US maglev thread


Highest Test Speeds are obtained on brand new tracks/guideways where certain safety trip features are turned off.
Correct. HSR is mature technology and is stretched to its limits to make these speeds. This is due to running on a technology that was invented centuries ago. Steel Rails. Mag-lev is still in its infancy, and will run regularly at 500km/h in its first iterations.

Similar to comparing propeller planes with early jet turbine engines. There were prop planes that could run as fast, or faster than jet planes. However, they were stretched to their limits. Jet turbines have since taken over.

While it is true that the distance between Las Vegas and Los Angeles is much longer than test tracks and guideways in operations, and that the average MagLev speeds may eventually be higher than what I posted earlier, the fact remains these are the top and average speeds of what exists in commercial operation today.
Yes, which are much faster than the average speeds of HSR in commercial operation today. Shanghai Mag-lev have run 501km/h during commercial runs. I don't know ANY high-speed rail that has done that. The French run was a specialized case.

I don't think Congress and State Legislatures are going to approve spending $Billions on systems that aren't commercial, "off-the-shelf" equipment and technology.
HSR isn't off-the-shelf, either.
Even California's proposed HSR train will not be traveling at 250 mph until it reaches the rural areas of the Valley. Likewise, neither will MagLev vehicles. Anything moving that fast is going to make a lot of noise. You can count on speeds on both vehicle choices will be reduced in urban and suburban areas.
This is where Mag-lev really shines. Its faster acceleration will enable it to get up to speed in rural areas much more quickly, increasing the average speed overall.
California is going to have to build new tunnels and tracks for the HSR train through the mountains north of L.A. If MegLev is chosen for L.A. to L.V. more new tunnels and guideways will have to be built through the same mountains. At least HSR trains on both corridors, to S.F. and L.V. can use the same tunnels and tracks through the mountains. That alone will save taxpayers $Billions.
And that's my major point.
Interestingly, the Japanese Mag-lev has the possibility of running on regular HSR rails, with the addition of magnetic side-panels on the HSR tracks. This has the added benefit that it will be able to be easily converted to standard high-speed rail if need be.
My second point is that the time savings isn't going to be worth the extra expense. There will be station stops along the way, slowing either technology down. There will be environmental concerns along the route that will slow either technology down. Neither will travel at the absolute fastest test speeds. At some point in speed, wind resistance gets too high for commercial economical operations.

The stops will have less of an effect on a technology that can accelerate faster. This is the main benefit of Mag-lev. That, along with a higher max speed.

I'm not making a case as to whether it's actually worth it or not. But these are factors that are worth considering.
 
Your average top speed in many cases will be no better than conventional high speed rail because you need the right track geometries. Turns or gradients will quickly slow you down and give you no better performance than standard rail.
 
Your average top speed in many cases will be no better than conventional high speed rail because you need the right track geometries. Turns or gradients will quickly slow you down and give you no better performance than standard rail.

Given that the HSR in California will be built to a 6000m radius, this won't be a problem. Japan's Shinkansen currently runs 4000m radius on its highest speed line. Its Mag-lev will be built to 8000m.

BUT, even if it were an issue...

where:
Train A = HSR
Train B = Mag-Lev :

Train A enters a 1500m curve at the curve's max speed of 150mph.
Train B enters a 1500m curve at the curve's max speed of 150mph.

Train A takes 10 minutes to resume cruising speed.
Train B takes 2 minutes to resume cruising speed.

(numbers are made up, but you can see where I'm going with this)

If there's another curve a few minutes down the road, HSR won't even GET to its cruising speed.

In other words, the more frequently the track forces the train to slow down, the greater advantage that Mag-lev has (within reason, we're obviously not talking about twisting canyon tracks.)

Of course, in reality, you built the track with as wide curves as possible.

Most of the curves will be in city limits anyhow, which will have limited speed due to noise restrictions.

Mag-lev is generally quieter, so in urban areas, the mag-lev would likely be able to travel at higher speeds.
 
why do you think that?

the NE is home to the most heavily populated area in the US and it already supports rail culture.

And so is California, especially recently. But population isn't everything. The car dependency in California is far greater than that of the NE, not to mention the pollution.
 
Given that the HSR in California will be built to a 6000m radius, this won't be a problem. Japan's Shinkansen currently runs 4000m radius on its highest speed line. Its Mag-lev will be built to 8000m.

BUT, even if it were an issue...

where:
Train A = HSR
Train B = Mag-Lev :

Train A enters a 1500m curve at the curve's max speed of 150mph.
Train B enters a 1500m curve at the curve's max speed of 150mph.

Train A takes 10 minutes to resume cruising speed.
Train B takes 2 minutes to resume cruising speed.

(numbers are made up, but you can see where I'm going with this)

If there's another curve a few minutes down the road, HSR won't even GET to its cruising speed.

In other words, the more frequently the track forces the train to slow down, the greater advantage that Mag-lev has (within reason, we're obviously not talking about twisting canyon tracks.)

Of course, in reality, you built the track with as wide curves as possible.

Most of the curves will be in city limits anyhow, which will have limited speed due to noise restrictions.

Mag-lev is generally quieter, so in urban areas, the mag-lev would likely be able to travel at higher speeds.

I think you give Meg-Lev too many advantages.

From http://perso.numericable.fr/~lucweb/lgvmed/eng/faq.htm
A standard braking profile from 300 km/h to full stop has been defined, it is 5 blocks length, 1500 m each. So, a TGV that runs at full speed will need around 7.5 km to stop "smoothly".

Likewise, it'll take just as long with either train technology to accelerate "smoothly" to a certain speed!

What do I mean by "smoothly"?
How fast a train can accelerate or deaccelerate without passenger discomfort. Keeping passengers from heaving, retching, or spewing is the limiting factor.
 
Your average top speed in many cases will be no better than conventional high speed rail because you need the right track geometries. Turns or gradients will quickly slow you down and give you no better performance than standard rail.

I have heard stories about Shanghai's Maglev shaking at top speed.
 
As noted, conventional HSR trainsets—in fact, nearly any electric motor propulsion vehicle—can accelerate much more rapidly than they do in practice. The limiting factor is passenger discomfort, not technology.
 
When's the last time you saw someone wretching on a Jumbo jet that's still on the tarmac?

The limiting factor to passenger discomfort is sudden changes in direction at high speeds, not during acceleration. Thus, when turbulence drops a plane, people wretch.

If acceleration was limited by passenger comfort, I doubt the Japanese would've spent so much money on making their trains faster. If it was just a matter of turning up the juice, I doubt the Japanese would've made such a big deal about increasing the acceleration of their trains:

Acceleration has been improved too. The N700 benefits from a 30% increase in acceleration performance and now meets the acceleration standards of commuter trains – at 2.6km/h/s – reducing the amount of time needed to reach maximum speed. In service the trains will be permitted to travel at a maximum speed of 270km/h on the Tokaido Shinkansen and 300km/h on the Sanyo Shinkansen.
source

By comparison, the Jumbo Jet above is 9.97 km/h/s. Of course, a plane is hardly smooth on takeoff, but you know what I mean. That's considerably faster to accelerate.

According to this article the Shinkansen N700 goes 0-60 in 37seconds. The fastest accelerating conventional train still is half as slow to accelerate than a 3-cylinder 1992 Geo Metro.

In other words, train acceleration is rarely a case of passenger discomfort.

If you've ever been on a Shinkansen, you'd know that it's hard to know when the train even starts moving, unless you're looking out the window.

I've never seen anything documented about Chinese people throwing up on the Shanghai mag-lev. And if you watch the Japanese Test Run video, you'll notice no one holding on for dear life.

Though it's possible that it may be an issue, I've never read or heard of (straight-line) acceleration being a comfort problem on Mag-lev.

Of course, direction changes around curves at high speeds may be an issue... but that's a different matter...
 
The main issue is cost. If they get mag-lev costs down, suddenly people will listen; powerful people.

The powerful people,
Powerful people...
The powerful people,
Powerful people...
 
Ok I haven't read any comments on here, but I know some people don't like Maglev because it doesn't go as fast on curves. Well, The trip from L.A to Las Vegas doesn't have many curves, correct?
 
Ok I haven't read any comments on here, but I know some people don't like Maglev because it doesn't go as fast on curves. Well, The trip from L.A to Las Vegas doesn't have many curves, correct?

The issue wasn't that it didn't go as fast around curves... it was that the speed benefits would be lost because it would have to slow down to the same speed as other trains around curves.

However, it was pointed out that a prime benefit of mag-lev would be its ability to recover its speed more quickly.

In any case, you are correct, any high speed line built between LA and Las Vegas would be built to modern high-speed standards, which like would include a minimum 5000m radius... making slowing down for curves less of a necessity.
 
Curves? What curves... You just cut right through those mountains and bridge right over em valleys. No need for curves ;-)
 


Back
Top