Still some infighting in Old Chelsea about the recreation centre as well as the Chelsea Creek development. One resident thinks that the southern part of Chelsea should be merged with the city of Gatineau.
http://www.ottawacitizen.com/life/Troubled+times+Chelsea/2976562/story.html
Troubled times in Old Chelsea
The village is a house divided over future expansion that would change its idyllic nature, Dave Rogers writes.
By Dave Rogers , The Ottawa CitizenMay 2, 2010
After two referendums and a civic election, Chelsea residents are still fighting over a planned $9.8-million recreation centre and proposals for a housing development in the village of Old Chelsea.
The municipality’s new mayor, Caryl Green, says she wants public discourse to be based on civility and respect. But sometimes squabbling or threats of lawsuits replace the polite behaviour the mayor hopes to promote.
The municipality is divided into two factions: those who want the recreation centre, more housing and urban water and sewer services and their opponents who want to preserve Chelsea’s idyllic character and curb spending.
Some residents, such as former mayor Judy Grant, complain that their property taxes have doubled to almost the amount they would pay in Ottawa. Others are worried that Chelsea may not be able to afford expensive infrastructure because the community has only 7,000 residents and the municipal debt has increased to $10 million from $1 million during the last eight years.
An example of the level of acrimony is the lawsuit launched by deputy mayor Luc Poulin against Douglas Griffin, a defeated candidate in November civic election.
Poulin says in his statement of claim that Griffin falsely claimed in an Oct. 26, 2009 e-mail message to at least 51 residents that Poulin was participating in a cover-up and was lying about recreation centre funding.
Griffin’s counterclaim said Poulin’s libel action violates Quebec’s new law that makes it illegal to file lawsuits that are intended to stifle debate on issues of public interest.
Poulin is seeking $9,000 in damages plus legal costs while Griffin has asked the court to award him $1.25 million.
Griffin said he “took exception to the campaign strategy of Poulin and Green which was to pretend that the funding for the centre was secure.”
However, Green says $6.1 million in federal and provincial infrastructure grants are still available for the centre even though construction hasn’t started and it can’t be finished by the March 31, 2010 deadline. She added the project will have to be scaled back or completed in stages because soil tests show the site is too sandy.
Chelsea residents approved the Meredith Centre by a vote of 53 per cent to 49 per cent in a referendum in June 2009.
Named after the family that donated the land, the centre is to be built on property near Chelsea Elementary School on Old Chelsea Road.
Part of the site is already used for soccer fields and a farmers market during the summer. Plans call for an NHL-size hockey arena, a double gym and a meeting hall with a capacity of 400.
Former mayor Grant said the size and cost of the recreation centre needs to be reduced.
“Most of the older people feel that the Meredith Centre is far too grandiose for the municipality, particularly when there is a need for a sewage system, which I believe is much more important. You need recreation to keep kids in our own back yard but it doesn’t need to be something with a price tag like the Meredith Centre.”
Green said the project is expected to go to tender at the end of April.
“The community is waiting to see a design that comes out of the design-build process,” Green said. “It is an accepted fact that this recreation and cultural centre is going ahead.
“The community groups are looking forward to when construction begins and we will be able to use this as the gathering place for the community. I think it will be welcomed and the hope is that it will be built by July 2011.”
A spokeswoman for foreign affairs minister Lawrence Canon, whose riding includes Chelsea, said the minister is committed to the project.
Another area of contention is the Chelsea Creek housing development that was approved by a vote of 41-39 in a referendum on Jan. 25, 2009.
Opponents who live near the site at Old Chelsea Road and Highway 5 worry their wells will dry up unless the new houses are connected to a water treatment plant.
Chelsea resident Jacques Cayer said projects such as the recreation centre and water and sewer services are so expensive that it would make economic sense for Gatineau to annex the southern part of the municipality.
“If we don’t do something Gatineau is going to want all the land south of Old Chelsea Road,” Cayer said. “They have water and sewer services up to the former Hewlett-Packard building on Highway 5.
“Somebody is going to ask why we should spend more than $15 million on water and sewer service in Chelsea when all we have to do is hook onto Gatineau’s pipes.”
Perhaps nothing demonstrates the level of contention in Chelsea than an incident at the April 6 council meeting.
Chelsea resident Kurt Burgstaller, 82, said the mayor told him not to interrupt when he asked for an English translation of a French-language septic tank contract. Burgstaller said the mayor then added that council business is normally conducted in French.
Burgstaller, a retired construction consultant, said he had asked for an English-language explanation about the contract because it didn’t make economic sense to have septic tank inspections done at an hourly rate.
“The council minutes were read in French and my French is limited so I asked the reader to repeat it in English which he did,” Burgstaller said. “I thought that giving out an hourly contract would be like inviting the fox into the henhouse. Then the mayor said the public is not invited to interrupt the reading of the minutes.
“She said in Quebec municipalities all proceedings are in French only, which is news to me. My intervention was on behalf of all taxpayers, not just those who speak French or English.”
When asked why Burgstaller was told to sit down and keep quiet, Green said it was all about respect.
“The issue had nothing to do with language or the septic tank issue,” Green said. “My reason for asking Burgstaller to refrain had to do with respect, the tone and the level of civility.
“My role is to ensure in the council that there be a certain decorum. I have said that we won’t tolerate personal attacks. We will welcome questions on issues to do with the business of the municipality and of course there will be differences in opinion.”
Green said people are allowed to ask questions at the start of each council meeting and questions of clarification are allowed in French or English as the resolutions are read.
© Copyright (c) The Ottawa Citizen