New subdivision developments


Alas, the development planned for Connaught Park is but a reflection of the disastrous development situation attacking old Aylmer for some time now. Aylmer has suffered an invasion by real estate developers who have stampeded to build without a second glance towards the citizens of Aylmer. No one has considered how this rampant development will affect the quality of life of the residents here. There is a price to pay for the suburbanization, as much at the level of building infrastructure as at the level of creating social services such as schools and leisure equipment. If our elected representatives are patting themselves on the back for this blessing that fell from the skies, I’d ask them to look ahead ten or twenty years. When the developers have gone off in search of new opportunity, we’ll be left holding the bill for the broken pots. This is when the blows will hurt.

If this “progress” can’t be stopped, at least it can be managed and controlled. The old municipal administration included this management in its policy planning and took steps to slow urban sprawl and residential development. If by grace, Aylmer’s heart manages to hold onto its soul, especially thanks to the recent renovations in Old Aylmer, the rest of Aylmer is suffering. I believe the members of the municipal council must be more vigilant about this issue. It is never to late to do right, sirs!

When I look around at what’s happening to my municipality, there are days when I dearly miss the old city of Aylmer.

I hear a lot of complaints for Aylmerois about how their area has been overdeveloped with sprawl since the merger, but the truth is that pretty much everything that has been built in Aylmer since the merger was done according to plans approved by the former city of Aylmer. These things are usually planned well in advance.

It may not be the case for the Les Golfs development, which is new, but for the rest of Aylmer, the municipal administrations of Constance Provost, and Marc Croteau after her, paved the way for paving Aylmer's paradise long before anyone had ever heard of the new, merged city of Gatineau.

It's a bit rich for people like her to come back now and blamed the merged city for planning decisions made many years ago, including many under her régime.
 
Proposed density increase elicits big reaction
Posted May 20, 2010
BY STEPH WILLEMS
http://www.emcbarrhaven.ca/20100520/news/Proposed+density+increase+elicits+big+reaction

EMC News - A May 6 community meeting concerning a proposal by Richcraft Homes for low-rise condominiums in an existing neighbourhood revealed that nearby residents aren't happy with what they're hearing.

Richcraft is seeking an Official Plan and Secondary Plan amendment to change the zoning of its six-acre parcel of land on Mountshannon Dr. (off of Longfields Dr.) from 'low-density residential' to 'mixed-density residential' to allow for the construction of 210 condo-style apartments in 12 low-rise buildings.

Residents at the meetingwhich was arranged by Barrhaven ward Coun. Jan Harder and featured representatives from the developer, its consulting firm, and the city's planning department said they were unsatisfied with the proposal, calling it too dense and out of place given that surrounding buildings are single-family detached homes. Many worried about an increase of traffic on their street, leading to a safety hazard for pedestrians and cyclists, while others worried their property would be devalued if the three-and-a-half story buildings were built.

Richcraft representative Kevin Yemm responded to these concerns by saying this development follows closely the city's recent Official Plan mandate for intensification, which calls for increased density and infill on existing land near transit routes, which would maximize existing sewer, water, transit and road infrastructure.

"The Official Plan supports the development that we're proposing," said Mr. Yemm prior to his presentation. "A vacant field would never maximize the infrastructure to its potential...This would meet the density targets that the councillors voted for."

The land in question has a long history. When the subdivision was laid out in the 1990's, as required, a parcel of land was set aside for possible institutional use. Regulations called for the land to be held for seven years, during which time the school board decided to proceed with construction of a school on a different property. When the time was up, the land went on the market, although other school boards, if interested, were allowed to have first dibs. There were no takers, and Richcraft purchased the six acres in 2004.

"There's been no interest from school boards on this site since the mid-90's," said Miguel Tremblay, a senior planner with FoTenn Planning & Urban Design.

In 2005, Richcraft came forward with a proposal for 85 townhomes on the site, but this too was poorly received by residents for many of the same reasons. The current proposal, which would feature more than double the amount of units from the previous proposal, allows for 288 outdoor parking spaces with an internal roadway and one entry point. The previous proposal featured garages and driveways with parking for two or more vehicles per unit.

A comparable development to the current proposal would be Richcraft's Jade Condo Flats, which are under construction adjacent to the Strandherd Park & Ride.

While several residents argued that the traffic on Mountshannon Dr. has already been too high for several years, the traffic study commissioned by Richcraft and submitted to the city concluded that the roadway has the capacity to accommodate extra cars. Many in attendance scoffed when told the study was conducted in January, when the roads would have few cyclists and pedestrians.

Colin White, senior planner for the City of Ottawa, told the EMC that city engineers and transportation experts are currently reviewing the study, after which they will conclude whether or not the study's assertion that the roadway has the extra capacity is true or not.

Mr. White did say that the community was designed to have that land developed, and that the collector road function of Mountshannon Dr. was designed to accommodate additional traffic. However, city transportation experts will ultimately have the final say on whether it can or not.

When asked why single-family homes weren't on the drawing board, the crowd of 50 was told that a six-acre plot doesn't lend itself easily to singles, and that because land values are no longer at 1997 prices, it would make those homes expensive.

Concerns arose about whether the location of the property was close enough to transit services to warrant special consideration under the Official Plan. To this, Mr. Tremblay responded, "A project doesn't have to be abutting a service to be close to it."

Mr. Tremblay pointed out that Mountshannon Dr. is served by an OC Transpo route, and that the property will be 860 metres from the future Longfields Transitway Station, which is currently under construction.

Answers to questions concerning the exact details on the project were not readily available given that this is the earliest stage of the project. Coun. Harder was unable to attend the meeting as she was handing out awards to two longtime Barrhaven residents at city hall, but she alerted her constituents to the situation via a mail-out, and said she plans to hold subsequent meetings as soon as more information and analysis is made available.

Coun. Harder added that she was not surprised that the development was greeted in a hostile manner.

"There are a couple of problems - first, this is an extreme increase in the density (of the site), and second, there is a lack of understanding of how the planning process works," said Coun. Harder the following day. "The city has to deal with applicants, and can't just throw (the proposal) out the window."

Coun. Harder said her goal is to deal with the issues raised by residents and work with them and the developer to make the situation better.
 
Richcraft has just gone way up in my books. There is something delicious about a developer setting off the neighbourhood alarm bells with a proposal for 85 new homes and then coming back with a new proposal for 210 of them! A few more cases like this could turn out to be the cure to nimbyism! :worship:
 
Richcraft has just gone way up in my books. There is something delicious about a developer setting off the neighbourhood alarm bells with a proposal for 85 new homes and then coming back with a new proposal for 210 of them! A few more cases like this could turn out to be the cure to nimbyism! :worship:

Hmm...good one...Richcraft could say 'look if you don't like our 210 unit proposal', we'll come back with a 350 unit plan with a blood boiling plant on the edge.
 
Proposed density increase elicits big reaction
Posted May 20, 2010
BY STEPH WILLEMS
http://www.emcbarrhaven.ca/20100520/news/Proposed+density+increase+elicits+big+reaction
In 2005, Richcraft came forward with a proposal for 85 townhomes on the site, but this too was poorly received by residents for many of the same reasons. The current proposal, which would feature more than double the amount of units from the previous proposal, allows for 288 outdoor parking spaces with an internal roadway and one entry point. The previous proposal featured garages and driveways with parking for two or more vehicles per unit.

Similar to the comments above, I really enjoy this part. Here's to hoping the neighbourhood complains enough that the development is thrown out. In 5 years, Richcraft will propose several low-rise apartment buildings with 500 units. That will get thrown out. The NIMBY opposition paves the way for Richcraft to build the first 30-story buildings in Barrhaven at this very site in 10 years time.

ok, enough with that fantasy, but Richcraft returning with the denser proposal is great poetic justice.

While several residents argued that the traffic on Mountshannon Dr. has already been too high for several years, the traffic study commissioned by Richcraft and submitted to the city concluded that the roadway has the capacity to accommodate extra cars. Many in attendance scoffed when told the study was conducted in January, when the roads would have few cyclists and pedestrians.

Is there something I'm missing? Doesn't the lack of pedestrians and cyclists mean a heavier load of vehicular traffic? This is just nonsensical.

Concerns arose about whether the location of the property was close enough to transit services to warrant special consideration under the Official Plan. To this, Mr. Tremblay responded, "A project doesn't have to be abutting a service to be close to it."

Mr. Tremblay pointed out that Mountshannon Dr. is served by an OC Transpo route, and that the property will be 860 metres from the future Longfields Transitway Station, which is currently under construction.

In my opinion, 860 metres to a transitway station is abutting mass transit.

Coun. Harder added that she was not surprised that the development was greeted in a hostile manner.

Of course she wasn't. It doesn't take much experience on Council (and Harder has alot) to know that residents will oppose everything but construction of their own home.

Reminds me of when I used to play SimCity - you could have a school, five parks, a fire station, a police station, and a hospital (at a massive budget deficit) for every block, and if you right-click to see what the NIMBYS, er, Sims, were thinking, it wasn't a compliment.
 
Is there something I'm missing? Doesn't the lack of pedestrians and cyclists mean a heavier load of vehicular traffic? This is just nonsensical.

Yes. Everyone in suburbia knows that no one would walk or cycle unless they had no other choice, i.e. they don't have cars, because if they did, they'd be using them and not subjecting themselves to ridicule by using their own muscle power. So the people who walk and cycle in the non-winter months simply don't travel much in the winter - they just sort of emerge every now and then and do what they need to do in as few trips as possible, and scurry back home.

So the residents are being perfectly reasonable in concluding that the January traffic study was no good, because they know that it's in the nicer weather when all the carless people emerge from their winter hibernation and clog up the streets with bicycles and slow down traffic by walking slowly across the streets with bags of bulk groceries and such, stocking up for the coming winter.

:D
 
860m is barely served at all - although some would prefer to walk there to high-frequency service, most (especially seniors) would be better served by a closer local route.
 
860m is barely served at all - although some would prefer to walk there to high-frequency service, most (especially seniors) would be better served by a closer local route.

I don't think 860 metres is that bad ("barely served at all") for rapid transit... 10-12 minute walk, 3-4 minute bike ride. If you are unable or unwilling to walk/bike that far there are both local and express bus stops right in front of the proposed development. But definitely not everyone would be willing to walk that distance.

The City uses 600 metres for rapid transit in its Official Plan (400 metres for local transit), so I'm not sure they can use that as a justification for increased density. City's application site is down so I can't read what their planning rationale was.
 
Last edited:
I don't think 860 metres is that bad ("barely served at all") for rapid transit... 10-12 minute walk, 3-4 minute bike ride. If you are unable or unwilling to walk/bike that far there are both local and express bus stops right in front of the proposed development. But definitely not everyone would be willing to walk that distance.

The City uses 600 metres for rapid transit in its Official Plan (400 metres for local transit), so I'm not sure they can use that as a justification for increased density. City's application site is down so I can't read what their planning rationale was.

I always think of the following for good distances:

400m means they are directly serviced. That would be reachable for nearly everyone and high-frequency service would be highly attractive at that distance. For bus stops, that should be the target for 95% of the population during rush hour and daytime on weekdays. For rapid transit, no other local services are necessary unless travel patterns warrant or the road network warrants.

800m means they are decently serviced. While not reachable by everyone (i.e. seniors, disabled) easily, many would be willing to walk that distance for high-frequency service (less so for lower-frequency service). That should be the bare minimum for rush hour and daytime service, and the goal for evening and weekend service for 90-95% of the population (although they should be closer if ridership warrants). Closer local service may be desirable if that is the distance from rapid transit, at least during the day on weekdays.

1,200m means some would be willing to go there, but it is too far for most captive riders and out of range for less mobile populations. That should be the bare minimum for evening and weekend service (and is certainly unacceptable at rush hour) - anyone beyond that distance should not be in the Urban Transit Area. Sometimes such a long walk is unavoidable though based on street networks. A closer local route should be available at most/all times of day if possible if that is the distance from rapid transit.
 
Good points eternallyme, I like your breakdown of distances

some more news in Kanata

Citizens to have say over planned Kanata development

BY JOANNE CHIANELLO , THE OTTAWA CITIZEN JUNE 22, 2010 8:02 PM


OTTAWA — Citizens will have a chance to air their concerns over a planned development in Kanata that critics say will ruin a pristine forest — although the trees may already be cut by the time the public meeting is held.

There has been growing public dissent about KNL Developments’ plans for a new subdivision that would affect parts of the South March Highlands — a forest that environmental groups call the most “bio-diversity dense” area in the city, with more than 679 species of wildlife and trees. They include endangered and threatened species such as the Blanding’s Turtle, and the Butternut and American Ginseng trees.

Councillor Marianne Wilkinson, who represents the area on city council, said the developer told her clear-cutting would begin on July 19, “and if we stop them, they’ll take us to court. That’s what they told me.”

Council’s planning and environment committee Tuesday agreed to public meetings about the project, but Wilkinson said she’s not sure such a big meeting can be organized before mid-July. And, indeed, the developers are not under any obligation to wait.

The developers do not expect to attend the public meeting, which they characterized as “an information session.” The builders will likely leave it to city staff to explain their position, such as KNL’s own “Tree Preservation Plan,” which has not yet been delivered to the planning committee. Asked whether the company would cut trees in the forest next month, a spokesman for the developer said that can be “decided later.”

It’s a complicated deal, stretching back 30 years and a couple of different owners. Short of buying the land from the developer — an expensive proposition — there’s little the city can do to protect the entire forest. Wilkinson is working on a swap of other city land for the forest, with little luck so far.

In the meantime, there are 89 conditions the developer is supposed to fulfill before moving forward. Eleven have to do with tree species and natural environment area.

© Copyright (c) The Ottawa Citizen
http://www.ottawacitizen.com/techno...planned+Kanata+development/3188029/story.html


Wilkinson backs down in face of opposition

Fear of competition pushes councillor to challenge heck of a deal for trees

BY RANDALL DENLEY, THE OTTAWA CITIZEN JUNE 22, 2010 COMMENTS (1)

Photograph by: The Ottawa Citizen, The Ottawa Citizen
OTTAWA — Councillor Marianne Wilkinson has learned an important thing in her decades in office. People don’t like to be told the truth, so don’t tell it to them.

That’s why the Kanata North councillor will appear at the city planning committee today to argue for more delay and study before trees are cut on land slated for development in Kanata Lakes. The developer, Urbandale, plans to cut the trees next month. Wilkinson’s last-minute intervention seems odd when one considers that 40 per cent of natural areas in Kanata Lakes will be retained despite the housing development. That’s the most generous such provision in the city. Five per cent is a more typical number. The councillor’s opposition seems odder still when one also realizes that the 40-per-cent deal was one she herself negotiated when she was mayor of Kanata in the early 1980s.

But that was then. Now, the public is upset because treed natural areas will be destroyed by the developer even though that is the outcome of a deal agreed to by the city and confirmed by the Ontario Municipal Board.

“I have told people that, but they don’t want to hear that,” Wilkinson says. “I’ve been told off for telling them the truth, by members of the public. They’re trying to find someone to run against me because that other person can obviously wave a wand and save it all.”

Given all of that, Councillor Wilkinson has apparently determined that the correct course of action is to put on a good show for the public. Further study and consultation would be ideal, particularly if it pushes the issue off until after the next election.

The councillor says there is a lot of tree expertise in her ward and residents should have a chance to offer their views on the Urbandale plan. To that end, she wants her colleagues to agree to bring the matter to the planning committee or allow her to conduct a community meeting on the subject.

The councillor holds out hope that the public will suggest creative ways to save additional trees, but she also says, “We lost that battle at the OMB. The only way you get around it is either paying for it or swapping for it.”

A land swap is the other avenue the councillor would like to explore. At first, she suggested that the National Capital Commission might like to give up some of its land to save trees in Kanata. No thanks, the NCC said. Now the councillor is trying to find some other city land to trade. Urbandale has said it is not interested in a swap. It wants to develop the land it has.

The councillor certainly paints a picture of devastation if the developers go ahead. The trees will be clear cut and the land blasted to flatten rocky outcrops.

Urbandale chief planner Mary Jarvis agrees that’s exactly what will happen and says the cut-and-blast approach is actually dictated by restrictive city rules on the slope allowed on roads and on city sewer requirements.

Urbandale filed a detailed tree-preservation plan for its Kanata Lakes lands in early 2007. Wilkinson has had her entire term of office to seek changes, but she’s only responding now that there is a public outcry. Wilkinson concedes that she’s a little late to the fray, but, “If there is a possibility of saving more of it, why not?”

City staff have asked Urbandale for more details on protection of butternut and black cherry trees, but planning manager Don Herweyer says it’s “very difficult” to preserve any individual trees within the development area. The city’s main interest is in the buffer area where the development meets the land that will be preserved. The

40-per-cent preservation amount “is pretty much fixed. There’s not room under that agreement for wholesale changes,” Herweyer says.

Too bad Wilkinson doesn’t have what it takes to stand up for the plan she championed so long ago. It was actually a heck of a deal for taxpayers, obtaining vast tracts of privately owned land at no cost. Under today’s rules all that land would have to be bought to save it from development. The deal preserves the land around the Kizell and Beaver ponds as well as the Trillium Woods.

Instead of defending her accomplishment, Wilkinson is going through the motions of a tree-saving fight that will almost certainly lead nowhere, all to avoid the nightmare of having someone run against her. For Ottawa city councillors, a contested election is a frightening scenario. The other word for it is democracy. Apparently it’s something to be avoided in Kanata North.

http://www.ottawacitizen.com/news/Wilkinson+backs+down+face+opposition/3183746/story.html
 
Good points eternallyme, I like your breakdown of distances

some more news in Kanata

Citizens to have say over planned Kanata development

BY JOANNE CHIANELLO , THE OTTAWA CITIZEN JUNE 22, 2010 8:02 PM


OTTAWA — Citizens will have a chance ...

© Copyright (c) The Ottawa Citizen
http://www.ottawacitizen.com/techno...planned+Kanata+development/3188029/story.html


Wilkinson backs down in face of opposition

Fear of competition pushes councillor to challenge heck of a deal for trees

BY RANDALL DENLEY, THE OTTAWA CITIZEN JUNE 22, 2010 COMMENTS (1)

Photograph by: The Ottawa Citizen, The Ottawa Citizen
OTTAWA — Councillor Marianne Wilkinson has learned an important thing ...

http://www.ottawacitizen.com/news/Wilkinson+backs+down+face+opposition/3183746/story.html

Sometimes Denley really nails it. Wilkinson is being hypocritical, and causing the city to expend money and effort purely to make her look better. There is no significant chance she will accomplish anything.
 
Sometimes Denley really nails it. Wilkinson is being hypocritical, and causing the city to expend money and effort purely to make her look better. There is no significant chance she will accomplish anything.

Exactly...this type of grandstanding and posturing gives municipal politics and politicians an even poorer reputation than they have with the general public.

Denley has been nailing it quite a bit lately. I used to regard him as the slightly more refined version of Lowell but lately he has improved greatly.

Urbandale will nod politely and on the designated day in July start with the moonblasting. The major decisions and permissions on this were granted years ago and quite frankly it is too late, however good the intentions are of the people whose homes back on to woods (do ya think that their homes ever were wooded areas before they became part of a subdivision).
 
No one seems to care much when farmland, of which we have very little in Canada compared to forest and granite, disappears...

Nevertheless, it must be possible to retain some trees and outcrops in these subdivisions, say along the rear property lines or at corner lots. It's not just the housing that makes new subdivisions bleak, it's the complete lack of tree cover as well. In former farmland there's not going to be a lot of pre-existing tree cover, but in Kanata on the Carp Ridge there sure is. Older parts of Kanata actually did retain a good amount of the pre-existing tree cover and even rock outcrops in places, but even that isn't done any more. It's probably asking too much to retain trees in strategic places like future roundabouts, medians and boulevards. Or why not take advantage of an outcrop and make it into a roundabout. From what I've seen in Kanata, creek ravines and the like have a fairly decent chance of being preserved, but other than that everything else is razed and blasted down.

There's just an absolute lack of creativity and sensitivity in the 'production' of new subdivisions.


On a related note, it's rather ludicrous to be putting extra expenditure into building wildlife crossings of Terry Fox when most of the land inside the arc will be developed in the 'raze it' method anyway, unless pockets or corridors of habitat are to be preserved that will be connected to these crossings.
 
No one seems to care much when farmland, of which we have very little in Canada compared to forest and granite, disappears...

Well that's because people see forests as pretty and useful and must be protected against "teh ev0l deVel0perz!" even though farmland is much more important. I also get a feeling that some people are putting too much faith into the hopeful success of those stacked farm towers so to speak.
 
Nevertheless, it must be possible to retain some trees and outcrops in these subdivisions, say along the rear property lines or at corner lots. It's not just the housing that makes new subdivisions bleak, it's the complete lack of tree cover as well. In former farmland there's not going to be a lot of pre-existing tree cover, but in Kanata on the Carp Ridge there sure is. Older parts of Kanata actually did retain a good amount of the pre-existing tree cover and even rock outcrops in places, but even that isn't done any more.

There's just an absolute lack of creativity and sensitivity in the 'production' of new subdivisions.

Teron did that sort of thing in the Beaverbrook area of Kanata in terms of laying out roads etc to preserve the rock outcroppings and large treed areas. Other areas of suburban Ottawa didn't fare too well that way.

Most of the tract home developments in Ottawa are treated as a product and many of the designers etc as part of the development team are paid x$ per door.
 
Does anyone know what is happening with the Chelsea Creek development? There are signs on the site that say construction is starting 'in 2010' but other than the signs there has been zero movement on this site. Perhaps they are still tangled up in legal issues?

The billboards seem to be worded strangely, too. Something to the effect of 'this is getting built, so deal with it' (at least that's how appears if you read between the lines).
 
Teron did that sort of thing in the Beaverbrook area of Kanata in terms of laying out roads etc to preserve the rock outcroppings and large treed areas. Other areas of suburban Ottawa didn't fare too well that way.

Most of the tract home developments in Ottawa are treated as a product and many of the designers etc as part of the development team are paid x$ per door.

Just north of the contested area, Minto kept some of the existing forest and incorporated it into their development on the west side of Morgan's Grant. The "park" at the north end of Statewood, for example, is actually a full block of original forest with paths running through it, as opposed to what usually passes for a park in a new development (a flat swatch of sod with a handful of sapplings scattered decoratively). Any developer that announces, "we will begin clear-cutting" needs to rethink the process.
 
On a related note, it's rather ludicrous to be putting extra expenditure into building wildlife crossings of Terry Fox when most of the land inside the arc will be developed in the 'raze it' method anyway, unless pockets or corridors of habitat are to be preserved that will be connected to these crossings.

They are required to have 40% natural space in the development, so there very well could be wildlife using that corridor regularly.
 


Back
Top