Development Rumours


There shouldn't be a height limit there at all! Build up!!!

There are fairly decent height limits proposed for that area if based on the Centre Plan. Here is an illustration of the proposed height limits for that area.

(source: http://www.halifax.ca/planhrm/documents/CentrePlanMeeting2Forum9-May-12.pdf )
heightlimitsyoungrobiec.jpg
 
Does anyone know what is going on at the former "Random Play" on Barrington? That store has been closed for a number of years, but recently they covered over the windows and there has been work going on inside.
 
There are fairly decent height limits proposed for that area if based on the Centre Plan. Here is an illustration of the proposed height limits for that area.

(source: http://www.halifax.ca/planhrm/documents/CentrePlanMeeting2Forum9-May-12.pdf )
heightlimitsyoungrobiec.jpg

The heights are pretty good in the area. But what they haven't done is decide on the former industrial/commercial land above the map (Kempt Road Corridor). That's the area I would want to see heights go way up (40+ if people really wanted to do it). But bonus the heck out of it, that way you can only go that high if a whole bunch of public benefits are provided (affordable/low income housing, community parks - that area would definately need it, community centre, etc.).

The other thing to consider with the regional centre height regulations is the building up of context. If the heights in the plan are achieved and the plan is looked at on a regular basis, there is nothing to say that things couldn't go higher in time. What I mean is: If the height of the area fenwick has shown tops out at 24 stories and say a bunch of buildings in the 18-24 storey range, you now have an context to say there are x number of buildings in that height range and huge demand - so increasing the height is warrented to pack more people in.

I call it the sneaky way of getting what you want - but just being patient enough to see it done over time. :)
 
The heights are pretty good in the area. But what they haven't done is decide on the former industrial/commercial land above the map (Kempt Road Corridor). That's the area I would want to see heights go way up (40+ if people really wanted to do it). But bonus the heck out of it, that way you can only go that high if a whole bunch of public benefits are provided (affordable/low income housing, community parks - that area would definately need it, community centre, etc.)

Yes, yes, yes!!! :cheers:

It would be a total dream come true to see out-of-character height rise throughout this area. It's much more likely to happen here than in the downtown.
 
Do we have a thread for this proposal? I know we have two on Isleville, but I don't think we had one for this.

Anyway, it's going for first reading December 10 at the new community council.
 
There was an article about the Spring Garden and South Park "L" building in ANS tonight. It was slightly confusing; on the one hand they talked about how construction may start soon but on the other they say that the developer has not yet filed any paperwork for approval under HbD. To me that suggests that construction is at least several months away. According to the article it's also possible for them to go up to 9 floors or approximately 29 meters (I guess that is a post-bonus height). Seems tall for such a small property, but it's not totally out of context given the Trillium and Lord Nelson. I do hope however that there will be some setbacks from SGR on the upper floors.

Neither the developer (Gregory Arab) nor the architect (Ron Smith of Studioworks) made a comment in the article. It would be nice to see some preliminary renderings and get a sense of when they plan to proceed.
 
There was an article about the Spring Garden and South Park "L" building in ANS tonight. It was slightly confusing; on the one hand they talked about how construction may start soon but on the other they say that the developer has not yet filed any paperwork for approval under HbD. To me that suggests that construction is at least several months away. According to the article it's also possible for them to go up to 9 floors or approximately 29 meters (I guess that is a post-bonus height). Seems tall for such a small property, but it's not totally out of context given the Trillium and Lord Nelson. I do hope however that there will be some setbacks from SGR on the upper floors.

Neither the developer (Gregory Arab) nor the architect (Ron Smith of Studioworks) made a comment in the article. It would be nice to see some preliminary renderings and get a sense of when they plan to proceed.

Hmm... I really hope the corner gets incorporated.

Go look at it on google streetview everybody... its back to the future! When you go through the intersection heading south on southpark one 3d shot is prior to the trillium construction with DQ and then when you cross through it becomes eastlink and the trillium pops out of the ground as well as the retirement home.

One thing that is so sad for Halifax is that when you street view down by the water is a sea of empty lots. Imagine 15-20 12+ story apartment buildings down there... downtown retail would thrive and nobody would need a car at all! If that were the case, we could have a few urban format grocery stores.
 
One thing that is so sad for Halifax is that when you street view down by the water is a sea of empty lots. Imagine 15-20 12+ story apartment buildings down there... downtown retail would thrive and nobody would need a car at all! If that were the case, we could have a few urban format grocery stores.

I agree, but I think something a lot of people overlook in the tower/no-tower discussion is that the real-estate market is small in Halifax. IT's not just restrictive zoning or viewplanes or anything that limits tall buildings—there aren't enough buyers to fill up a dozen 20-storey buildings in one location, especially if they're all put on the market at once. (That's yet another reason why Skye was a bizarre proposal.) If construction outpaces household formation, then boom, you've got a bubble. Welcome to Vancouver.

Most of the infill in Halifax right now is modest, 4 to 8-storey structures being built on parking lots and otherwise underused sites. That's what's economical around here, and to me, it's kind of exciting. We're urbanizing and infilling our existing streets and neighbourhoods, without a lot of heritage demolition, rather than creating an inhospitable sea of lookalike towers (as is happening in central Toronto right now).

I just hope the quality of design and architecture continues to improve, as it has in the past few years.
 
Last edited:
I agree, but I think something a lot of people overlook in the tower/no-tower discussion is that the real-estate market is small in Halifax.
Most of the infill in Halifax right now is modest, 4 to 8-storey structures being built on parking lots and otherwise underused sites. That's what's economical around here, and to me, it's kind of exciting.

I think that's a myth. There could be affordable rental properties that would divert the amount of people from paying some suburban rents because there aren't many apartments downtown. Clayton park has a number of buildings that would contribute to densities if they were downtown.

The reality: the bigger rental projects have been held back by red tape in instances where the developer has the capacity to build and also the ambiguity in the policy environment in general.

People are building 4-8 story structures because those are small-time developers for the most part or parts of a larger developer's development (e.g. Gladstone Ridge). Some of the bigger developers have even just started proposing just below new heights instead of being involved in trying to go 20 stories without a battle. Over 12 was a battle in Halifax 9 times out of 10 prior to HRMxDesign.
 
I think that's a myth. There could be affordable rental properties that would divert the amount of people from paying some suburban rents because there aren't many apartments downtown. Clayton park has a number of buildings that would contribute to densities if they were downtown.

The reality: the bigger rental projects have been held back by red tape in instances where the developer has the capacity to build and also the ambiguity in the policy environment in general.

Oh, no question that good, affordable inner-city projects would bring people in from the suburbs. But the market has no appetite for dozens of Gladstone Ridge–sized developments to crop up all of a sudden. The HRM added about 5,000 households between 2006 and 2011. Even if that number increases over the next census period thanks to an improving economy, a Gladstone Ridge-sized project has, what, 300-400 units? Unless we see a massive vacating of the 'burbs, we're not going to become a high-rise city. It's economics.

Besides, I genuinely believe that people would prefer to live in a six-storey building than a 30-storey building. There are so many strip malls, industrial sites, and straight-up empty lots on the peninsula, especially in the north and west ends, that mid-rise infill could probably double (okay, that's a wild guess) the population with very little substantial demolition, and very few high-rises. I'm not against high-rises, BTW, not at all. Hopefully whatever gets built at the Skye/Twisted Sisters site is as tall as allowed by HRMxD, and is a great design. I just don't think large numbers of high-rises are the ideal development model for Halifax, right now.
 
the building on Alderney drive north of Belmont House has a construction fence around it. Looks like the roof might be in the process of being removed.
 
I don't know if I full believe in the 'bubble' idea. It has to do with more than just pure economics and supply and demand, it also has to do with the job market and population growth.

If the ship building contract gets signed in the next six months, then the demand for all forms of housing (singles, semis, condos, townhouses) will all go up because the ship yard will begin hiring and families, couples or even single people will begin flocking to HRM. While that would create a temporary 'blip' on a graph of demand vs supply, if a bunch of 20 storey buildings came on stream around that time I'm sure the units would get snapped up by various people moving here for work.

The thing to consider is that growth has been essentially isolated to the corridors and the vision of those corridors (unless the plan changes drastically when it gets to council) is between 6 to 24 stories in most areas (24 is mainly around the Bridge terminal and Kempt/Young).

That said I agree with the idea of using midrise infill on the peninsula to create what I like to call 'pop up density'. These smaller projects create little pockets of density (typically along major streets) that do help contribute to the overall population.

But I do agree that HbD has helped to improve the process. Certainly red tape has been identified as an issue by HRM staff in this report that was discussed yesterday. Outdated regulations don't help anyone.

But I think the economic growth in HRM is poised for some amazing change, with the ship building contract being the catalyst. It would become a snowball effect and if we do see offshore oil pick up (based on the investment, I can't see why something doesn't come along), we could be poised to be seeing a lot of growth. In which case, the market's ability to absorb 20+ storey towers won't be as problematic. Do I think we'll get to Calgary growth levels (which is rumored at 200 people a day moving here), I don't think so. But even if we got to half that, I worry that the current planning system doesn't have the capacity or capability of being able to deal with that volume. My comment is not meant as a slight on the planning staff, on the contrary I think they are doing a very good job. I just don't think there are enough planners and having outdated rules doesn't help.
 
I agree that there isn't enough demand in Halifax to justify building highrises on all empty lots in a reasonable amount of time. There isn't really that much land downtown though and land values are high there so it's a natural place for more highrises construction. There's also an advantage to having a diverse inventory of different housing types, whether we are talking about highrise, shorter buildings, rental vs. condo, etc.

Housing bubbles like in Vancouver are not caused by an oversupply of units relative to the household creation rate. If that were the only factor we'd see housing prices slowly fall and the rate of new construction would drop to some equilibrium point. The cause of Vancouver's high prices is a lack of construction relative to demand coupled with a steady injection of money from investors who believe that real estate prices will continue to skyrocket, giving them a good return when they flip the property. The value of housing here is based on imaginary future returns instead of its present value to residents; that's the bubble. Restrictions on new supply are another necessary part of the equation.
 
the building on Alderney drive north of Belmont House has a construction fence around it. Looks like the roof might be in the process of being removed.

drove by this morning, and the roof is indeed gone. I have not heard what is going there.
 
Besides, I genuinely believe that people would prefer to live in a six-storey building than a 30-storey building.

I don't agree. While you or someone you know may prefer to live in a six story building I'm sure you'd find no shortage of people who genuinely like the idea of living in and among tall buildings. The market has not been there in the past because it has not been allowed to be there because of the old town ways. It's starting to look like the medium city necessities are taking center stage. We are poised to be a medium sized city and the fact is we have to put people where they want to be and where it's efficient and sustainable to provide the city infrastructure.
 
I don't agree. While you or someone you know may prefer to live in a six story building I'm sure you'd find no shortage of people who genuinely like the idea of living in and among tall buildings.

You often see price increases of, say, $1000 per floor even in highrise buildings where the stacks of units have identical floorplans. In other words, people are willing to pay more just for the increased height.

Another advantage of the taller buildings is that they can support more amenities. I live in a larger condo complex and we have a swimming pool, hot tub, and club house. Some places have shared kayaks, or fibre optic networking, shared cars, security/concierge, or whatever else. A 6 storey building with 40 or 50 units can't afford those things unless it is very high end.

The good news is that we don't have to guess what people want, we can create flexible planning rules that allow people to vote with their wallets and buy the kind of housing they prefer.
 
There was an article about the Spring Garden and South Park "L" building in ANS tonight. It was slightly confusing; on the one hand they talked about how construction may start soon but on the other they say that the developer has not yet filed any paperwork for approval under HbD. To me that suggests that construction is at least several months away. According to the article it's also possible for them to go up to 9 floors or approximately 29 meters (I guess that is a post-bonus height). Seems tall for such a small property, but it's not totally out of context given the Trillium and Lord Nelson. I do hope however that there will be some setbacks from SGR on the upper floors.

Neither the developer (Gregory Arab) nor the architect (Ron Smith of Studioworks) made a comment in the article. It would be nice to see some preliminary renderings and get a sense of when they plan to proceed.

I am not sure where the 95 feet high mentioned in the story comes from since the post-bonus height for this site is 49 meters and the pre-bonus height is 38 meters. However, the height will be limited by the setback requirements.

A low-rise building (18.5 meters or less) can cover 100% of a lot, however mid-rise and high-rise buildings would require setbacks from all interior lot lines. In the case of the L-shaped lot, 4 of the 6 sides are interior lot lines and would require setbacks over a height of 18.5 meters. It might be possible to build as high as 33.5 meters (mid-rise) since interior lot line setbacks as small as 10% of the lot width are permissible. However, for a high-rise (over 33.5 meters) 11.5 meter setbacks from the interior lot lines are required and the width of the lot is less than 11 meters (so the setback requirements cannot be met).

These are the applicable setback requirements from the Downtown Halifax Land Use By-Law - https://www.halifax.ca/capitaldistrict/documents/DHLUBandDesignManual.pdf

Streetwall: Stepbacks

(7) The following minimum stepbacks above the streetwall shall apply to buildings with streetwall setback requirements of 0 to 1.5 metres or 0 to 4.0 metres as identified on Map 6:
(a) a minimum of 3 metres for that portion of a building that is a maximum of 33.5 metres in height; or
(b) a minimum of 4.5 metres for that portion of a building that is greater than 33.5 metres in height.

Building Setbacks and Stepbacks

Low-Rise Buildings


10.
(1) No setback is required from an interior lot line for a low-rise building or the lowrise portion of a building.
(2) With the exception of required streetwall setbacks, a low-rise building or the lowrise portion of a building is permitted to cover 100% of the lot upon which it is situated.
(3) On lots located outside of Central Blocks, as identified on Map 8, a low-rise building or the low-rise portion of a building may be setback from interior lot lines no more than 20% of the lot width.

Mid-Rise Buildings

(4) Above a height of 18.5 metres, or the height of the streetwall, the mid-rise portion of a building shall be setback from interior lot lines no less than 10% of the lot width or 5.5 metres, whichever is less. Where a lot has more than one streetline, the greater lot width shall apply.
(5) The mid-rise portion of a building shall not project beyond the vertical plane of the exterior walls of the low-rise portion of the building.

Mid-Rise Buildings: Central Blocks


(6) Notwithstanding subsection (4), no setback is required from an interior lot line for the mid-rise portion of any building on Central Blocks as identified on Map 8.

High-Rise Buildings

(7) Any portion of a high-rise building above a height of 33.5 metres shall be setback 11.5 metres from interior lot lines.
(8) Any portion of a high-rise building above a height of 33.5 metres shall be separated a minimum of 17 metres between the high-rise portion of other buildings or the same building on the same lot, where one of the high-rise buildings is used for commercial purposes.
(9) Any portion of a high-rise building above a height of 33.5 metres shall be a minimum of 23 metres between the high-rise portion of other buildings or the same building on the same lot, where both of the high-rise buildings are used for residential purposes.
(10) Any portion of a building above a height of 33.5 metres shall be a maximum width of 38 metres and a maximum depth of 38 metres.
(11) Notwithstanding subsection (10) any portion of a building above a height of 33.5 metres located in the Central Blocks, as identified on Map 8, shall be a maximum width of 38 metres and a maximum depth of 27.5 metres.

There is also an additional setback requirement for this area. This might be why 95 feet (29 meters) is the maximum achievable height.

Precinct 3: Spring Garden Road Area

(3) On the south side of Spring Garden Road, between Queen Street and South Park Street, and on the east side of South Park Street between Spring Garden Road and Sackville Street, above a height of 17 metres measured at the streetline, buildings shall be setback an additional 0.9 metres from the streetline, for every 0.6 metres in height.

Just for fun (this is not the owner's real proposal), I followed all the stepback requirements and streetwall heights required by HRM_by_Design and I got the following building shape (below), Since adjacent buildings may be redeveloped in the future, it wouldn't be sensible to have windows on the interior walls so these might have to be blank.

1485southparkstreetspri.jpg


What a difference in form could occur if the EastLink building were incorporated (many more windows could be incorporated).

1485southparkstreeteast.jpg
 
Last edited:
Those planning requirements you cite strike me as far too much of an exercise in micromanagement. No wonder our taxes are so high if this is what planners spend their time doing all day.
 
What they could do is build a straight tower at the highest setback and then do a nice podium up to the street. It would actually be nice if the eastlink building area was open in front in a way similar to the trillium... sort of a little entrance pavillion.
 
...



Just for fun (this is not the owner's real proposal), I followed all the stepback requirements and streetwall heights required by HRM_by_Design and I got the following building shape (below), Since adjacent buildings may be redeveloped in the future, it wouldn't be sensible to have windows on the interior walls so these might have to be blank.

1485southparkstreetspri.jpg


What a difference in form could occur if the EastLink building were incorporated (many more windows could be incorporated).

1485southparkstreeteast.jpg

Nice work massing up the requirements - gotta say, I find the has more potential interest than having the whole corner.
 


Back
Top