Quote:
Originally Posted by delts145
Around the time that The Austonian was built, I thought the Austin Skyline was going to be very attractive. I was particularly envious of the height that was being added. However, and perhaps this is Austin's least attractive angle, but the shot while dense is exactly what I hope Salt Lake avoids. That is the bland sameness of in-your-face residential towers. IMO, Vancouver's same mistake is even more exaggerated. I think L.A. or Seattle have evolved as much more attractive skylines. I hope Salt Lake City will continue to individualize its tower skin colors, material varieties, and window design arrangements in much the same way as Los Angeles. From the renderings, we're seeing right now with examples such as Kensington, Dakota Pacific, 95 S. State, Worthington, and 4th S. and W. Temple, there's an attractive mix developing. All Salt Lake needs now is to continue what it's doing, add a few towers mixed in that are in the 500-600 ft. range, and design a couple of creative crowns. Add Salt Lake's backdrop and it will easily have one of the prettiest skylines in No. America.
|
If Salt Lake continues doing what it's doing, it is unlikely to have a very strong skyline. The towers are even more generic than Austin's - as if they're out of a city builder simulator. And that's already on top of a skyline that is underwhelming due to its boxiness.
Really, we'd be lucky to look like Austin in a decade. I'd be thoroughly impressed if that was the case, as they've got a pretty significant, and diverse, skyline.
Unfortunately, Salt Lake doesn't. Worse, the towers that are being proposed don't change the overall issue with the skyline - the fact it has a table top effect and, maybe most egregious of all, it's pretty much flat atop ever single major skyscraper.
That latter point might not be too problematic if there was more diversity in the heights but it doesn't exist, which only accentuates that table top feel.
If Salt Lake continues doing what it's doing, namely putting out fairly generic tower proposals, what you claim to want to avoid is going to happen.
Look, I'm excited for a lot of these proposals but none of them are particularly great.