I agree w/ Blessed that the location's downtown aren't a necessity. To me I think a communal stadium between USA & Mobile (and the Sr. Bowl & the GMAC for that matter) would need to be somewhere between them. That's the reason I thought Springhill. I think I'd rather it go up on the east side of I-65... partly b/c to me that "feels" like the "Mobile" side. I don't know that I'd have a problem w/ having it near the baseball stadium, it's just that I think it'd have more of an impact being on/off Springhill than Govt. USA already operates its medical center just down the street beyond that, so clearly it's in line w/ their operations. That area is also really easy to get to and get out of for most of USA's student body (and for avg. Mobilians as well) w/ US 98 right there in addition to the interstate. A re-working of the intersection w/ I-65 & Springhill/US98 may be needed & perhaps a widening of that section of Old Shell & N. Sage.
Right now that area (Crichton) is an economically depressed part of the city (cheap land) and is in desperate need of revival. I think I'd like to see the purchase of the whole area bordered by I-65, Old Shell, Springhill, & N. Sage. This would give them room to create a large park environment surrounding the stadium & make maximum impact on the surrounding area. While the stadium itself would be somewhat justified to the western section of that, the parking would trail to the east of it in a landscaped parking area (lots of trees and mounded medians to make it nice for tailgating & attractive to look at). Springhill & Moffat/US98 intersect on the NE point of this tract in an area with several shopping centers. The only real problem w/ this location is that the train tracks cut across a small section of it, but they could be re-routed by 50' or so or the issue could be built around fairly easily. They would probably need to be elevated anyway to deal w/ the traffic... but that could be something planned and done when funds became available.
My own personal idea on the stadium's appearance would be to not go w/ the traditional brick that so many others have gone to (b/c it's played & boring & Mobile ain't an industrial-feeling city). I'd like more of a mixed contemporary approach that made the stadium stand out more (but not in a bad way). My idea would be to use a wide lower concourse w/ its visible outer areas sheathed in a frosted blue-green glass (Water Cube-esque) that would make it easier to cool the area's w/in while letting in natural light and would help the primary facade (which would be above it) of the stadium make a stronger impact. Above that first level (about 20' tall), and about 20' in from the outermost wall of the lower concourse, I would like to see them start w/ masonry in a similar vein to that used by the Ridgecrest dorm in Tuscaloosa. That creamy color above the aqua-colored glass would make it look more like a sandcastle on a beach (tying into the aquatic theme in the city & making a great visible impression). You could use almost any exterior style (Art Deco, Roman Coliseum, etc.) that suited your budget. This would essentially be an exterior skin, but wouldn't have to match the internal walking spaces. Lots of openings in the masonry section (majority of the structure) would allow light and air to circulate through the building. Parts of Ole Miss' Vaught-Hemingway are in the vein of what I'm thinking in terms of this upper section. Virginia Tech also uses a variation of this idea. FSU uses a variation that's stylistically more-in line w/ what I'm seeing in my head, but they use brick instead.
Surrounding that you'd have room for about 50-100 feet of planting area & greenspace (lots of room for Azaleas to pay homage to the city... and Springhill, for that matter... while making a very strong visible impact from the interstate). During the Azalea season, this could be a central point for many events b/c of its easy parking situation & ease of entrance/exit. USA & the bowls aren't going to need more than 50K anytime soon, so the endzones would stay open. I say continue the concourse level around one endzone (using the same aqua-colored frosted glass on the roof and exterior side) and build a museum to Gulf Coast Athletics (w/ a large part devoted to the Sr. Bowl... as a selling point to those folk to make them stay). There are tons of great athletes who grew up an hour from that location (Emmett Smith, Brett Favre, Hank Aaron, etc... many of which may be willing to donate items or help promote the facility). This would increase the use of the facility in down-time which would increase the traffic in the area.
This could be done in stages, of course, w/ the stadium's largest two sections being built first & the museum built later as funds/grants became available. Mobile may have to foot a large part of the bill initially (this is one reason why I think it should be used as a redevelopment project) but I think the two could get something set up where the percentage paid by the city shrank over time & USA's grew... perhaps from Mobile holding 55-65% of the total debt initially to Mobile holding 35% after 10 years (& USA the lion's share since they would be the primary users). Naming rights would be an important facet of getting the stadium up and running. Portland recently signed a deal for $8.5 million on a soccer stadium & they say that's a bargain-basement for that kind of thing. Troy got $18 million for their stadium from Movie Gallery. FAU is shopping around $20 million for their stadium's collective naming rights. Ultimately, I think Mobile getting $15 million would be a big chunk & a reasonable amt. to expect. They're saying $100 million for total construction cost, but FAU is building a 30K seat stadium in FL for $62 million. Akron (which doesn't draw well at all) just built a 30K stadium for $61.6 million (and sold 16.1 million in naming rights to a couple different companies). UCF completed a 45K seat stadium for $54 million in '07 (and got $15 million from Brighthouse).
There is also the potential for the city selling Ladd-Peebles to the Mobile County School System. Even giving it away at $15 million would be a bargain for MCSS relative to how many HS's play there. W/ naming rights and the sale of LPS, that would take at least around $30 million off the top. Financing $70 million split between the city & USA would be easier to sell to people.
Anyway, just ideas...