Keith P.
Active member
By reboot I mean rebuilding the area so it is more urban and less car oriented, with fewer lanes and little to no surface parking. This does not mean eliminating vehicle traffic or structured parking.
There will be car traffic but it is a 3 lane bridge. The city could build 16 lanes leading up to the bridge and the throughput would still be determined by the 3 lane bottleneck on the bridge. The other paths around there on the Dartmouth side generally rapidly turn into small 2 lane streets. In the 70's there were plans to incorporate this part of town into an expressway project: https://samaustin.ca/redesigning-prince-albert-road/. This is not surprising to me at all and seems to explain some of the inconsistent roadways. A lot of the overbuilt roadways around the city date from this era and because the networks were not completed they do not make sense in terms of efficient land use.
That still needs to be done in some way, shape or form.
Consider that the case for a 3rd harbour crossing has long since been made but has not moved forward. Meanwhile lots of money has been spent trying to make the Macdonald something it was never designed to be. It has now reached its engineering limits in terms of the weight the basic structure can carry. It is rather poorly sited for the way the city has developed but there seems little chance that the south-end crossing that is so badly needed will ever be built. Therefore something must be done. Bicycles and pedestrians will not ever be a significant part of such traffic.
The problem is that the approaches on the Halifax side in particular are constricted and the proximity to CFB Halifax makes their redesign and expansion problematic. In a perfect world a two-level bridge would make some sense but that would require a totally new structure given the weight limits of the Macdonald.
If you were given the task of designing something that would carry the commuter traffic from the southern and eastern suburbs of Dartmouth plus container traffic from the south end of Halifax you have a wicked problem. This is particularly true considering that HRM has consistently stuck its head firmly in the sand regarding the latter and will only make things worse once Cogswell gets blown up and turned into narrow laneways littered with roundabouts. If one assumes that HRM will continue to make the DT core unfriendly to all traveling there and will require those working there to live there then perhaps it is all moot. But one suspects that concept will ultimately collapse under its own weight of hubris.
Logically the Dartmouth side is more easily fixed (though none of this is particularly easy): expropriate the unfortunate residential properties along either side of Woodland Ave and continue that westbound past the existing Victoria Rd terminus of Woodland to extend it down to Wyse, where it will move traffic efficiently to the Macdonald. Perhaps a second crossing adjacent to the Macdonald heading back to Dartmouth could utilize Barrington more efficiently and get traffic off North, Agricola, Gottingen and the other surface streets that are presently clogged. This would of course also make transit a somewhat more appealing option since they would be stuck in traffic less frequently.