Quote:
Originally Posted by J.OT13
I liked the City's second attempt at the route with the shallow tunnel and "windows" to the river. I never understood why that was not satisfactory for the NCC. How is the new routing any better?
|
Good Day.
The new, or at least latest, routing, is no improvement at all.
The original was to have cut through a small piece of NCC to the southern edge from Dominion to and through Rochester Field up to Richmond/Byron Transit Corridor. This was the best option available for reasonable cost and less disruption to communities, and better catchment and destinations and TOD. It remains by definition the best routing of these options. But it sailed.
After the McKellar park screams and NCC objections, City revised to the next best, along the southern edge of NCC from Dominion to Cleary, in a half buried trench/tunnel/berm, with windows for view, ventilation, and emergency exit, with MUP on top for green space and minimal southside view disruption, and minimized disruption to the parkway roads, and minimizing the additional costs. It also minimized exposure to water table seepage and potential floodplain exposure, with those windows being on the upper degree of the tunnel walls, not down to the bottom of railbase.
Then Skead Rd. screamed, NCC still had (big) objections, and the whole thing went to the 100-day negotiation, report, and agreement (basically Heritage Canada and Cabinet told NCC to get it done), with the resultant full burial, Parkway roads re-alignment, and re-greening of the lands to the north of the roads to the river's edge. And greater costs yet again. And half-assed catchment.
And as a final point of fact, we do not yet know for absolute for sure that the RoW from Cleary (should be Sherbourne) to (Woodroffe, now) New Orchard will indeed be fully cut-and-cover buried. It is supposed to be, but.......sometimes things change, and ya knever know.
EnJoy!