OMB appeal may shift balance of power
http://www.ottawacitizen.com/news/appeal+shift+balance+power/1779913/story.html
Planning experts await outcome of Manotick development dispute
BY JAKE RUPERT, THE OTTAWA CITIZENJULY 10, 2009
OTTAWA — The City of Ottawa’s court appeal against an Ontario Municipal Board ruling allowing a large subdivision outside of Manotick could fundamentally shift the balance of power over planning decisions across the province, municipal planning experts say.
Currently, final power rests with the board, which hears appeals of municipal council rulings on development applications. The city’s bid in court seeks to bolster the weight of municipal decisions, making it harder for the board to overturn them.
Last week when word got out that the city had won the right to appeal the Manotick ruling, development firms, urban planners, government planners, landowners, and municipal lawyers took notice.
“This is a big one,” said Alta Vista Councillor Peter Hume, chair of Ottawa city council’s planning committee and president of the Association of Municipalities of Ontario. “Depending on what the judges ultimately say, it could shift power over these decisions to councils. There’s no question this is groundbreaking stuff, and that a lot of people will have an interest in the outcome.”
Neal DeRuyter, a planner from Kitchener who works for developers, said if the judges who hear the appeal bolster the strength of council decisions on such issues, it could cause a lot of trouble for the industry.
DeRuyter doesn’t think a decision will go as far as giving councils absolute power over these decision, but that authority could be “immensely increased,” which could make it much more difficult for developers to get projects approved.
The appeal argument takes up a decades-long debate over who should have the power to say yes or no to construction projects.
In many municipalities, including Ottawa, local politicians have become increasingly angry that an unelected provincial body, a board made up mostly of planners, planning lawyers and former city politicians from around Ontario, routinely overturns local council decisions on development applications.
However, board supporters, largely from the development industry, say the board is needed because new developments are often unpopular, and politicians tend to make irrational decisions for political reasons.
In the Manotick case the city is pursuing, Minto Communities, a large developer, applied to more than double the size of Manotick village by building 1,400 residences on its outskirts over the next 10 years or so.
Rideau-Goulbourn Councillor Glenn Brooks, historically an ally of developers, represents the area where the project was vehemently opposed by residents. He led the charge against the application, and it was rejected by a 19-5 council vote.
Minto appealed this decision to the board and won an outright victory when board members agreed city council got it wrong on almost every point.
The city filed an application for an appeal in Divisional Court stating the board had not given sufficient “regard” to the council decision in its ruling, which a provincial government amended to planning law in 2007 requires it to do.
The city won the right to appeal the board ruling and is getting ready to file their case.
The judge hearing the application, Ontario Superior Court Justice Robert Maranger, agreed that exactly what weight the board is supposed to give a council decision in a case like this isn’t defined and should be because, depending on the definition, the board’s decision in the Manotick case “certainly” could be viewed as wrong.
The ruling was sweet music to the ears of some municipal politicians tired of losing to developers. For them, it’s a democratic principle at stake.
They are elected to make decisions about local issues, including what can be built and where, but the board frequently reverses their decisions.
In Ottawa, these include board decisions allowing a large expansion of the urban boundary in the west end, two 27-storey buildings on a downtown parking lot, big-box malls, and other things city council rejected.
There’s also an outstanding threat to appeal a recent city council vote that granted another small expansion of the urban boundary when the development industry wanted much more land designated for residential buildings.
After the board’s decision on the Manotick development, Brooks said the city might as well rip up all its planning policies because they are “worthless” under the current balance of power.
Brooks said the changes to the planning law were designed to give municipalities more power, but the reality missed the goal.
In a speech on the subject to members of the Ontario Bar Association’s municipal law section in June 2007, the then-minister of municipal affairs John Gerretsen said the changes most relevant to them were the “greater power and autonomy that municipalities now have to influence decisions that affect their communities.
“The reforms give greater weight to council’s decisions,” Gerretsen, a former mayor of Kingston, said in the speech. “When disagreements arise, and matters end up before the Ontario Municipal Board, the OMB is required to have regard for councils’ decisions.”
City lawyers are expected to argue the board has not been doing this, and it should give great weight to council decisions. Lawyers for Minto are expected to argue the opposite.
Hanging in the balance, Hume said, is control over how cities, towns, and even rural areas will grow.
“I’ve been doing this a long time, and this is the biggest case I’ve seen,” he said. “This is about power over these decisions across the province.”
No hearing on the issue has been scheduled, and it could be more than a year before the appeal is decided.
© Copyright (c) The Ottawa Citizen