Development Rumours


Those planning requirements you cite strike me as far too much of an exercise in micromanagement. No wonder our taxes are so high if this is what planners spend their time doing all day.

Well - I think that planners probably don't do enough of this.

Or enough processing permits and proposals, to be honest.
 
Those planning requirements you cite strike me as far too much of an exercise in micromanagement. No wonder our taxes are so high if this is what planners spend their time doing all day.

As a practicing planner (not in HRM), I'm not sure whether to be insulted or insulted. Glad to know that someone who firmly understands the science of planning is making an informed comment *rolls eyes*.

I will admit, I'm not an urban designer, that's not my background. But HbD isn't just about facilitating large scale buildings but ensuring that when large scale buildings are developed, if there is a small scale building next to it, the relationship doesn't cause problems. Put yourself in the shoes of someone in a 2 storey house/building and then something like Trillium goes up next to you. That's quite imposing.

A planners job is to look not only at what the future of a site will be but what will the current use of a site is and the relationships are between them. And I'd love to hear the half baked idea you are going to come up with on how the work planners do has your taxes so how...I'll go pop the popcorn in preparation.
 
Well - I think that planners probably don't do enough of this.

Or enough processing permits and proposals, to be honest.
Actually in HRM, I planners don't process the permits. That's what a development tech does. Planners do the development agreements though (that facilitate the ability to apply for a development permit).

Fenwick> Can you PM me with information on sketch up? How much did your copy cost? I'm thinking of getting a copy and if you have some information, that would be helpful!
 
As a practicing planner (not in HRM), I'm not sure whether to be insulted or insulted. Glad to know that someone who firmly understands the science of planning is making an informed comment *rolls eyes*.

I will admit, I'm not an urban designer, that's not my background. But HbD isn't just about facilitating large scale buildings but ensuring that when large scale buildings are developed, if there is a small scale building next to it, the relationship doesn't cause problems. Put yourself in the shoes of someone in a 2 storey house/building and then something like Trillium goes up next to you. That's quite imposing.

A planners job is to look not only at what the future of a site will be but what will the current use of a site is and the relationships are between them. And I'd love to hear the half baked idea you are going to come up with on how the work planners do has your taxes so how...I'll go pop the popcorn in preparation.

I'm talking about this sort of thing:

High-Rise Buildings

(7) Any portion of a high-rise building above a height of 33.5 metres shall be setback 11.5 metres from interior lot lines.
(8) Any portion of a high-rise building above a height of 33.5 metres shall be separated a minimum of 17 metres between the high-rise portion of other buildings or the same building on the same lot, where one of the high-rise buildings is used for commercial purposes.
(9) Any portion of a high-rise building above a height of 33.5 metres shall be a minimum of 23 metres between the high-rise portion of other buildings or the same building on the same lot, where both of the high-rise buildings are used for residential purposes.
(10) Any portion of a building above a height of 33.5 metres shall be a maximum width of 38 metres and a maximum depth of 38 metres.
(11) Notwithstanding subsection (10) any portion of a building above a height of 33.5 metres located in the Central Blocks, as identified on Map 8, shall be a maximum width of 38 metres and a maximum depth of 27.5 metres.

Precinct 3: Spring Garden Road Area

(3) On the south side of Spring Garden Road, between Queen Street and South Park Street, and on the east side of South Park Street between Spring Garden Road and Sackville Street, above a height of 17 metres measured at the streetline, buildings shall be setback an additional 0.9 metres from the streetline, for every 0.6 metres in height.

Why 0.9 meters and 0.6 meters, for just one example? Why not 1 and .5 or whatever? Same with all the rest of the numbers. They seem totally arbitrary. If a building doesn't meet these exactly why would it be rejected if it was otherwise outstanding? Seems to me the guidelines ought to describe what is desired, not prescribe such rigid dimensions.
 
I'm talking about this sort of thing:

Why 0.9 meters and 0.6 meters, for just one example? Why not 1 and .5 or whatever? Same with all the rest of the numbers. They seem totally arbitrary. If a building doesn't meet these exactly why would it be rejected if it was otherwise outstanding? Seems to me the guidelines ought to describe what is desired, not prescribe such rigid dimensions.

I can't speak to why those specific numbers were chosen. My experience is we choose numbers not no a random spinning of the wheel but on qualitative research. When I worked on rules for low density residential housing, we didn't just make a random pick of numbers. We went through permit records, sifted through data and did calculations and modeling of what would happen if we changed a rule.

I can only assume that those numbers were derived from evaluating historical development in the downtown area and looking at all of these requirements. I'd also point out that a zoning system is all about absolute numbers; the same as any other regulatory framework. Imagine if a speed limit was a guideline - you can drive 50, or roughly that. really!? No...it's 50. If you are over, your are over. If you are under, you are okay. That's the way a zoning system (and any regulatory system works). This just happens to be one that is more focused on creating a building envelope with a design emphasis, versus the typical box. This system puts more regulation in place to control design.

Regardless of the regulation - there is also the process of a variance, which the applicant can seek. They can ask for one or more relaxations (variances) to the bylaw rules if they can ensure the test in the HRM charter is met. I'm still waiting for the part about the taxes, since my popcorn is now popped.
 
I'm not sure of the actual dimensions of Spring Garden Road, but I think the setback requirements are based on a ratio of street wall height to street width. I remember hearing that this ratio is slightly different for Spring Garden than other parts of the Peninsula, although the Centre Plan uses this principle too (again I think the ratios are slightly different for different streets). The main goal is to preserve sunlight penetration, I think.
 
One problem with guidelines open to interpretation is you get an "I'll know it when I see it" type of planning regime where developers have to invest a lot of time and money up-front to come up with designs that are then arbitrarily rejected or accepted based on a flexible interpretation of the planning rules. The MPS is pretty bad for this.

That being said I think the quantitative requirements that do exist should be directly derived from real requirements in terms of sunlight, etc. The street ratio requirements are real. Some of the old density limits (and probably a lot of the new HRM by Design ones, really) basically appear to be made up.
 
Fenwick> Can you PM me with information on sketch up? How much did your copy cost? I'm thinking of getting a copy and if you have some information, that would be helpful!

The Sketchup version that I use is the free, legal version that you can download from this website - http://www.sketchup.com/intl/en/download/index.html. I believe it contains all of the functions of the more costly "Pro" version but doesn't contain all the file import and export options, which you probably won't need.

I have been using 3D computer CAD modelling for over 10 years and the Sketchup version is much more user-friendly than 3D computer modelling software that costs a few thousand dollars per licence. It doesn't contain all the features of engineering 3D modelling software but has been designed to be fun and easy to use.
 
One problem with guidelines open to interpretation is you get an "I'll know it when I see it" type of planning regime where developers have to invest a lot of time and money up-front to come up with designs that are then arbitrarily rejected or accepted based on a flexible interpretation of the planning rules. The MPS is pretty bad for this.

That being said I think the quantitative requirements that do exist should be directly derived from real requirements in terms of sunlight, etc. The street ratio requirements are real. Some of the old density limits (and probably a lot of the new HRM by Design ones, really) basically appear to be made up.

But doesn't HRM by Design do this sort of arbitrary "know it when I see it" business thanks to the existence of a Design Review Committee? I have found some of their pronouncements to be rather alarming and some of the members seem to be nothing more than a few local busybodies who think they know better than those investing the money what we should have built in this city. I frankly find them to be a total waste and another of the many flaws within HRMbD.
 
I can't speak to why those specific numbers were chosen. My experience is we choose numbers not no a random spinning of the wheel but on qualitative research. When I worked on rules for low density residential housing, we didn't just make a random pick of numbers. We went through permit records, sifted through data and did calculations and modeling of what would happen if we changed a rule.

I'm still waiting for the part about the taxes, since my popcorn is now popped.

You made my point with the first section quoted in bold. All that work wasn't done for free. Presumably some group of planning bureaucrats did a lot of work and spent a lot of time researching and developing all this stuff. That doesn't happen for free. I question the value of spending tax dollars on that kind of minutiae.
 
You made my point with the first section quoted in bold. All that work wasn't done for free. Presumably some group of planning bureaucrats did a lot of work and spent a lot of time researching and developing all this stuff. That doesn't happen for free. I question the value of spending tax dollars on that kind of minutiae.

Someone should be paid to understand the impacts of different forms of development and then be able to apply them to a model of the city's form in order to put forward reasonable rules. I don't think that, on the one hand, we should ask for logical reasons for planning rules and then, on the other hand, ask that the time not be taken to develop the logic.
 
Here is a nice shot of that corner (including a 3D Christmas projection thing). A ~33m building to step it up would be sweet.

B97117385Z.120121206195228000GLQ1T5LS.11.jpg


http://thechronicleherald.ca/busine...ection-lights-up-streetscape-on-spring-garden
 
You made my point with the first section quoted in bold. All that work wasn't done for free. Presumably some group of planning bureaucrats did a lot of work and spent a lot of time researching and developing all this stuff. That doesn't happen for free. I question the value of spending tax dollars on that kind of minutiae.

Each development is going to have a different impact on the surrounding context, the neighbouring properties, etc. To say that it will have the same impact simply isn't so, so in order to minimize that effect there has to be some minutiae to deal with. Fortunately, just as there is a rule - there is a mechanism to varry the rule, should the applicant be able to meet the tests in the charter.
 
I actually like the eastlink building - I think it's been fixed up well with good colour, and its character among the mix of buildings makes the block more interesting.
Now, of course I would still prefer for the lot to be integrated for the greater good of the corner - my ideal would be a fairly large-radius sweeping corner that would act as a sort of bridge between SGR and the new activity on South Park, and also as a more pronounced 'grand entrance' to the denser retail area of SGR. Doesn't look like that's going to happen though.
 


Back
Top