Development Rumours


By reboot I mean rebuilding the area so it is more urban and less car oriented, with fewer lanes and little to no surface parking. This does not mean eliminating vehicle traffic or structured parking.

There will be car traffic but it is a 3 lane bridge. The city could build 16 lanes leading up to the bridge and the throughput would still be determined by the 3 lane bottleneck on the bridge. The other paths around there on the Dartmouth side generally rapidly turn into small 2 lane streets. In the 70's there were plans to incorporate this part of town into an expressway project: https://samaustin.ca/redesigning-prince-albert-road/. This is not surprising to me at all and seems to explain some of the inconsistent roadways. A lot of the overbuilt roadways around the city date from this era and because the networks were not completed they do not make sense in terms of efficient land use.

That still needs to be done in some way, shape or form.

Consider that the case for a 3rd harbour crossing has long since been made but has not moved forward. Meanwhile lots of money has been spent trying to make the Macdonald something it was never designed to be. It has now reached its engineering limits in terms of the weight the basic structure can carry. It is rather poorly sited for the way the city has developed but there seems little chance that the south-end crossing that is so badly needed will ever be built. Therefore something must be done. Bicycles and pedestrians will not ever be a significant part of such traffic.

The problem is that the approaches on the Halifax side in particular are constricted and the proximity to CFB Halifax makes their redesign and expansion problematic. In a perfect world a two-level bridge would make some sense but that would require a totally new structure given the weight limits of the Macdonald.

If you were given the task of designing something that would carry the commuter traffic from the southern and eastern suburbs of Dartmouth plus container traffic from the south end of Halifax you have a wicked problem. This is particularly true considering that HRM has consistently stuck its head firmly in the sand regarding the latter and will only make things worse once Cogswell gets blown up and turned into narrow laneways littered with roundabouts. If one assumes that HRM will continue to make the DT core unfriendly to all traveling there and will require those working there to live there then perhaps it is all moot. But one suspects that concept will ultimately collapse under its own weight of hubris.

Logically the Dartmouth side is more easily fixed (though none of this is particularly easy): expropriate the unfortunate residential properties along either side of Woodland Ave and continue that westbound past the existing Victoria Rd terminus of Woodland to extend it down to Wyse, where it will move traffic efficiently to the Macdonald. Perhaps a second crossing adjacent to the Macdonald heading back to Dartmouth could utilize Barrington more efficiently and get traffic off North, Agricola, Gottingen and the other surface streets that are presently clogged. This would of course also make transit a somewhat more appealing option since they would be stuck in traffic less frequently.
 
How could crossing a 3-lane signalized intersection be considered "hellish"?
Standing on a sidewalk as cars whizz by at high speed isn't pleasant. Give it a shot sometime.

I think the minimum number of lanes one can cross if crossing at Wyse and the bridge is seven, but I might be wrong.

Until the construction got underway there were pedestrian islands midway across so it would be in no way difficult.
Great, cars driving by at great speed on all sides of you, with nothing to protect you if anything were to go wrong.

As for being "pedestrian-friendly", while the planning dogma of course requires that, it makes no sense if there are no destinations for pedestrians to visit. As of now the only thing is the poorly-sited transit terminal requiring a challenging hike to the top of a hill.
There's a hotel, a shopping centre, a sportsplex, and the weekend I was there there was some kind of exhibition/carnival thing going on. All great things for pedestrians to visit and use if the intersection and roads were more enticing to them. I don't think many of the cars using the intersection were going to any of these locations.
 
There's a hotel, a shopping centre, a sportsplex, and the weekend I was there there was some kind of exhibition/carnival thing going on. All great things for pedestrians to visit and use if the intersection and roads were more enticing to them. I don't think many of the cars using the intersection were going to any of these locations.

The road network is poorly connected too, with all of the car traffic for the destinations being mixed in with the bridge traffic as a result. For example if you are going to Metropolitan Place you have to go from the Wyse Road side. There are no connections from the Windmill Road side. But Windmill Road has 4 lanes and 2 streets that could connect to Metropolitan Place yet dead end.
 
Standing on a sidewalk as cars whizz by at high speed isn't pleasant. Give it a shot sometime.

Great, cars driving by at great speed on all sides of you, with nothing to protect you if anything were to go wrong.


Give it a shot sometime? As a life-long Dartmouthian, and having worked in Metropolitan Place for a total of nine years (in two separate stints), I've crossed there as a pedestrian in all directions over many decades countless (literally) times. It can be a pain in the ass because of the duration of the lights, but apart from that, I'd have to say it's no big deal...unless one is unusually timid or prone to hyperbole.

Plus, there are medians to break up the crossing. You're never crossing seven contiguous lanes.

The truly dangerous crosswalk in the area is the (ironically) well-marked and lighted mid-block one between the Sportsplex and Metropolitan Place. It's sheer dumb luck nobody's been killed there. HRPS could camp out there and easily issue 100 failure-to-yield-to-a-pedestrian-in-a-crosswalk tickets on any given weekday - probably before noon.
 
Last edited:
Standing on a sidewalk as cars whizz by at high speed isn't pleasant. Give it a shot sometime.
I don't necessarily agree with this. I've walked in this area - to me, the most heinous part of the experience was how far back things are from the sidewalk - to get from sidewalk to grocery store, for example, there's a not-insignificant parking lot to get through/past. I don't think the speed or volume of traffic is an impediment (at least they weren't to me).

There's a hotel, a shopping centre, a sportsplex, and the weekend I was there there was some kind of exhibition/carnival thing going on. All great things for pedestrians to visit and use if the intersection and roads were more enticing to them. I don't think many of the cars using the intersection were going to any of these locations.
I DO agree with this, however. If things were a little more thoughtfully done, it would make a difference to both car drivers and walkers/wheeled pedestrians.
 
Plus, there are medians to break up the crossing. You're never crossing seven contiguous lanes.
Do you recommend standing in the medians between walk signals (ie, in between three lanes on one side and three lanes on the other)? I can't imagine that being very fun.

Also, my post wasn't directed at you specifically, so I don't understand why you took it so personally.
 
Do you recommend standing in the medians between walk signals (ie, in between three lanes on one side and three lanes on the other)? I can't imagine that being very fun.

The only un-fun part is being next to the panhandlers, since that is where they all stand to ply their trade. Haven't seen too many of them hit by rogue motorists.
 
By reboot I mean rebuilding the area so it is more urban and less car oriented, with fewer lanes and little to no surface parking. This does not mean eliminating vehicle traffic or structured parking.

There will be car traffic but it is a 3 lane bridge. The city could build 16 lanes leading up to the bridge and the throughput would still be determined by the 3 lane bottleneck on the bridge. The other paths around there on the Dartmouth side generally rapidly turn into small 2 lane streets. In the 70's there were plans to incorporate this part of town into an expressway project: https://samaustin.ca/redesigning-prince-albert-road/. This is not surprising to me at all and seems to explain some of the inconsistent roadways. A lot of the overbuilt roadways around the city date from this era and because the networks were not completed they do not make sense in terms of efficient land use.

I haven't used this route as a commute in many years so I'm open to correction if things have changed, but I would think if anything demand has increased as Halifax and surrounding communities continue to grow. The point is, traffic is increasing while bridge capacity hasn't, since the extra reversing lane was installed.

When I commuted by the Macdonald, there were long lines of traffic on all adjacent routes waiting to get onto the bridge. The unused lanes tended to allow those who weren't going over the bridge to still traverse the neighbourhood. If you remove lanes while keeping traffic volume and bridge limitations the same, aren't you just getting longer lines and more clogged streets? How is this good for anyone?

I think it's easy to put on the blinders and default to the standard urban themes, but it's important to remember that this area is still a major traffic route between the cities and it's not likely to change soon.

IMHO, it's transit that needs rebooting, not the traffic lanes. There is already plenty of unused capacity for bicycles, so I don't see bicycle traffic jams being an issue anytime soon.

Adding a third crossing, which has been discussed ad nauseam, wouldn't be a bad idea either - though I don't expect to see it happen in my lifetime, to be frank.
 
Standing on a sidewalk as cars whizz by at high speed isn't pleasant. Give it a shot sometime.

I think the minimum number of lanes one can cross if crossing at Wyse and the bridge is seven, but I might be wrong.


Great, cars driving by at great speed on all sides of you, with nothing to protect you if anything were to go wrong.

FWIW, I don't find crossing the street to be all that unsettling. If it's a signalled crossing you can very easily watch for cars coming at you and assess your risk as you cross with the signal. I think it's much less risk than other activities that we participate in, such as cycling on city streets.


There's a hotel, a shopping centre, a sportsplex, and the weekend I was there there was some kind of exhibition/carnival thing going on. All great things for pedestrians to visit and use if the intersection and roads were more enticing to them. I don't think many of the cars using the intersection were going to any of these locations.

As I mentioned in my other post above, this is a major traffic route, and one of only two ways to drive between Halifax and Dartmouth (without going the 'long way'), so of course most of those people were not going to the Sportsplex or the shopping centre. This concept is not unique to Wyse Road or Nantucket, there are many other large busy roads in Metro and the suburbs, where most users are just trying to get somewhere and are not there to visit the local establishments.
 
My solution to tons of cars lining up at rush hour to cross would be the raise the toll to the point where the rush hour demand roughly matches what the bridge can actually handle. The tolls have not even kept up with inflation. They last went from 75 cents to $1 in 2011 and 75 cents was the rate set in 1992. The added revenues would enable more bridge construction. I would also get rid of the toll booths and switch to an automated system which would probably save some money. They have been use in many other places for years.

It's similar to how parking pricing should be set such that there are always a few free spaces.

For what it's worth though my idea of redesigning this area has more to do with removing the pseudo-highway and "stroad" aspects than lanes for people using the bridge. I think a stronger distinction between bridge through traffic (e.g. you decide if you are going on the bridge when Wyse first fans out, with no later lane changes) and local traffic would probably be a net win. I believe the current road network around there is the semi-random result of a bunch of iterative changes made over many years with an eye to connecting to an expressway system that never materialized, so a lot of seemingly car-oriented infrastructure there is not actually very helpful even to motorists.
 
Do you recommend standing in the medians between walk signals (ie, in between three lanes on one side and three lanes on the other)? I can't imagine that being very fun.

I hope you're being facetious, but if not - no, of course not, not between signals. I just meant that it gives you a chance to pause momentarily and check to see that your way remains clear before you start crossing the third or fourth lane. That you don't have to cross seven in a row, that's all.

Also, my post wasn't directed at you specifically, so I don't understand why you took it so personally.

I didn't take it personally in the least and I'm sorry if my post made it seem that way. I was simply stating my opinion from the perspective of someone who has made those pedestrian crossings (I believe) more often than most of the posters here.
 
Last edited:
My solution to tons of cars lining up at rush hour to cross would be the raise the toll to the point where the rush hour demand roughly matches what the bridge can actually handle. The tolls have not even kept up with inflation. They last went from 75 cents to $1 in 2011 and 75 cents was the rate set in 1992.

I'm absolutely with you on that, but toll increases are a very, very touchy subject with the public around here. Raise them by even a nickel and every TD&H comes out of the woodwork screaming "we've paid for those effing bridges ten times over already" and "they should be part of the highway system and covered by our taxes". The former is a particularly bone-headed reaction which ignores the fact that someone has to pay to operate and maintain the damn things. The latter scares the bejeezus out of me because I've seen the state of provincially-maintained highways and bridges in this province and shudder to think what would happen to the HH bridges were they under provincial control. At least the user-pay model we have now ensures dedicated attention and maintenance - which is also largely free of (party) political considerations.

I think if you can't absorb a toll increase in pace with inflation, you probably can't truly afford to operate a vehicle in the first place anyway. But if that crowd saw the tolls charged on similar bridges elsewhere in North America they'd probably stroke out.

I would also get rid of the toll booths and switch to an automated system which would probably save some money. They have been use in many other places for years.

I believe the bridge commission has stated that that's their fairly near-term objective.
 
I think if you can't absorb a toll increase in pace with inflation, you probably can't truly afford to operate a vehicle in the first place anyway. But if that crowd saw the tolls charged on similar bridges elsewhere in North America they'd probably stroke out.

It's not really about a money grab, or it doesn't need to be. The revenues can be diverted elsewhere, maybe improving the infrastructure in the long run, bridge or transit. I question if in the long run a model where large numbers of people drive over the Macdonald bridge in their private vehicles at rush hour will make sense. I think this is more reasonable on the MacKay which is not in the urban core and has semi-coherent freeway connections.

And there are alternatives: bus, ferry, walking, or biking.

That being said around here we had tolls eliminated (tolls collected by reading license plates automatically) and the bridges are a complete shit show outside of smaller and smaller windows of time. It has really reduced the quality of life here because getting out of town is difficult and there are tons of accidents due to stops and starts on highway-like routes. It seems everyone I know who drives has been rear-ended at one time or another by a distracted driver. So NS is not alone in enacting nonsensical populist transportation policies.
 
No, of course not. I was agreeing with you on all points. I'm just saying the irrational masses around here erupt in righteous fury over the matter of bridge tolls. It can be quite comical, actually.

I agree too. Just adding to it. I do think it's poorly communicated and misunderstood. You can have market-clearing prices or you can fix artificially low prices and pay some other way, through shortages or in this case congestion.

The rent discussion feels similar with "greedy landlords" and "greedy developers". That's just not a good first-order approximation of how the system works. Sellers bid down prices and buyers bid up prices. If you're greedy and you charge $3,000 for an apartment but somebody else has another identical one for $1,000 yours goes empty and you get $0. And the big commercial landlords, the biggest villains of all, probably do the best job of maximizing occupancy. Meanwhile there are still city councillors voting to saw off floors from new buildings, in some cases the same ones who say they are concerned about homelessness and housing affordability.
 
My solution to tons of cars lining up at rush hour to cross would be the raise the toll to the point where the rush hour demand roughly matches what the bridge can actually handle. The tolls have not even kept up with inflation. They last went from 75 cents to $1 in 2011 and 75 cents was the rate set in 1992. The added revenues would enable more bridge construction. I would also get rid of the toll booths and switch to an automated system which would probably save some money. They have been use in many other places for years.

It's similar to how parking pricing should be set such that there are always a few free spaces.

For what it's worth though my idea of redesigning this area has more to do with removing the pseudo-highway and "stroad" aspects than lanes for people using the bridge. I think a stronger distinction between bridge through traffic (e.g. you decide if you are going on the bridge when Wyse first fans out, with no later lane changes) and local traffic would probably be a net win. I believe the current road network around there is the semi-random result of a bunch of iterative changes made over many years with an eye to connecting to an expressway system that never materialized, so a lot of seemingly car-oriented infrastructure there is not actually very helpful even to motorists.

Those are all good points, and I'd be happy if that was the actual direction in which this was going.

One point though, I may be wrong on this, but just like rising gas prices not dissuading people from driving, I don't think nominal toll increases would stop people from using the bridge to commute with their vehicles. Most would grumble and complain about it, but then just cough it up and continue along. So while the increase in revenue would be great, I suspect the bridge would still be at overcapacity. Maybe raise it to $20 per crossing and that might force people to not use it, though they'd probably just come in by the 102 instead...

Edit: And it would be disingenuous of me if I didn't add that I don't ever agree with artificially raising costs for the public just to dissuade them from doing something the government doesn't want them to do. Sure, raise the tolls to cover costs, but do not add tax designed to make their lives difficult so that they choose a less-desirable option. It's an tactic that I often see the cycling activists bringing up and frankly I see it as bad ethics. In a free democratic a society such as ours, let's let people make decisions for themselves - i.e. make the concept of using transit so attractive to them that they want to use it. Which means make it efficient and convenient. I will always hate the mindset of wanting to force people to do something less desirable (like use slow, packed, inefficient buses, or ride a bicycle) just because it fits into a small group's value system and they want to force the rest of the population to abide by it.
 
Last edited:
In 2019 almost 33 million passenger vehicles crossed the 2 bridges. More buses are not the answer. More ferries are not the answer. In 1971 the number was 10.9 million.
 
I think if you can't absorb a toll increase in pace with inflation, you probably can't truly afford to operate a vehicle in the first place anyway. But if that crowd saw the tolls charged on similar bridges elsewhere in North America they'd probably stroke out.



I believe the bridge commission has stated that that's their fairly near-term objective.

Yes, this is in planning phase for a while now. Last year's replacement of the Macpass readers was the start. Complete replacement is 3-5 years away. And after that, redecking or replacement of the Mackay is next major project, in 10-15 years.
 
Yes, this is in planning phase for a while now. Last year's replacement of the Macpass readers was the start. Complete replacement is 3-5 years away. And after that, redecking or replacement of the Mackay is next major project, in 10-15 years.

Would this future MacKay project include a median divider, a fifth reversible car lane, active transportation link, and/or bus lanes? I think if you can't get 2-3 of those from a redecking, a totally new or retrofitted structure is worth the cost.
 
Would this future MacKay project include a median divider, a fifth reversible car lane, active transportation link, and/or bus lanes? I think if you can't get 2-3 of those from a redecking, a totally new or retrofitted structure is worth the cost.

Adding lanes by re-decking likely isn't possible, due to width of the towers. Adding a median also isn't likely, as it would make it impossible to vehicles to cross in the event of lane closures or collisions.
 


Back
Top