New subdivision developments


I find it strange that all of these huge suburb developments get approval (well, a good portion of them anyways), but infill projects in the city proper are more often rejected or scrutinized. Why is this?
 
Court to rule on city planning power to stop Manotick expansion
http://www.ottawacitizen.com/news/C...er+stop+Manotick+expansion/1771338/story.html

BY JAKE RUPERT , THE OTTAWA CITIZENJULY 8, 2009 3:01 PM


OTTAWA — In a potential landmark legal battle, the city has been granted leave to appeal an Ontario Municipal Board ruling that allowed a large subdivision in Manotick, despite municipal council's having voted against the development.

The subdivision proposed by Minto Communities would see 1,400 homes built just outside the village, more than doubling its size.

City council voted against the development for several reasons including that it was outside the urban area beyond which major development isn’t supposed to occur, the roads couldn’t handle the traffic, Minto wanted to build too quickly, it would alter the village’s character, and there wasn’t enough protection for environmentally sensitive areas.

Minto appealed to the board, which hears appeals of municipal planning decisions, and the board ruled in Minto's favour, letting the big development go ahead.

The city applied to Ontario’s Divisional Court for leave to appeal the board’s ruling. The city argued the board didn’t follow the Planning Act’s instruction to “have regard to” a council decision when dealing with such appeals, and that the board’s ruling was plain wrong.

In his ruling, Ontario Superior Court Justice Robert Maranger said the city’s appeal will be heard because what exactly “having regard to” a council decision means has not been defined by a court, and, depending on the definition, the board’s “decision is certainly open to question.

“The powers of municipalities, and what deference the OMB should afford any given municipal council’s decision is an important issue that merits consideration and perhaps direction from the Divisional Court,” Maranger wrote.

So, essentially, the judge wrote, since the requirement that the board “have regard to” council decisions became law in 2007, different interpretations have been applied, and it’s time a judge set the record straight.

© Copyright (c) The Ottawa Citizen
 
OMB appeal may shift balance of power
http://www.ottawacitizen.com/news/appeal+shift+balance+power/1779913/story.html
Planning experts await outcome of Manotick development dispute

BY JAKE RUPERT, THE OTTAWA CITIZENJULY 10, 2009


OTTAWA — The City of Ottawa’s court appeal against an Ontario Municipal Board ruling allowing a large subdivision outside of Manotick could fundamentally shift the balance of power over planning decisions across the province, municipal planning experts say.

Currently, final power rests with the board, which hears appeals of municipal council rulings on development applications. The city’s bid in court seeks to bolster the weight of municipal decisions, making it harder for the board to overturn them.

Last week when word got out that the city had won the right to appeal the Manotick ruling, development firms, urban planners, government planners, landowners, and municipal lawyers took notice.

“This is a big one,” said Alta Vista Councillor Peter Hume, chair of Ottawa city council’s planning committee and president of the Association of Municipalities of Ontario. “Depending on what the judges ultimately say, it could shift power over these decisions to councils. There’s no question this is groundbreaking stuff, and that a lot of people will have an interest in the outcome.”

Neal DeRuyter, a planner from Kitchener who works for developers, said if the judges who hear the appeal bolster the strength of council decisions on such issues, it could cause a lot of trouble for the industry.

DeRuyter doesn’t think a decision will go as far as giving councils absolute power over these decision, but that authority could be “immensely increased,” which could make it much more difficult for developers to get projects approved.

The appeal argument takes up a decades-long debate over who should have the power to say yes or no to construction projects.

In many municipalities, including Ottawa, local politicians have become increasingly angry that an unelected provincial body, a board made up mostly of planners, planning lawyers and former city politicians from around Ontario, routinely overturns local council decisions on development applications.

However, board supporters, largely from the development industry, say the board is needed because new developments are often unpopular, and politicians tend to make irrational decisions for political reasons.

In the Manotick case the city is pursuing, Minto Communities, a large developer, applied to more than double the size of Manotick village by building 1,400 residences on its outskirts over the next 10 years or so.

Rideau-Goulbourn Councillor Glenn Brooks, historically an ally of developers, represents the area where the project was vehemently opposed by residents. He led the charge against the application, and it was rejected by a 19-5 council vote.

Minto appealed this decision to the board and won an outright victory when board members agreed city council got it wrong on almost every point.

The city filed an application for an appeal in Divisional Court stating the board had not given sufficient “regard” to the council decision in its ruling, which a provincial government amended to planning law in 2007 requires it to do.

The city won the right to appeal the board ruling and is getting ready to file their case.

The judge hearing the application, Ontario Superior Court Justice Robert Maranger, agreed that exactly what weight the board is supposed to give a council decision in a case like this isn’t defined and should be because, depending on the definition, the board’s decision in the Manotick case “certainly” could be viewed as wrong.

The ruling was sweet music to the ears of some municipal politicians tired of losing to developers. For them, it’s a democratic principle at stake.

They are elected to make decisions about local issues, including what can be built and where, but the board frequently reverses their decisions.

In Ottawa, these include board decisions allowing a large expansion of the urban boundary in the west end, two 27-storey buildings on a downtown parking lot, big-box malls, and other things city council rejected.

There’s also an outstanding threat to appeal a recent city council vote that granted another small expansion of the urban boundary when the development industry wanted much more land designated for residential buildings.

After the board’s decision on the Manotick development, Brooks said the city might as well rip up all its planning policies because they are “worthless” under the current balance of power.

Brooks said the changes to the planning law were designed to give municipalities more power, but the reality missed the goal.

In a speech on the subject to members of the Ontario Bar Association’s municipal law section in June 2007, the then-minister of municipal affairs John Gerretsen said the changes most relevant to them were the “greater power and autonomy that municipalities now have to influence decisions that affect their communities.

“The reforms give greater weight to council’s decisions,” Gerretsen, a former mayor of Kingston, said in the speech. “When disagreements arise, and matters end up before the Ontario Municipal Board, the OMB is required to have regard for councils’ decisions.”

City lawyers are expected to argue the board has not been doing this, and it should give great weight to council decisions. Lawyers for Minto are expected to argue the opposite.

Hanging in the balance, Hume said, is control over how cities, towns, and even rural areas will grow.

“I’ve been doing this a long time, and this is the biggest case I’ve seen,” he said. “This is about power over these decisions across the province.”

No hearing on the issue has been scheduled, and it could be more than a year before the appeal is decided.

© Copyright (c) The Ottawa Citizen
 
Carp River group files appeal with OMB on proposed Fernbank development
http://www.ottawacitizen.com/Carp+R...posed+Fernbank+development/1871691/story.html

BY KATE JAIMET, THE OTTAWA CITIZENAUGUST 7, 2009 11:20 PMBE THE FIRST TO POST A COMMENT


OTTAWA — As the mop-up continues in flood-ravaged neighbourhoods of Kanata and Stittsville, the Ontario Municipal Board is preparing to hear an appeal that challenges the city’s plan to develop the nearby Fernbank area, and argues that piecemeal planning along the Carp River watershed could lead to more flooding problems.

The Carp River Coalition filed its appeal of the city’s master plan for Fernbank development on July 23, just one day before torrential rains inundated hundreds of basements in Glen Cairn and other parts of Kanata as well as Stittsville and West Carleton. A hearing date for the appeal before the provincial board, which can overrule city council planning decisions, has not been set.

West Carleton Councillor Eli El-Chantiry said that he is not aware of the appeal, but that the city may have to re-think its development of Fernbank, separately from the OMB process, based on the analysis of the July 24 flood. City staff expect to have that analysis finished by the end of this month.

“We should wait to see the cause of the flood… Is it the volume of rain? Is it the ditches? Is it the stormwater sewer system? We need to know the answers,” El-Chantiry said. “If the report comes and says this area cannot develop or we should rethink development in that area because of the flood, well, we may have to rethink that. Because, quite frankly, I’m not ready to jump and authorize another thousand homes, just to wait a few years and flood them again.”

The city plan for Fernbank, passed by a reluctant council last June 24, foresees a development of as many as 11,000 homes on 674 hectares of land connecting Kanata to Stittsville. The land is to be developed by several companies including Richcraft, Metric Homes, Fernbank Properties, Urbandale, Brookfield Homes and Mattamy Homes. The plans also call for 76 kilometres of water mains, sanitary sewers and storm sewers.

About one-third of the development will be on land that drains into the Carp River.

The city never wanted to approve development of the Fernbank area, which lies upstream of Glen Cairn and on the opposite bank of the Carp. But the city was forced into it by an OMB decision in favour of developers in 2005. This new appeal may force the board to revisit its own decision.

“Building on these areas risks flooding in other areas, and in new homes,” said Mikelis Svilans, a member of the Carp River Coalition. “This is not a minor issue.”

Svilans said his coalition’s appeal has four main points:

-- The environmental assessment for the area was integrated with the planning process, whereas it should have been done separately;

-- The planning of the Carp River watershed is being done piecemeal, with insufficient analysis of the cumulative effect of various developments, including those in Fernbank and Kanata West;

-- The plan foresees a rise in the floodwater levels of the Carp River; and

-- The stormwater infrastructure standards are inconsistent, with stricter standards in the part of the development that drains into the Jock River, and laxer standards in the Carp River watershed.

City spokesman Michael FitzPatrick said the city is aware of the appeal. “The appeal doesn’t raise any new issues that weren’t discussed during the consultation process,” he said. “The city will defend its process, why and how it did what it did.”

But Stittsville-Kanata West Councillor Shad Qadri said that no development can go ahead in Fernbank as long as there is an appeal before the OMB. But that won’t delay any imminent projects, since developers were not expecting to build there for another three to five years.

Qadri agreed with El-Chantiry that the flooding two weeks ago in Glen Cairn may cause the city to revisit its plans for developing Fernbank. He said that measures of the water flow in the Carp River during the storm on July 24 should be plugged into the model that determines what sorts of storm-sewer and drainage systems are necessary in new developments along the Carp — and the model should be recalibrated if necessary.

“Before any development takes place in the Fernbank area, we (need to) look at the new waterflows,” he said. “But that question should be going to the OMB. Why did they say (in 2005) it’s OK to go ahead and build on that land?”

Kanata North Councillor Marianne Wilkinson said development in Fernbank can go ahead, and changes to infrastructure planning can be made as necessary, once the water-flow model has been recalibrated.

© Copyright (c) The Ottawa Citizen
 
southfacing... http://www.flickr.com/photos/23575605@N08/3802127895/
bonus points for figuring out where this is.... ;)

3802127895_792d84b8d5.jpg
 
Minto has submitted an OPA, ZBL Amendment, and Plan of Subdivision for lands in South Nepean Town Centre near Wal-Mart and Loblaws. Here`s a link to their planning rationale.

Here's what their proposal looks like

minto_barrhavenTC.jpg


  • In the mixed use midrise zones they propose to reduce the density target from 200 units per ha to 150 units per hectare, as they are only proposing 4 stories rather than 4-6 stories envisioned in the CDP.
  • Also in part of the mid-rise areas they are also proposing to increase the height limit to 12 stories to permit four apartment buildings with commercial services and offices on the main floor (CDP height limit was 6 fl).
  • In the high density mixed use area they are proposing mixed use developement with a reduced height minimum of 4 storeys for office/commercial buildings rather than 6 storeys and reduced density targets from 250 to 200 residential units per ha.
  • They are also making adjustments to the road system and park blocks in the CDP.
 
Last edited:
This is without a doubt in Kanata South (very pretty :slob: ). Off Eagleson road right accross from Emerald Meadows drive. :cheers:
 
Yeah, that retirement home is kind of 'out there' in terms of amenities for the residents to walk to.

There is a commercial development proposed at Eagleson & Bridgestone (at the top middle of the picture) that will be within walking distance, and a larger development to the south of this development. Also, the Superstore isn't too far away.
 
Speaking of Kanata

Councillor calls for halt to building projects in Kanata

Moratorium needed until flooding issue in certain areas fixed, Feltmate says

By Patrick Dare August 14, 2009 10:41 PM



OTTAWA — Kanata South Councillor Peggy Feltmate says she wants a moratorium on development in parts of Kanata until the city gets to the bottom of the area’s repeated floods.

The councillor on Friday said she is working on a moratorium motion that would go to city council’s planning and environment committee, perhaps as early as Aug. 25, then on to council.

She said the Kanata area’s third serious flood in 13 years has convinced her that the city does not have the information in hand to allow more development and, potentially, more flood risk.

Glen Cairn, in her Kanata South ward, saw flooding in 1996, again in 2002 and a third time on July 24 during an intense rainstorm. On one street, sewage backed up into every home. Across Kanata and Stittsville, about 1,000 homes saw flooding and three wastewater pumping stations overflowed in the western part of the city.

“What’s sobering about it for me is that everybody thought there was a fix after the second time. That’s what’s so distressing and difficult,” said Feltmate. “The sooner we do this (moratorium) the better.”

The City of Ottawa spent about $7 million over the last few years on drainage work in the Glen Cairn area, including increasing the capacity of the Carp River and the ability of culverts to take water away from residential areas.

Feltmate said some development projects approved years ago may not meet modern planning standards and could contribute to further flooding in Kanata. She said she is refining exactly what area would be covered by a moratorium. She noted that Glen Cairn, mostly built in the 1970s, was constructed without stormwater facilities.

One of the city’s own current projects, the construction of the Terry Fox Drive extension, could be part of the debate about future development in Kanata. That $47-million road project runs by environmentally sensitive lands in Kanata and involves taking out a significant amount of floodplain: About 30 per cent of the new road, or 1.5 kilometres, is plotted through the floodplain of the Carp River.

The proposed road, linking north and south Kanata, runs by the Carp River and requires realignment of a creek, construction of stormwater facilities, building a crossing facility for animals and avoiding nearby sensitive natural areas.

The city’s managers for the project plan to replace the lost floodplain by lowering other lands in the area. But Ottawa Riverkeeper executive director Meredith Brown says it’s a bad idea to take out floodplain and alter natural drainage patterns. She is concerned the development that’s been allowed in Kanata so far may have contributed to flooding problems.

Feltmate said the proposed design for the Terry Fox Drive project will be public in the third or fourth week of September, allowing for debate about whether the road goes ahead.

The councillor, who was out of the country when the most recent flood hit, has sent city staff a bunch of questions about the flooding. One of the critical ones still outstanding is whether drainage work recommended in 2003 by a city consultant was done in Glen Cairn’s most southern streets, where the flood hit hardest. Feltmate believes the work was not done and she wants to know why.

The chairman of city council’s planning and environment committee, Peter Hume, said a moratorium on development in the Kanata area may be welcomed by the public. He said people want to know that the city’s systems work well before allowing more building to occur. He said the city must take care to include in the moratorium area only the lands where drainage is a concern.

“We have to be doing things to build public trust,” said Hume. “I think the public will say that’s the right thing to do.”

He said there was strong pressure to approve the growth project, but council must be assured that the road will not adversely affect drainage in the area.
© Copyright (c) The Ottawa Citizen
 


Back
Top