Good points eternallyme, I like your breakdown of distances
some more news in Kanata
Citizens to have say over planned Kanata development
BY JOANNE CHIANELLO , THE OTTAWA CITIZEN JUNE 22, 2010 8:02 PM
OTTAWA — Citizens will have a chance to air their concerns over a planned development in Kanata that critics say will ruin a pristine forest — although the trees may already be cut by the time the public meeting is held.
There has been growing public dissent about KNL Developments’ plans for a new subdivision that would affect parts of the South March Highlands — a forest that environmental groups call the most “bio-diversity dense” area in the city, with more than 679 species of wildlife and trees. They include endangered and threatened species such as the Blanding’s Turtle, and the Butternut and American Ginseng trees.
Councillor Marianne Wilkinson, who represents the area on city council, said the developer told her clear-cutting would begin on July 19, “and if we stop them, they’ll take us to court. That’s what they told me.”
Council’s planning and environment committee Tuesday agreed to public meetings about the project, but Wilkinson said she’s not sure such a big meeting can be organized before mid-July. And, indeed, the developers are not under any obligation to wait.
The developers do not expect to attend the public meeting, which they characterized as “an information session.” The builders will likely leave it to city staff to explain their position, such as KNL’s own “Tree Preservation Plan,” which has not yet been delivered to the planning committee. Asked whether the company would cut trees in the forest next month, a spokesman for the developer said that can be “decided later.”
It’s a complicated deal, stretching back 30 years and a couple of different owners. Short of buying the land from the developer — an expensive proposition — there’s little the city can do to protect the entire forest. Wilkinson is working on a swap of other city land for the forest, with little luck so far.
In the meantime, there are 89 conditions the developer is supposed to fulfill before moving forward. Eleven have to do with tree species and natural environment area.
© Copyright (c) The Ottawa Citizen
http://www.ottawacitizen.com/techno...planned+Kanata+development/3188029/story.html
Wilkinson backs down in face of opposition
Fear of competition pushes councillor to challenge heck of a deal for trees
BY RANDALL DENLEY, THE OTTAWA CITIZEN JUNE 22, 2010 COMMENTS (1)
Photograph by: The Ottawa Citizen, The Ottawa Citizen
OTTAWA — Councillor Marianne Wilkinson has learned an important thing in her decades in office. People don’t like to be told the truth, so don’t tell it to them.
That’s why the Kanata North councillor will appear at the city planning committee today to argue for more delay and study before trees are cut on land slated for development in Kanata Lakes. The developer, Urbandale, plans to cut the trees next month. Wilkinson’s last-minute intervention seems odd when one considers that 40 per cent of natural areas in Kanata Lakes will be retained despite the housing development. That’s the most generous such provision in the city. Five per cent is a more typical number. The councillor’s opposition seems odder still when one also realizes that the 40-per-cent deal was one she herself negotiated when she was mayor of Kanata in the early 1980s.
But that was then. Now, the public is upset because treed natural areas will be destroyed by the developer even though that is the outcome of a deal agreed to by the city and confirmed by the Ontario Municipal Board.
“I have told people that, but they don’t want to hear that,” Wilkinson says. “I’ve been told off for telling them the truth, by members of the public. They’re trying to find someone to run against me because that other person can obviously wave a wand and save it all.”
Given all of that, Councillor Wilkinson has apparently determined that the correct course of action is to put on a good show for the public. Further study and consultation would be ideal, particularly if it pushes the issue off until after the next election.
The councillor says there is a lot of tree expertise in her ward and residents should have a chance to offer their views on the Urbandale plan. To that end, she wants her colleagues to agree to bring the matter to the planning committee or allow her to conduct a community meeting on the subject.
The councillor holds out hope that the public will suggest creative ways to save additional trees, but she also says, “We lost that battle at the OMB. The only way you get around it is either paying for it or swapping for it.”
A land swap is the other avenue the councillor would like to explore. At first, she suggested that the National Capital Commission might like to give up some of its land to save trees in Kanata. No thanks, the NCC said. Now the councillor is trying to find some other city land to trade. Urbandale has said it is not interested in a swap. It wants to develop the land it has.
The councillor certainly paints a picture of devastation if the developers go ahead. The trees will be clear cut and the land blasted to flatten rocky outcrops.
Urbandale chief planner Mary Jarvis agrees that’s exactly what will happen and says the cut-and-blast approach is actually dictated by restrictive city rules on the slope allowed on roads and on city sewer requirements.
Urbandale filed a detailed tree-preservation plan for its Kanata Lakes lands in early 2007. Wilkinson has had her entire term of office to seek changes, but she’s only responding now that there is a public outcry. Wilkinson concedes that she’s a little late to the fray, but, “If there is a possibility of saving more of it, why not?”
City staff have asked Urbandale for more details on protection of butternut and black cherry trees, but planning manager Don Herweyer says it’s “very difficult” to preserve any individual trees within the development area. The city’s main interest is in the buffer area where the development meets the land that will be preserved. The
40-per-cent preservation amount “is pretty much fixed. There’s not room under that agreement for wholesale changes,” Herweyer says.
Too bad Wilkinson doesn’t have what it takes to stand up for the plan she championed so long ago. It was actually a heck of a deal for taxpayers, obtaining vast tracts of privately owned land at no cost. Under today’s rules all that land would have to be bought to save it from development. The deal preserves the land around the Kizell and Beaver ponds as well as the Trillium Woods.
Instead of defending her accomplishment, Wilkinson is going through the motions of a tree-saving fight that will almost certainly lead nowhere, all to avoid the nightmare of having someone run against her. For Ottawa city councillors, a contested election is a frightening scenario. The other word for it is democracy. Apparently it’s something to be avoided in Kanata North.
http://www.ottawacitizen.com/news/Wilkinson+backs+down+face+opposition/3183746/story.html