Quote:
Originally Posted by djh
I think "white flight" and socially mixed housing can be two completely separate issues. Correlation <> Causation.
Socially mixed housing can come in many forms, which I was advocating in my original post. It doesn't necessarily mean white and non-white. It also doesn't necessarily mean middle class and poor. It can be families mixed with seniors mixed with studio suites. It can be services for night-shift workers mixed with traditional office workers. It can be work-from-home live/work spaces with facilities (e.g., shared office spaces in bookable communal rooms and high-speed internet). There's many variations of socially-mixed buildings that encourage mixing, tolerance, support, and community.
None of these examples would contribute to "white flight". Far more likely to cause the middle class incumbents to get fed up and leave their neighbourhood is just seeing it change from what they knew and grew up with. Sticking tall buildings near single-family homes causes people to hate the change and disruption - not necessarily the people in it, whether they be millionaires or pensioners.
Either way, back to the original point, any multi-family building with just one type of resident is detrimental to a neighbourhood, whether the new residents are millionaires, pensioners, screaming kids or unemployed government assistance people. Developers and city planners definitely need to mix up the buildings, but smartly and not too much of any one group.
|
Why does anyone need to mix up anything?
Why doesn't the market just take care of the mixing aspect of things?
I don't like Yaletown. I don't live in Yaletown.
I like Coal Harbor. I cant afford Coal Harbor.
I like East Van, I can afford East Van. I live in East Van.
There - market making decisions for me, and I'm adjusting to the reality accordingly.
Why do we have to centrally plan the way people are allocated living quarters?
Also, in reference to the white flight, I don't think white flight happens because of people of different socio-economic status moving in, white flight happens when drug addicts and untreated mentally ill people get free reign of a neighborhood.
Those with the means choose to leave, as would be a the logical choice.