You've struck a rich vein with these cabinet cards,
e_r!
I don't believe the chopped-up house in the other photo is the same as this one, which shows a house that has just been
moved to the NWC of 10th and Hope from the NEC of Third and Broadway by Eugene Germain, after he'd bought it from
attorney Jackson Graves. Please note the palm trees (the one at left is being planted) and, in the left background, the
stable and little house to its right:
Quote:
Originally Posted by ethereal_reality
|
In this close-up from a Seaver Center photo we see the same house; the palm tree is planted and the rest of the landscaping
is complete. The same stable and small house are in the background. Also, what we can see of the house to the right of the
Graves/Germain home matches the cabinet card (if anyone heard a loud gasp a few days ago, that may have been me when
I first saw this image):
P-010-0131 @ Seaver Center
Here's the same photo from Graves' autobiography,
My Seventy Years in California (1927), though the date has to be 1889
or shortly after, not 1888:
Hathitrust
The right edge of this view, dated 1888, shows the front of the Graves home when it was at the NEC of Third and Fort/Broadway:
BEHR-0072 at CA State Library
It seems Graves, the Seaver Center, and whoever wrote on the back of the cabinet card all have the date wrong (Graves
also misremembers the house being moved to
Tenth and Hill). Here, the June 6, 1889,
Los Angeles Times reports that
Germain is preparing to move Graves' former home from Third and Fort/Broadway to Tenth and Hope:
ProQuest via LA Public Library
The
June 21, 1889,
Los Angeles Herald wrote that, "One of the most notable residences in Los Angeles eight or nine years
ago was that of J. A. Graves, Esq., on the corner of Fort and Third Streets. This house is now on wheels, and traveling down
Hill Street, beyond Sixth, on its way to a new site . . . ." So if they were preparing to move the house on June 6, and it was
at Sixth and Hill on June 21, I'd say the end of June 1889 would be a decent guess at the cabinet card's date.
And here's 953 S. Hope at lower right on the 1894 Sanborn Map, which mostly agrees with the photos:
Library of Congress
1891 Los Angeles City Directory:
fold3.com
Oh yeah almost forgot -- there are photos of the Graves/Germain house in both locations in this
Homestead Museum blog article.