Quote:
Originally Posted by micmiko
Since you like to cherrypick statistics to highlight shortcomings: YUL's total int'l pax in 2012 was 8,287,969 vs YVR's 8,199,365. This is easily searchable, it's the same whether you use Statcan or the airport authority's own numbers.
The moral of the story is that airports grow and shrink. YVR was third in the past and outgrew other airports within the past 10 years. Using pandemic numbers as some final indictment on YVR's future is clearly meaningless, but if you like seeing the glass half empty each day, that's your problem.
The problem isn't that YVR has shortcomings, which you like to continually bring up, but that comparing YUL or any other airport to YVR in the YVR thread achieves nothing useful. I am not going to base my flying decisions when I fly out of YVR on whether YUL has more international passengers, I am going to base it on which destinations YVR flies to and what amenities YVR offers. If I am flying internationally, I will 99% of the time fly out of YVR, YYZ or another non-Canadian international airport. I (and the majority of British Columbians) couldn't care less about any flights out of YUL unless I am flying specifically to Quebec.
It is really baffling how that is hard for some to understand. Does airport X coming in second or third really help you sleep at night?
Anyways, back to the YVR updates!
|
These airport comparison tend to miss the mark. The numbers don't matter to an air traveler. What matters is the traveler experience and the network you have access to. So if we want to do a comparison.....
Lounges - YVR has better lounge options in both the international, trans-boarder and domestic area.
Art work and engaging environments - YVR has better art work hands down. From fish tanks to play stations, YVR is just a more interesting airport to be a passenger at.
Transit - YVR has direct transit. YUL is on the way soon to have a direct metro connection.
Ground Transportation - YVR was late to the Uber thing, but now has a good setup. YUL was early to Uber, then decided they did not like Uber, then changed their mind.
Asia connections - YVR is much better.
European connections - Hands down YUL.
Food - Very subjective. I give this one to YUL for in-terminal and on-property. Off property YUL would also have it if they still had Le Beefteque on Cote-de-Liesse. However it is closed. With it gone, there is no reason to stay at any hotels near the airport . YVR has lots of Asian and seafood restaurants off property, and argument could be made. Even two on-property establishments with water side patios. It tough, but I will give to YUL.
Security - No question YVR is more friendly. The only airport where my half-empty 120 mL toothpaste has ever been confiscated in YUL. We don't need CASTA to be that diligent.
There you go YVR wins.