I finally got a chance to see the new Les Sherman park LED lighting. It is much better than the old lights, but also a very poor execution of LED lighting. Particularly compared with how good the LED lighting is in Wascana Park.
https://imgur.com/a/stAnBbD
The Wascana Park lighting was clearly engineered by a company that knew what it was doing. The fixtures they picked light the ground very well without seeming very bright. There is a dimming between light poles, but not complete darkness. The light from LEDs covers a very well defined area. Manufacturers have specs for all their products. You pick a product to get the coverage you need based on pole height and spacing.
I think the city skipped that for the Les Sherman Park lights. The lights are super bright, subjectively I'd say 3-4x as bright as the Wascana Park lights, and there are totally dark spots between the lights as the lights don't appear to have a very good lateral throw. I wonder if they just picked the exact same fixture as the Pilot Butte Creek Pathway lighting project, those lights are mounted on much taller poles.
Also bizarrely they picked a 5000K light. Early LED adopters picked 5000K and it was universally hated. SaskPower picked 3000K for the streetlights as did Wascana Park for their path light.
The city is going to need to do a much better job if they are planning to start swapping out the rest of the old path lights in the city. I'll send my observations to them in hopes they don't blow a ton of money doing a half assed job in the other parks.