Quote:
Originally Posted by kemachs
Ok so we're celebrating Hines because they want to demolish a beautiful, historic part of Denver's fabric and build...another generic residential building? Now I see you live in the suburbs where most things are generic, and I suppose you'll call me a NIMBY for daring to challenge market forces, but I'm just bemoaning the fact that this town could give two shits about historic architecture. Everyone is always screaming about property rights and the almighty dollar - it's a libertarian's wet dream. If the owner of the Brown Palace wanted to demolish the building, would even that cross a 'property rights' line for you? Would you have celebrated the replacement of the Aladdin Theatre with a Walgreens, back in the 1980s?
|
I'll first start by saying that suburban/urban has nothing to do with an appreciation for historic buildings. I work for a company that has probably saved more dirty old historic buildings than any other company (at least locally) - so let's correct your condescending assumptions with that fact. I would consider myself well versed in historic preservation, both federal and at the state level (in numerous states) and have preserved many buildings, small and large, during my time. Simply put, there are things worth saving and there are things which should make way for progress. Carmen Court is one of the losers. Denver still has many structures worth saving, but folks confuse old buildings with historic preservation. Preservation is meant to maintain a significant piece of history, not a little 6-plex a rich Gates engineer built way back in the day to make a buck. The building had no notable architect, served no contextual purpose, and isn't prominent. Is it a cool aesthetic? Yes, but that's not what makes buildings historic. I really wish people would stop confusing old buildings with historic buildings and no, the Brown Palace is not comparable to Carmen Court.
I would encourage you to read the criterion for historic preservation on the national park service website. If, after, you familiarize yourself with the program and still feel Carmen Court is worth saving, well then so be it. If you put in the time to understand the process, you will understand this result. By the way, it takes a lot of time!