Council votes to delay clear-cutting
Developer says conditions met for South March Highlands project
http://www.ottawacitizen.com/techno...cutting/3279234/story.html?cid=megadrop_story
BY KATE JAIMET, THE OTTAWA CITIZEN JULY 14, 2010 11:02 PM
City council passed a motion Wednesday that could delay the planned clear-cutting of 20 hectares of pristine forest in the South March Highlands.
The motion would stop the developer, KNL Development Limited, from cutting down trees in the area north of Kanata’s Beaver Pond until it has met certain conditions, including a city-approved tree planting and conservation plan.
KNL, a partnership between development companies Urbandale and Richcraft, has said it plans to begin clear-cutting the forest Monday. Before the meeting, the company sent a letter to city councillors saying it believed it had “followed all city policies and requirements for the draft plan approval in order to proceed with the development.”
The letter said the company understood the concerns of nearby residents, but it was just living up to the terms of an agreement made 28 years ago. It’s building on land that was approved for development when other property — including Trillium Woods — was preserved as natural area, and, now that it has met all the conditions, KNL plans to go ahead.
“The developer says their tree-preservation plan has been approved. City staff says it has not been approved,” Kanata North Councillor Marianne Wilkinson said. “I take the direction that city staff are the ones to tell us if something has been approved or not.”
Besides the tree conservation plan, the motion mentions four other plans that KNL must develop and have approved by the city before it can begin cutting trees:
-a communications strategy acceptable to the city’s director of planning;
-an archeological plan;
-a natural features and vegetation preservation plan; and
-a city-approved storm water management plan.
The required plans are among a list of 89 conditions that were agreed upon several years ago by KNL and the city and have been upheld by the Ontario Municipal Board.
Wilkinson said she was concerned that, if the city was lax in enforcing the conditions, it could face a lawsuit from citizens opposing the development, which would destroy part of the ecologically significant South March Highlands.
“I know the trees will come down eventually. I’m not trying to stop that.… I just want to make sure it’s squeaky-clean,” Wilkinson said. “Hopefully, if they look at it some more, they can find some place where they can save some trees. I don’t know.”
Mayor Larry O’Brien expressed concern that KNL could undertake legal action if the city delayed its development plans. In response to the mayor’s comments, city solicitor Tim Marc informed council that KNL filed documents with the Ontario Municipal Board on Wednesday morning, asking for clarification of the 89 conditions.
In accordance with the motion, city staff will send a letter to KNL saying that, until the conditions are met and approved by the city, “no clear cutting or other site modification can occur in the South March Highlands.”
As well, city staff are directed “to pursue all legal means, including an injunction, in the event that KNL fails to comply.”
Council also passed a motion asking staff to negotiate a land-exchange with KNL that would allow the city to retain a 20-metre-wide, wooded corridor through the KNL development lands, linking Beaver Pond to Trillium Woods. The specific land-exchange would have to be approved by council after the staff negotiations.
City staff and developers will also face questioning from the community tonight at a public meeting.
Councillors Jan Harder and Peter Hume supported the motion, but warned it would not change the fact that trees would eventually be cut and the area would be developed.
Councillors Diane Holmes and Alex Cullen said the city should go further to try to save the forest. “If we were interested in stopping development, we would be expropriating these lands and putting them to public use, and that would be what I think the public wants,” Cullen said.
© Copyright (c) The Ottawa Citizen