I don't know where everyone got the idea that New York was some kind of homeless-free miracle, but it definitely isn't - at least if you leave heavily-policed areas. The NY Times has run multiple articles about tent cities, like this one from August
https://www.nytimes.com/2021/08/02/nyregion/homeless-camps-relocate.html and the stats about the number of homeless people in NYC are depressing:
https://www.coalitionforthehomeless.org/basic-facts-about-homelessness-new-york-city/
That's an estimate of almost 50,000 homeless people
just in the shelter system in August. Not total. Not counting the people in tents on the street. And 122,000
different people over the last year in shelters. That's more people than live in Boulder.
Compare that to Denver articles from August
https://www.rmpbs.org/blogs/news/study-finds-drastic-increase-in-denverarea-homelessness/ that estimate about 5000 sheltered homeless people in Denver proper. That's still a lot of people, but 1/10th the NY estimate. Searching for totals and this comes up:
https://kdvr.com/news/local/denver-unsheltered-homeless-counts-almost-tripled-since-2014/ and it looks like they estimated about 6000 people last year. The unsheltered total has gone way up, BUT overall the numbers of homeless people for the metro area are waaaaaay lower. And that 100k in NYC looks like it is only for the 8 ½ million 5 boroughs. So that would be about 1/20th the homeless population for about ¼ of the population.
And it's not just us and the west coast and NYC. Just google "XXX city homeless population" and the first result is usually some news article or a non-profit trying to help. Our counts are low compared to a lot of places. Even Phoenix with their aggressive policies has 7000-something. Nashville has 20,000 homeless people?
Also, limited experiences within the little mini police states the NYPD has set up does not mean that reactionary "justice" will somehow make Denver safer again. Throwing the homeless in jail is more expensive than offering services. It would be cheaper to just build housing for them, because it costs us almost $40k a year to house someone in a prison
https://www.vera.org/publications/price-...15-state-spending-trends-prison-spending or about $3,300/month.
I think there are a few causes for homelessness that we as a society just refuse to do anything about. First, we have a housing crisis and our local governments would rather pander to people who prefer to keep things "the way they are now" than to really address the crisis. Secondly, and compounding that, is that we've built the economy around exploitative wages and a lot of working people struggle to afford to rent an apartment. For example, those striking janitors at DIA? The agreement they just signed would raise the
top-level pay to $21/hour. "TOP LEVEL PAY" and still not enough to afford to rent a "median" apartment according to
Apartment List. And third, our approaches to addiction and mental health services are mostly mediocre and trend towards the prohibitionary and masochistic. All three of these things contribute to our homeless problem and are brought up by advocates again and again and again.
And that's the worst part: instead of ever facing some of these issues
causing homelessness we're always talking about fighting the symptoms. Clearing camps, bringing in more police, hardening drug penalties, locking people up (or worse). None of these things have worked so far and they aren't going to work in the future if we don't begin to address the causes of homelessness in the first place.
For example, the camping ban made certain spaces safer but it didn't
stop people from camping, it didn't make the homeless go away just because they couldn't camp somewhere. It pushed the problem to other places, and if we just "clean up" downtown without addressing other issues, we're only going to shift the problem somewhere else (I would actually bet that a lot of the 16th street problem is because the junkies can't congregate at Civic Center any more, the same as Union Station got worse after they started policing the hill at Confluence more)
So to wrap up all this late night ranting: 1. I think we need significant systemic change to make this "better", and 2. it's not just a Denver problem