, I would expect the Washington DC to Baltimore mag-lev line to have already been extended to Chicago. so if we have Los Angles to Denver mag-lev and Washington DC to Chicago mag-lev and nothing but open, flat land with a couple cities named Saint Louis and Kansas City, between Chicago and Denver, what do they do next?
 
Governors Agree to Back Fast Train

Trip between Vegas, Anaheim, Calif., could take only 86 minutes

By David McGrath Schwartz
December 22, 2008

For over 20 years, boosters have dreamed of and lobbied for a train that could travel from Southern California to Las Vegas at 300 mph.

The proposed magnetic levitation train line linking Las Vegas and Anaheim, Calif. — attacked by critics as a multi-billion dollar pipe dream — has gained new life.

Near the bottom of a news release detailing Gov. Jim Gibbons’ meeting last month with President-elect Barack Obama was the announcement that Gibbons and California Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger had agreed to move ahead with the high-speed train project.

“Arnold and I agreed to jointly work together on the project,” said Gibbons, who is planning to travel to Sacramento to talk with Schwarzenegger about it.

The train, Gibbons argues, should be a candidate for federal economic stimulus money.

The rail line, which would generally follow the route of Interstate 15 and cost between $12 billion and $13 billion, would create construction jobs on both sides of the state line and, once complete, speed the arrival of tourists to Las Vegas. (A trip between Las Vegas and Anaheim could take as little as 86 minutes.)

In June, Sen. Harry Reid, the Democratic majority leader, helped pass a bill that freed up $45 million for an environmental study of the route.

Obama and his advisers have been working with Congress on an economic stimulus package that would improve infrastructure and put people to work. The Washington Post on Friday put the size of the stimulus at $850 billion.

Yet to the critics, the bill is in danger of becoming one big pile of pork.

“We’re not exactly big fans of congressional earmarks, we’re also not a fan of just sending a big box of cash to states and cities for their own version of parochial pork barrel project,” said Steve Ellis, vice president of Taxpayers for Common Sense, a national nonpartisan budget watchdog group.

A push for the maglev project — a proposal which, he notes, “certainly has its detractors” — would add to the impression that special interests, states, cities and transportation advocates are behaving like greedy children with dreams of getting a pony for Christmas. (Las Vegas Mayor Oscar Goodman said last week that a new city hall, mob museum and performing arts center should be included in the stimulus package.)

But Ellis said any economic stimulus should yield an immediate benefit. The maglev project could take a decade or more to build. The federally required environmental impact study of the project would take from 18 months to two years.

“Something should get done,” Ellis said. “It should not be something that slowly bleeds, and the impact isn’t felt until after the recession is over.”

The Regional Transportation Commission of Southern Nevada will hold a news conference today with Reid to announce 60 projects that are “ready to go” within 180 days.

Jacob Snow, the RTC’s general manager, said these projects total about $1 billion, and include highway projects, interchanges, street paving and mass transit projects.

Snow wouldn’t comment specifically on the maglev project, but said: “We certainly think some sort of facility like maglev, a high-speed rail system between Southern California and Southern Nevada, is needed. No doubt about that.”

The first leg is planned for Las Vegas to Primm.

Reid spokesman Jon Summers said it’s too early to know what projects would be included in a federal economic stimulus bill. But a high-speed train between Las Vegas and Southern California “not only makes good economic sense for the state, it makes sense from an environmental and energy perspective as well,” he said.

Reid “supports any project that moves people quickly and safely between Nevada and California,” Summers said, citing frequent traffic jams on I-15.

Amtrak ended service between Las Vegas and Los Angeles in 1995.

Reid requested the Government Accountability Office prepare a feasibility study on a rail project between Las Vegas and Southern California, which Summers said should be out in the next three months.

The maglev, or magnetic-levitation, train would require a new set of “rails” — the train, suspended above the track by magnets, rides on a cushion of air. There are few commercial maglev trains operating worldwide, including in Japan and Shanghai, China.

A competing proposal for a faster train between Southern Nevada and Southern California would use conventional rails. That privately funded line would, however, run between Victorville, Calif., and Las Vegas.

Reid has criticized that project because he doesn’t think people will drive from Los Angeles to Victorville and then board a train to Las Vegas.

Bruce Aguilera, chairman of the Nevada-California Super Speed Train Commission, which oversees the maglev project, welcomed news of the governor’s support for the maglev project being included in an economic stimulus package.

Aguilera, who is also vice president and general counsel at MGM Mirage’s Bellagio, acknowledged that the maglev group has kept a low profile in recent years.

“We didn’t have things to say,” Aguilera said.

The project’s backers will break their silence next month, announcing how they plan to raise $11.25 million in matching funds needed to access the $45 million in federal funding.

With that money, Aguilera said, they plan to open an office in Las Vegas, start paying a staff member who has been working on a volunteer basis and re-launch their Web site.
 
MagLev isn't that much faster than electric powered HSR trains.
The highest recorded speed of a maglev train is 581 km/h (361 mph), achieved in Japan in 2003, 6 km/h faster than the conventional TGV speed record.

Since California will be building electric powered HSR trains from L.A. to S.F., why not use the same line north to the high desert, then branch off towards Las Vegas.

The best-known high-speed maglev currently operating commercially is the IOS (initial operating segment) demonstration line of the German built Transrapid train in Shanghai, China that transports people 30 km (18.6 miles) to the airport in just 7 minutes 20 seconds, achieving a top speed of 431 km/h (268 mph), averaging 250 km/h (150 mph).

Look at the speed, distance, and elapsed time ratios:
Distance between L.A. and L.V. = 278 mi
Automobile per Google Maps = 255 minutes (up to 330 mins in traffic)

MagLev
Real Operation Speed = These trains regularly run around 268 mph.
Elapsed Time = 62 minutes

HSR
Real Operation Speed = These trains regularly run around 200 mph.
Elapsed Time = 83 minutes

Commercially operating MagLev is actually faster than electric power High Speed Rail by just 21 minutes.

Of course, Transrapid technology uses conventional electromagnets and attractive-type electromagnetic suspension (EMS).
Japan has a demonstration line in Yamanashi prefecture where test trains JR-Maglev MLX01 have reached 581 km/h (361 mph), slightly faster than any wheeled trains (the current TGV speed record is 574.8 km/h, 357.0 mph). These trains use superconducting magnets which allow for a larger gap, and repulsive-type electrodynamic suspension (EDS).
In current electromagnetic suspension (EMS) systems, the train levitates above a steel rail while electromagnets, attached to the train, are oriented toward the rail from below. The electromagnets use feedback control to maintain a train at a constant distance from the track, at approximately 15 millimeters (0.6 in).
In new technology electrodynamic suspension (EDS), both the rail and the train exert a magnetic field, and the train is levitated by the repulsive force between these magnetic fields. At slow speeds, the current induced in these coils and the resultant magnetic flux is not large enough to support the weight of the train. For this reason the train must have wheels or some other form of landing gear to support the train until it reaches a speed that can sustain levitation. Another disadvantage for EDS trains are strong magnetic fields onboard the train would make the train inaccessible to passengers with pacemakers or magnetic data storage media such as hard drives and credit cards, necessitating the use of magnetic shielding, and limitations on guideway inductivity limit the maximum speed of the vehicle.

If I was building the L.A. to L.V. line, I would save lots of money using the first 30 or so miles of the L.A. to S.F. line, including the tunnels through the San Gabriel Mountains. Saving 21 minutes isn't worth building 30+ more miles of ROW, nor building new tunnels.
 
Last edited:
MagLev isn't that much faster than electric powered HSR trains.
The highest recorded speed of a maglev train is 581 km/h (361 mph), achieved in Japan in 2003, 6 km/h faster than the conventional TGV speed record.

Since California will be building electric powered HSR trains from L.A. to S.F., why not use the same line north to the high desert, then branch off towards Las Vegas.
While I agree with you that a single technology is ideal in many circumstances, remember, that TGV and rail is not sustainable at those speeds. The track needed major maintenance, and it took a LONG straight run to reach that speed. About 140km of track were set aside for the TGV test, The Japanese Mag-lev reached 581km/h in 10-15km, considering the entire test track is only 18km (taking into account safety margins and deceleration time). It is also capable of much higher speeds as well. Mag-levs best traits are its acceleration, not its max speed. Japanese HSR trains are renowned for their acceleration. If you can't travel at your max speed for more than a few minutes before starting to decelerate for the next stop, then what is the point?
The best-known high-speed maglev currently operating commercially is the IOS (initial operating segment) demonstration line of the German built Transrapid train in Shanghai, China that transports people 30 km (18.6 miles) to the airport in just 7 minutes 20 seconds, achieving a top speed of 431 km/h (268 mph), averaging 250 km/h (150 mph).
Unfortunately, the transrapid maglev can not practically reach its top speed and decelerate (although it reached 501km/h in a test run) in a mere 30km. That being said, a station to station average of 250km/h is pretty impressive in just 30km. Conventional Rail can only exceed that on longer runs of at least 160km between stations. Mag-levs benefits are not so much the ability to travel faster, but rather, the ability to make more stops without affecting average travel time very much. Of course, this is more attractive in densely populated nations like Japan and some European countries, but it has practical benefits as well, if implemented on the right corridors in the US as well.
Look at the speed, distance, and elapsed time ratios:
Distance between L.A. and L.V. = 278 mi
Automobile per Google Maps = 255 minutes (up to 330 mins in traffic)

MagLev
Real Operation Speed = These trains regularly run around 268 mph.
Elapsed Time = 62 minutes

HSR
Real Operation Speed = These trains regularly run around 200 mph.
Elapsed Time = 83 minutes

Commercially operating MagLev is actually faster than electric power High Speed Rail by just 21 minutes.
I haven't checked your calculations, but have you taken into account that maglevs are able to maintain a MUCH higher average speed than HSR? Because on known systems, HSR is lucky to average 160-180km/h including stops on long runs. The Nozomi Shinkansen in Japan use (I believe) the fastest accelerating trainsets, and while their max speed is limited to 270km/h due to this being the original Shinkansen track from the 60s, they only make one stop in Nagoya and Kyoto after leaving Tokyo... and they average ~220km/h. Shinkansen trains don't make long stops. Trust me on this. 60 seconds, if you're lucky. Compare this to the 30km run in Shanghai, which averages 250km/h on a 30km run and factor in longer distances and you'll end up with faster trips, I'm sure. I'd hazard a guess that Mag-lev could average 450km/h in many cases.

All that being said, given that much of the line passes through a desert, and that there will likely be fewer stops (if I'm not mistaken), HSR may very well be the right choice, however, I just wanted to point out that the key benefit of Mag-lev is not only greater speed, but also less wear and tear on components at higher speeds (caternary wires, tracks, bogies are all affected by friction) and much higher acceleration.

Of course, Transrapid technology uses conventional electromagnets and attractive-type electromagnetic suspension (EMS).
Japan has a demonstration line in Yamanashi prefecture where test trains JR-Maglev MLX01 have reached 581 km/h (361 mph), slightly faster than any wheeled trains (the current TGV speed record is 574.8 km/h, 357.0 mph).
Slightly faster TOP speed. But undoubtedly a MUCH faster potential average speed. The planned maglev line between Tokyo and Osaka will cut the trip down to 60 minutes, from about 145 min. on the Super Express. That's an AVERAGE of about 500km/h including stops (fewer than current Tokaido line)
If I was building the L.A. to L.V. line, I would save lots of money using the first 30 or so miles of the L.A. to S.F. line, including the tunnels through the San Gabriel Mountains. Saving 21 minutes isn't worth building 30+ more miles of ROW, nor building new tunnels.

On this route, I'd be inclined to agree with you. Even though I think mag-lev has useful applications, I think that they fit better in highly developed corridors.
 
Look at the speed, distance, and elapsed time ratios:
Distance between L.A. and L.V. = 278 mi
Automobile per Google Maps = 255 minutes (up to 330 mins in traffic)

MagLev
Real Operation Speed = These trains regularly run around 268 mph.
Elapsed Time = 62 minutes

HSR
Real Operation Speed = These trains regularly run around 200 mph.
Elapsed Time = 83 minutes

your calculation are very flawed. you need to take into account maglev's MUCH higher acceleration and also i could run at way higher than 268mph. it could probably run at 300mph, and reach that speed much quicker than HSR, therefore run at that speed for much longer.
 
the Baltimore-Washington project, estimated to cost $3.7 billion in 2002 dollars.

...

The Maglev, with its 18-minute projected travel time between the two cities,

As it is, an Acela train leaving DC and making no intermediate stops takes 30 mins on schedule to depart from DC and then depart from Penn Station in Charm City.

$3.7 Billion to save 12 minutes?

:gtfo2:
 
Wikipedia claims that the fastest test speed of a maglev was at 361 miles per hour. I think a very modern, new maglev constructed between Vegas and LA could approach those speeds if it didn't have all that many stops. Then it could only take around 30 minutes to get there.

Going to Vegas could go from an arrive Friday, leave Sunday by car into a leave at 5pm, arrive at 6 and arrive back by midnight sort of deal. All for under $200 I would imagine.

WOW this just became a whole lot more exciting to me. Originally I was like "no way, its a gimmick" but now, so long as it leads into LA and not just Annehiem, it looks very attractive.
 
Wikipedia claims that the fastest test speed of a maglev was at 361 miles per hour. I think a very modern, new maglev constructed between Vegas and LA could approach those speeds if it didn't have all that many stops. Then it could only take around 30 minutes to get there.

Going to Vegas could go from an arrive Friday, leave Sunday by car into a leave at 5pm, arrive at 6 and arrive back by midnight sort of deal. All for under $200 I would imagine.

WOW this just became a whole lot more exciting to me. Originally I was like "no way, its a gimmick" but now, so long as it leads into LA and not just Annehiem, it looks very attractive.

Highest Test Speeds are obtained on brand new tracks/guideways where certain safety trip features are turned off.

While it is true that the distance between Las Vegas and Los Angeles is much longer than test tracks and guideways in operations, and that the average MegLev speeds may eventually be higher than what I posted earlier, the fact remains these are the top and average speeds of what exists in commercial operation today.

I don't think Congress and State Legislatures are going to approve spending $Billions on systems that aren't commercial, "off-the-shelf" equipment and technology.

Even California's proposed HSR train will not be traveling at 250 mph until it reaches the rural areas of the Valley. Likewise, neither will MegLev vehicles. Anything moving that fast is going to make a lot of noise. You can count on speeds on both vehicle choices will be reduced in urban and suburban areas.

California is going to have to build new tunnels and tracks for the HSR train through the mountains north of L.A. If MegLev is chosen for L.A. to L.V. more new tunnels and guideways will have to be built through the same mountains. At least HSR trains on both corridors, to S.F. and L.V. can use the same tunnels and tracks through the mountains. That alone will save taxpayers $Billions.
And that's my major point.

My second point is that the time savings isn't going to be worth the extra expense. There will be station stops along the way, slowing either technology down. There will be environmental concerns along the route that will slow either technology down. Neither will travel at the absolute fastest test speeds. At some point in speed, wind resistance gets too high for commercial economical operations.
 
Ever read about mag-lev in an air tight vacuum tube? Speeds of up to 5,000mph will be possible and no energy will be required to maintain speed, once acceleration has occurred (no wind resistance). Passenger seats would rotation 180 degrees for deceleration, so to keep people firmly and comfortably in their seats. Stops would probably be something like this:

Los Angles-Las Vegas-Denver-Chicago-New York

Cost would probably be in the trillions ($4-$10 trillion USD), but it may be extended through the Atlantic ocean to London at some point in the future (for an additional $10 trillion USD).
 
Maglev in America, eh?

indifferent0018.gif


Mmm hmm, sure..
 
Ever read about mag-lev in an air tight vacuum tube? Speeds of up to 5,000mph will be possible and no energy will be required to maintain speed, once acceleration has occurred (no wind resistance). Passenger seats would rotation 180 degrees for deceleration, so to keep people firmly and comfortably in their seats. Stops would probably be something like this:

Los Angles-Las Vegas-Denver-Chicago-New York

Cost would probably be in the trillions ($4-$10 trillion USD), but it may be extended through the Atlantic ocean to London at some point in the future (for an additional $10 trillion USD).

I've heard of this. Its called Vactrain technology.
 
Why does California need it the most?

MegLevs are for travelers going long distances.

What's the average auto trip distance in California?
Page 18 Table 6 of the 2001 National Household Travel Survey indicates that average person distance per trip is 6 - 12 miles, with work commutes generally being longer than shopping trips or other errands. But that's an average, and based on survey responses. It's quite possible that the majority of trips are much shorter than the average.
 
Frankly, I don't think there's a single place in the United States that's ready for maglev. Everywhere, including CA and the NE, needs to focus on more basic needs at this point.

In the NE, for example, traditional HSR far superior to Acela could be had with some relatively simple track upgrades along the corridor. Instead of investing in a fancy new maglev, we could do that and then spend the leftover money on better local transit.
 
Ever read about mag-lev in an air tight vacuum tube? Speeds of up to 5,000mph will be possible and no energy will be required to maintain speed, once acceleration has occurred (no wind resistance). Passenger seats would rotation 180 degrees for deceleration, so to keep people firmly and comfortably in their seats. Stops would probably be something like this:

Los Angles-Las Vegas-Denver-Chicago-New York

Cost would probably be in the trillions ($4-$10 trillion USD), but it may be extended through the Atlantic ocean to London at some point in the future (for an additional $10 trillion USD).

I suspect the bolded "no"s should be changed to "very little"s. You can't afterall, create a complete vacuum. Friction will still exist.
 


Back
Top