Quote:
Originally Posted by dilliam
People are always mentioning "sense of scale", but honestly, I don't really understand what you mean. Can't you understand the scale of a building within the context of other buildings? Even though I don't mind them, I understand the gripes with all glass towers... the "scale" stuff is confusing, though.
|
Thanks for asking. Here's what I mean.
The Woolworth Building in New York is 792 feet tall. The John Hancock Building in Boston is 790 feet tall. So they're almost exactly the same height. But the Woolworth has a design made to look tall, and a big part of that design is a white building with clearly delineated windows.
https://2015.ctbuh.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/04/Woolworth_Overall2_MGa-769x1024.jpg
While Hancock is all glass of the same color. On Woolworth you can see each floor clearly, while on Hancock all you basically see is a monolith of blue glass. (In this picture you can see the lines between floors, but remember that you're looking at a still image on a bright, sunny day. Usually it just appears as one sheet of blue glass in real life. Still, every floor looks exactly the same.)
https://s3-production.bobvila.com/slides/21124/original/john_hancock_building.jpeg?1501005178
The sense of human scale comes to play when you remember that the average grown human is between 5-6 feet tall. So when you see the windows on Woolworth, you can see all those clearly delineated floors and imagine people on each floor, so it gives you a sense of how tall the building is. You can't do that so easily with an all glass building. Maybe at night when the lights are on, but that's pretty much it.
So when all glass buildings are added to skylines, it takes away part of that sense of grandeur because you lose the human scale. Look at New York City before and after the glass/box buildings were added. The old skyline was beautiful, grand and soaring.
https://farm3.staticflickr.com/2700/4083894465_30b7e76d34_z.jpg?zz=1
The new skyline... it has a bunch of boxes blocking the view of the older, more majestic skyscrapers.
https://d21xlh2maitm24.cloudfront.net/nyc/Brooklyn-Bridge-Park.jpg?mtime=20190620143027